An ordinance, its constitutionality, and scrutiny

Recently, the President of India exercised legislative power under Article 123 of the Constitution to promulgate “The Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi (Amendment) Ordinance, 2023” (Ordinance), which negates a Constitution Bench judgment of the Supreme Court of India.

An ordinance, its constitutionality, and scrutiny 26 May 2023

Context:

Recently, the President of India exercised legislative power under Article 123 of the Constitution to promulgate “The Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi (Amendment) Ordinance, 2023” (Ordinance), which negates a Constitution Bench judgment of the Supreme Court of India.

Key issues:

First, the scope of the Court’s verdict: 

  • While interpreting Article 239AA(3)(a), the the Court interpreted that out of the 66 entries in List II (the State list), while the executive power of the Government of NCTD covers 63 entries, that of the Union of India is restricted to the remaining three: public order (entry 1), police (entry 2) and land (entry 18).
  • Consequently, executive power over “services” (entry 41) can be exercised exclusively by the Government of the NCTD. 

Second, the constitutionality of the ordinance:

  • The above interpretation was negated by the Union of India, acting through its Council of Ministers under Article 74, by triggering extraordinary legislative power of the President under Article 123 in the promulgation of an ordinance.
  • The ordinance was to read/insert entry 41 of List II (State list) into Article 239AA(3)(a), thereby expanding the scope of accepted matter.
  • This could not have been done without amending Article 239AA(3)(a) of the Constitution. 
  • The power conferred on Parliament under Article 239AA(3)(b) is to make fresh laws — not to amend Article 239AA(3)(a) of the Constitution.

Alteration needs an amendment:

  • Unlike the power conferred on Parliament under Article 239AA(7)(a) that no such clause Parliament’s law making shall not be deemed to be an amendment of the Constitution for the purposes of Article 368 has been stipulated in Article 239AA(3)(a). 
  • Therefore, altering the scope of Article 239AA(3)(a) requires constitutional amendment under Article 368; there is not an iota of doubt.
  • The ordinance promulgated to expand the scope of excepted matters in Article 239AA(3)(a) is void ab initio and is liable to be struck down for bypassing constitutional amendment. 
    • Article 123 is no substitute for Article 368 (amendment of the Constitution) in Part XX.
  • A Constitution Bench (five judges) of the Supreme Court declares/interprets the law (Article 239AA(3)(a)), the same is binding on all courts and authorities in India in terms of Articles 141 and 144, respectively. 
  • The aid and advice of the Union Council of Ministers to the President under Article 74 could not have overridden Article 144. The basis of the Court judgment is Article 239AA(3)(a). To alter this basis, a constitutional amendment is necessary.

A perspective:

  • In the landmark seven-judge Bench verdict of the Supreme Court in Krishna Kumar Singh vs State of Bihar (2017) 2 SCC 136, the Court held that the satisfaction of the President under Article 123 is not immune from judicial scrutiny.
  • It was further held that the Court is empowered to look into the relevance of material placed before the President, but not its sufficiency or adequacy.
  • The ordinance is likely to be struck down since it expands excepted matters in Article 239AA(3)(a). Parliament alone can do this under Article 368.

                                                                                                          News Source: The Hindu

Archive Calendar

Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Need help preparing for UPSC or State PSCs?

Connect with our experts to get free counselling & start preparing

Know about Physics Wallah

Physics Wallah is an Indian online education platform, that provides accessible & comprehensive learning experiences to students of classes 6 to 12 and those preparing for JEE and NEET exams. We also provide extensive NCERT solutions, sample papers, NEET, JEE Mains, BITSAT previous year papers, which makes us a one-stop solution for all resources. Physics Wallah also caters to over 3.5 million registered students and over 78 lakh+ Youtube subscribers with 4.8 rating on its app.

We Stand Out because

We successfully provide students with intensive courses by India's qualified & experienced faculties. PW strives to make the learning experience comprehensive and accessible for students of all sections of society. We believe in empowering every single student who couldn't dream of a good career in engineering and medical field earlier.

Our Key Focus Areas

Physics Wallah’s main focus is to create accessible learning experiences for students all over India. With courses like Lakshya, Udaan, Arjuna & many others, we have been able to provide a ready solution for lakhs of aspirants. From providing Chemistry, Maths, Physics formulae to giving e-books of eminent authors, PW aims to provide reliable solutions for student prep.

What Makes Us Different

Physics Wallah strives to develop a comprehensive pedagogical structure for students, where they get a state-of-the-art learning experience with study material and resources. Apart from catering students preparing for JEE Mains and NEET, PW also provides study material for each state board like Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, and others.

Aiming for UPSC?

Download Our App

# #
Quick Revise Now !
AVAILABLE FOR DOWNLOAD SOON
UDAAN PRELIMS WALLAH
Comprehensive coverage with a concise format
Integration of PYQ within the booklet
Designed as per recent trends of Prelims questions
हिंदी में भी उपलब्ध
Quick Revise Now !
UDAAN PRELIMS WALLAH
Comprehensive coverage with a concise format
Integration of PYQ within the booklet
Designed as per recent trends of Prelims questions
हिंदी में भी उपलब्ध

<div class="new-fform">






    </div>

    Subscribe our Newsletter
    Sign up now for our exclusive newsletter and be the first to know about our latest Initiatives, Quality Content, and much more.
    *Promise! We won't spam you.
    Yes! I want to Subscribe.