Cultural Diversity in India: Shaping Identities and Nations

Culture is the shared understanding that develops through social interactions, setting one group apart from another and shaping its identity. Importantly, cultures are not static; they evolve with elements being added, removed, and rearranged. This dynamism makes cultures dynamic and functional. 

This cultural diversity leads to the development of community identities and the further evolution of the nation-states at a larger scale. 

In this article, the significance of culture, the ethos of cultural diversity and other related aspects will be analysed.

Diverse Settings, Different Cultures: Wisdom Beyond Technology

• Cultural Diversity in Nature: Humans inhabit diverse natural settings, such as mountains, plains, forests, deserts, and islands, and reside in various social setups like villages, towns, and cities. 
  • These diverse environments necessitate different coping strategies, giving rise to a rich set of cultures.
• Adaptive Wisdom: The contrasting responses to the 2004 tsunami cultural diversity in India vividly illustrate this Cultural Diversity. 
  • While mainland and island populations, accustomed to modern living, were unprepared and suffered significant devastation, 
  • Primitive tribal communities on the islands, including the Onges, Jarawas, Great Andamanese, and Shompens, who lacked access to modern technology, relied on their experiential knowledge to foresee the disaster and moved to higher ground, saving themselves.
• Beyond Technological Metrics: This underscores that access to modern science and technology doesn’t inherently determine the superiority of a culture. 
  • Instead, cultures should be evaluated based on their ability to effectively cope with the challenges posed by nature.

Defining Culture: Shared Wisdom and Collective Life

• Evolution of Cultural Diversity Perception: The term ‘culture’ has historically been associated with acquiring refined tastes in classical music, dance, or art, differentiating individuals from the ‘uncultured’ masses, even concerning something we would today see as individual, like the preference for coffee over tea. 
• A Sociological and Anthropological Perspective: However, sociologists and anthropologists study culture as a broader concept, not limited to individual preferences but as a way of life shared by all members of society. For instance,
  • Edward Tylor defined culture as a “complex whole” that includes knowledge, belief, art, morals, law, custom, and other capabilities and habits acquired by humans as members of society.
  • Bronislaw Malinowski, described culture as comprising inherited artifacts, goods, technical processes, ideas, habits, and values.
  • Clifford Geertz, influenced by these ideas, suggested looking at human actions as conveying messages within webs of significance that individuals create. 
  • Leslie White also emphasized culture’s role in adding meaning to objective reality.
  • Alfred Kroeber and Clyde Kluckhohn’s, comprehensive survey on culture highlighted the diverse definitions of culture, emphasizing common elements like ‘way,’ ‘learn,’ and ‘behavior.’ 
  • These definitions stress culture’s role in guiding behavior and its significance as a shared knowledge system passed down through generations.
• The Essence of Culture: Concisely, culture is not merely about individual preferences but represents a collective way of life encompassing knowledge, beliefs, practices, and values that shape human behavior and meaning in society. 
  • These ideas have evolved over time and have been refined by various sociologists and anthropologists.

Culture Diversity and Identity: Language, Roles, and Subcultures

• Socially Constructed Identities: Identities are not innate but rather constructed through individual and group interactions with others. 
  • An individual’s identity is shaped by the various social roles they assume. 
• Multiplicity of Roles: In modern society, individuals often take on multiple roles, each with its own set of responsibilities and powers. 
  • However, simply performing these roles is not enough; they must also be acknowledged and recognized by others.
• Language as a Cultural Diversity Key: Language plays a crucial role in this recognition process. Different social groups often develop their own language and code, creating a unique world of meanings and significance. 
  • Example: Students in schools may have their own way of referring to teachers, classmates, and class performances, reinforcing their shared identity.
  • Similarly, women may create their own language and private spaces, especially when congregating in rural areas to bathe or in urban areas around washing lines on rooftops. 
• Exploring Subcultures: Within a culture, there can exist numerous subcultures, such as elite and working-class youth groups. 
• Features of Subcultures
  • Cultural Diversity: These subcultures are defined by their distinct styles, tastes, and associations, often reflected in speech, clothing, music preferences, and social interactions.
  • Identity Forged in Unity: Subcultural groups act as cohesive units, providing a sense of identity to their members. 
  • Leadership and Collaboration: These groups may have leaders and followers,  but they are united by a shared purpose and collaborate to achieve their goals. 
    • Example: Young residents of a neighborhood may form a club to engage in sports and other constructive activities. 
  • Elevating Group Image: These activities not only enhance the group’s image within the community but also boost members’ self-esteem and motivation to excel in their endeavors.
  • Distinct Identity Through Acceptance: Through acceptance and recognition within their community, these groups differentiate themselves from others and establish their unique identities.

