Answer

The need for domain experts in civil services arises from the increasing complexity of governance. In 2019, lateral entry brought 9 private-sector professionals into senior roles, highlighting its potential. However, concerns about equity, accountability, and integration led to resistance. A hybrid model combining academia, industry, and civil services offers a balanced approach to address administrative challenges.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Need for Domain Experts in Civil Services

• Complex Governance Challenges: Issues like climate change and data security require specialized knowledge for effective decision-making.
  For example: The Data Empowerment and Protection Architecture (DEPA) framework by NITI Aayog was developed with tech experts to ensure secure data sharing and privacy protection in governance.
• Skill Gaps in Bureaucracy: Bureaucrats often lack specialized expertise in emerging fields such as AI and biotechnology, which can hinder effective policy-making and implementation.
  For example: The National Education Policy (2020) relied on Dr. K. Kasturirangan, a domain expert, for comprehensive reforms in the education sector.
• Improved Policy Innovation: Experts bring fresh perspectives and global insights, fostering innovative policy solutions.
  For example: The Digital India initiative was strengthened by private-sector IT professionals advising on cloud-based solutions and digital payments.
• Enhanced Public Service Delivery: Experts help design citizen-centric policies that are efficient and scalable.
  For example: Health professionals from AIIMS were critical in framing protocols for the Ayushman Bharat scheme’s efficient implementation.
• Increased Credibility of Policies: Incorporating domain expertise enhances public trust in governance by demonstrating professionalism.
  For example: The GST rollout benefited from inputs by top economists and tax professionals like Dr. Bibek Debroy, ensuring smoother implementation.
• Addressing Global Standards: Specialized knowledge ensures policies meet global benchmarks and improve India’s standing.
  For example: Experts in international trade negotiations enabled the India-UAE CEPA agreement, signed in 2022, enhancing economic ties.

Challenges of the Integrated Model

• Resistance from Bureaucracy: Fear of diminished roles and disruption of the cadre system creates institutional pushback.
  For instance: Lateral entry appointments in the Ministry of Commerce faced resistance from senior bureaucrats concerned about hierarchy.
• Equity Concerns: Lateral recruitment may bypass reservation norms, raising concerns about fairness and equal representation in public sector appointments.
• Integration Challenges: Cultural differences between sectors create barriers to effective collaboration, slowing progress and mutual understanding in joint initiatives.
  For instance: Corporate professionals inducted into government roles under lateral entry schemes reported difficulties in adjusting to the decision-making processes and rigid protocols of the public sector.
• Risk of Bureaucratic Fragmentation: Diverse work styles may challenge administrative cohesion, potentially affecting teamwork and decision-making efficiency.
  For example: In the Smart Cities Mission, disagreements between lateral hires and traditional bureaucrats over project implementation approaches caused delays in some cities.
• Risk of Favoritism: Unregulated lateral recruitment could lead to biased appointments, undermining meritocracy.

Opportunities Offered by the Integrated Model

• Enhanced Efficiency: Experts contribute practical insights that enhance the effectiveness and efficiency of policy-making and implementation.
  For instance: Economists in NITI Aayog used targeted data-driven approaches to improve outcomes in the Aspirational Districts Program.
• Innovative Solutions: Collaboration encourages innovative and creative solutions to address complex governance challenges effectively.
  For instance: PPP models in Smart Cities Mission enhanced urban infrastructure using domain expertise.
• Global Best Practices: Experts with international exposure can tailor successful global models to suit India’s unique socio-economic and cultural contexts.
  For instance: The reform of Indian Railways benefited from collaborations with experts involved in Japanese Shinkansen technology for the bullet train project.
• Skill Development in Bureaucracy: Cross-sector collaboration strengthens civil servants’ skills by exposing them to diverse perspectives and innovative practices.
  For instance: Training initiatives under Mission Karmayogi integrate skill-building in emerging technologies.
• Boost to National Competitiveness: Integration of experts aligns policies with global standards, enhancing India’s standing.
  For example: The PLI (Production Linked Incentive) scheme benefited from expert-designed frameworks to attract investment in electronics.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store

Way Forward

• Transparent Recruitment: Ensuring fairness by strictly adhering to reservation norms for underrepresented groups, while also maintaining a meritocratic approach to select the most qualified candidates.
  For instance: Open recruitment through UPSC, ensuring representation and merit, can address equity concerns.
• Capacity-Building Programs: Training lateral entrants and civil servants through joint programs to ensure seamless integration, enhance collaboration, and promote shared understanding of administrative processes.
• Clear Accountability Measures: Defining clear responsibilities for lateral hires and implementing regular performance audits to ensure accountability, effectiveness, and alignment with organizational goals.
  For instance: Periodic assessments by independent bodies like the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG).
• Small-Scale Pilots: Test the integrated model in sectors like education or health to evaluate its effectiveness, identify challenges, and refine implementation strategies before broader adoption.
  For instance: Pilots in the Ayushman Bharat Digital Health Mission can help identify potential issues, streamline processes, and ensure smoother scaling of the initiative nationwide.
• Institutional Support: Establish a dedicated body to oversee lateral recruitment and training, ensuring standardized processes, effective integration, and continuous professional development for recruits.

India’s governance must integrate domain expertise to address complex challenges and enhance service delivery. By ensuring equity, accountability, and seamless integration, a balanced model combining academia, industry, and civil services can enable transformative reforms, preparing India’s governance system for Vision 2047.