Nonprofit organizations and Indigenous groups are raising alarms over the proposed Tropical Forest Finance Facility (TFFF).
About Tropical Forest Finance Facility
- TFFF is a new financial scheme aimed at conserving tropical forests by paying countries for preserved or restored forest areas.
- The initiative is expected to launch at COP30 in Belem, Brazil, but critics argue it prioritizes profit over genuine conservation.
- It was proposed by Brazil, Indonesia, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo (home to 52% of the world’s rainforests).
- It is designed to complement other market-based approaches like REDD+, but does not create carbon credits.
About Tropical Forests
- Tropical forests are rich ecosystems found in tropical zones surrounding the equator.
- They cover about six percent of Earth’s land surface area.
- These forests feature a dense upper canopy of broad-leafed trees.
- Despite their lush appearance, they have nutrient-poor soils with rapid decomposition.
- More than 50 percent of all land-based plant and animal species on Earth live in tropical forests.
- Tropical forests include both tropical rainforests and tropical deciduous forests:
- Tropical rainforests thrive in areas where temperatures remain high year-round and annual rainfall exceeds 1,800–2,500 mm (70–100 inches.
- Tropical deciduous forests grow in similarly hot regions, but with annual rainfall between 800–1,800 mm and a distinct dry season.
- Brazil is home to about a third of the planet’s remaining tropical rainforests, including two-thirds of the Amazon rainforest.
- Tropical forests play a critical part in the planet’s water cycle and are crucial carbon sinks, storing about a quarter of all terrestrial carbon on Earth.
|
Key Concerns About the TFFF
- Lack of Transparency: The TFFF’s financial backers and operational details remain unclear.
- Indigenous Exclusion: Indigenous communities who are key forest protectors, are sidelined in decision-making.
- Unstable Funding & Financial Risks: The promised $4/hectare/year payments aren’t guaranteed and could shrink if investments underperform raising sustainability concerns.
- Forests Treated as Profit Sources: By monetizing “ecosystem services,” the scheme prioritizes financial returns over genuine conservation, risking greenwashing by corporations.
- Weak Climate Impact: The TFFF fails to address root causes of deforestation, offering no binding protections while distracting from real emission reduction efforts.
Alternative Solutions Proposed by Global Forest Coalition
- Redirect Military Spending to Forest Protection: Redirecting 1% of global military budgets ($26.4 billion/year) to forest protection could provide six times more funding than the TFFF’s annual target.
- Oil Tax for Conservation: A small $1 per barrel tax on oil could generate $38 billion annually, nearly ten times more than the TFFF’s $4 billion goal.
- Strengthen Indigenous Land Rights: Direct funding and legal recognition for Indigenous forest stewardship.
- Address Root Causes of Deforestation: Combat the drivers of forest loss, industrial agriculture, mining, and fossil fuel expansion, through policy reforms rather than financial offsets.
Global Forest Coalition
- The Global Forest Coalition (GFC) is an international coalition of NGOs and Indigenous Peoples’ Organizations defending the rights of forest peoples in forest policies.
- The GFC was founded in 2000 and is a successor to the NGO Forest Working Group.
- GFC participates in international forest policy meetings and organizes joint advocacy campaigns.
- It works on issues like Indigenous Peoples’ rights and the need for socially-justified forest policy.
|
Conclusion
While the TFFF claims to protect forests, critics warn it prioritizes investor profits over real conservation and sidelines Indigenous communities. Stronger, publicly funded solutions may be needed to ensure forests are protected for their ecological value, not just financial returns.
30 Apr 2025