The Importance of Community Identity: Bonds, Labels, and Universal Conflicts

• Identity Formation: Our sense of identity is crucial for navigating the world, and it’s shaped through socialization within our immediate families and communities. 
  • This process involves ongoing dialogue, negotiation, and sometimes even struggle with significant individuals like our parents, family, kin, and community. 
• Community Bonds: The community provides us with our mother tongue, Cultural Diversity, and self-identity. 
  • Community identity is ascriptive, determined by birth and belonging, rather than earned qualifications or accomplishments. 
• Involuntary Affiliation: People often feel a deep sense of security and satisfaction in belonging to communities to which they were born, even though this belonging is entirely accidental.
• Indelible Labels: Ascriptive Identities, such as family, religious, regional, or ethnic affiliations, are challenging to shed, and others may continue to identify us by these markers. 
• Emotional Bonds and Identity Threats: This unconditional and almost inescapable belonging to communities can lead to strong emotional attachments and reactions when there’s a perceived threat to these identities. 
• Universal Essence: These identities are universal; everyone has some form of them, and people are equally committed and loyal to their respective identities. 
• Identity Conflicts: This universality and commitment make conflicts involving these identities difficult to resolve, as each side tends to view the other as an enemy, often exaggerating their virtues and the vices of the other side. 
  • This tendency can make it challenging for people on either side of a conflict to see that they are constructing mirror images of each other in the heat of the moment.

Dimensions of Culture: Cognitive, Normative, Material Dimensions

• Culture encompasses three key dimensions:
  • Cognitive Dimension: This dimension involves how individuals process information to give it meaning.
    • It includes recognizing familiar sounds or interpreting symbols like political cartoons.
  • Normative Dimension: Culture also involves rules and norms that govern behavior, such as customs and traditions. 
    • Example: Not opening others’ letters or performing specific rituals during funerals.
  • Material Dimension: This dimension encompasses tangible aspects enabled by materials, tools, and machines. 
    • Activities like creating art or using technology, such as internet chatting, fall under this category.
• Interconnected Dimensions: Analyzing these dimensions separately provides valuable insights into culture, but they are interconnected, contributing to a holistic understanding of a society’s way of life.

Cognitive Aspects of Culture: Writing, Technology, and Cultural Shifts

• Understanding the Challenge: Recognizing the cognitive aspects of one’s own culture can be more challenging compared to its tangible (material) and explicit (normative) aspects. 
• Cognitive Elements of Culture: Cognitive elements involve how we process information from our environment which may be different in different societies. 
  • Societal Variations: In literate societies, ideas are documented, but in non-literate societies, oral traditions and memory are key.
  • The Transformative Power of Writing: The impact of writing on culture is profound. 
    • Walter Ong, in his Orality and Literacy, suggests that material which is not written down has specific characteristics like repetition of words which makes it easier to remember. 
    • On the other hand, texts become more elaborate when they are in written form. 
  • Democratizing Literacy: Literacy historically favored privileged individuals, and efforts have aimed to make it relevant to the less educated.
• Technological Shifts and Cultural Diversity Resilience: In today’s world, electronic media, multiple channels, and instant access have changed how we access information. 
  • However, some traditions, like memorizing cultural diversity in india, classical music, persist. 
  • The effects of modern technology on culture and memory are still being explored.

Normative Aspects of Culture: Guiding Behavior and Legal Frameworks

• Guiding Principles: The normative dimension of culture encompasses folkways, morals, customs, conventions, and laws, which are guiding principles for social behavior. 
• Social Norms : Social norms are typically followed due to socialization and are reinforced by sanctions that promote conformity.
  • Norms are implicit rules, whereas laws are explicit rules. 
  • Cultural Sensitivity: Pierre Bourdieu emphasizes that understanding another culture’s norms requires recognizing implicit nuances.
  • Example:  A person should not offer to return a gift too quickly for something which has been given to him earlier, otherwise, it may look like an attempt to get rid of a debt. 
• Laws or Legal Frameworks: In contrast, laws are formal sanctions established by the government, applicable to the entire society, and backed by penalties and punishments. 
  • Violating laws, such as stealing, leads to legal consequences. 
  • Laws are formal and represent the State’s authority over acceptable behavior.
• Normative Inequities: Norms, unlike laws, can vary based on social status, and dominant groups may impose discriminatory norms. 
  • Examples: Include norms that prohibited Dalits from sharing water sources or women from freely navigating public spaces.

Material Aspects of Culture: Balancing Material and Intangible Dimensions

Culture encompasses two primary dimensions: material and non-material.

• Material Dimension: Includes tools, technologies, machines, buildings, transportation methods, and production and communication instruments etc. 
  • These are crucial for enhancing quality of life. 
  • Example: Everyday life heavily relies on technology in urban areas, such as mobile phones, cars, refrigerators, and computers. 
  • Even in rural settings, technology like transistor radios and electric pumps for irrigation are used. 
• Non-Material Dimension: These consist of cognitive and normative aspects, which are intangible elements like knowledge, beliefs, values, and social rules. 
• Symbiosis of Material and Non-Material Elements: Both these material and non-material aspects are essential for the proper functioning of a culture. 
• Exploring ‘Culture Lag’: However, when technological advancements progress rapidly, the non-material dimensions, including values and norms, may struggle to keep pace. 
  • This can result in a phenomenon known as “culture lag,” where the non-material aspects cannot fully adapt to the changes brought about by technology.