The proposal for the creation of an All-India Judicial Service (AIJS), suggested by President Droupadi Murmu, has reignited the debate on judicial reforms in India. 

Objectives and Benefits of the AIJS

The AIJS aims to recruit young, bright individuals from varied backgrounds to become judges at the district level, improving the diversity and quality of the judiciary:

• Vacancy Management: The proposal envisions creating a centralised pool of candidates for district-level judicial positions, which could help in managing the chronic vacancy issues across various state courts.
• Reducing Corruption: The current system of appointment of lower judges often involves political influence, with senior advocates being promoted to judicial positions. 
  • The AIJS promises a more transparent, merit-based process, potentially curbing such corruption and bias.    
• Judicial Diversity: By recruiting from a broad, national pool, the AIJS could enhance diversity within the judiciary, ensuring representation from varied socio-economic and regional backgrounds.  

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Arguments Against the AIJS

• Judicial Independence Concerns: If the executive controls or influences the posting and transfer of judges, it may undermine judicial independence, potentially affecting impartiality and eroding trust in the fairness of judicial decisions.
• Administrative Complexity: Transitioning to a centralised recruitment system would involve complex administrative hurdles, including managing quotas, tenure policies, and pay parity across states. 
  • These challenges could lead to logistical issues and friction between the central and state governments. 
• Divergent Legal Systems: Differences in legal education across states, along with unique state-specific laws, could hinder transferred judges’ ability to effectively understand and apply local laws, creating challenges in the administration of justice.
• Impact on Local Language Preferences in Selection: A centralised recruitment process could overlook candidates’ proficiency in local languages, which is crucial for ensuring fairness, particularly in rural areas where local language knowledge is often essential for effective communication in court.
• Overrepresentation of Regions: Centralised exams may favour candidates from regions with better infrastructure for coaching and exam preparation, such as metropolitan cities. 
  • This could reduce the geographical and socio-economic diversity of the judiciary, disadvantageous candidates from rural or smaller towns.

Check Out UPSC Modules From PW Store

Conclusion

The All-India Judicial Service (AIJS) has the potential to address judicial vacancies and improve diversity. However, to be truly effective, it must be carefully designed to avoid shortcomings, ensuring regional representation, local legal expertise, and the attraction of top talent.

DOWNLOAD PDF

India faces severe environmental health challenges due to pollution and rapid economic growth. 

• To address these, there is a need for a unified Environmental Health Regulatory Agency (EHRA) to integrate environmental governance with public health and drive sustainable development.

Reasons for Urgency for Establishing an EHRA

• Global Climate Action and India’s Advocacy:
  • The 2024 COP 29 highlighted the urgent global demand for ambitious climate action.
  • India is advocating for increased climate financing from developed nations, emphasising the need for effective environmental management.
• Rising Pollution and Health Risks:
  • Environmental pollution, particularly in air, water, and soil, continues to pose severe health risks in India. 
  • Pollution has direct adverse effects on public health, contributing to a rise in diseases.
• Increasing Greenhouse Gas Emissions:
  • According to the Emissions Gap Report 2024, India saw a 6% increase in greenhouse gas emissions compared to the previous year, signalling the critical need for integrated policies to manage both climate and health challenges.
• Interdependencies Between Climate, Environment, Health, and Economy:
  • As India experiences rapid economic growth, the interlinkages between environmental sustainability, public health, and economic growth are undeniable.
  • However, current institutional capacities are limited to address these complex, interconnected issues holistically.
• Comprehensive Data Integration:
  • There is a significant disconnect between the efforts of the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC), and the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW). 
  • These agencies focus separately on pollution control, environmental policies, and disease surveillance, leading to insufficient data flow and a lack of coordination in addressing health risks arising from pollution.
• Epidemiological Evidence of Health Impacts:  
  • Studies in India highlight the detrimental effects of pollution on public health, contributing to the rise in non-communicable diseases like respiratory, cardiovascular, and metabolic disorders. 
  • Vulnerable groups, including children, the elderly, and economically disadvantaged communities, face higher risks from exposure to pollutants.
• Controlling hazards:
  • An EHRA could have prevented disasters like the Bhopal Gas Tragedy by enforcing safety protocols, conducting risk assessments, ensuring industry compliance, and coordinating quick response measures to protect public health and the environment.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Classes

Benefits of an EHRA

• Data Integration: An EHRA could integrate environmental and health data to track, regulate, and mitigate health impacts more effectively.
• Unified Regulatory Framework: It would enable the formulation of a comprehensive response to all types of pollution, ensuring cumulative accountability and international collaboration.  
• Evidence-Based Policy: A data-driven, evidence-based regulatory framework would be developed, informed by global funding and research, to address specific national challenges like air quality, vector-borne diseases, and chemical exposures.
• Incentivised Practices: The establishment of an EHRA could drive sustainable practices that foster innovation, green jobs, and long-term economic resilience.
• Alignment with Global Standards: By adhering to international standards and policies, India could promote economic growth without compromising environmental health.
• Community Involvement: Involving the public is crucial for the success of environmental health initiatives, as citizens can advocate for cleaner air, water, and healthier living conditions.  
• Global Commitments: An EHRA would help India meet international commitments such as those under the Paris Agreement and the Sustainable Development Goals by aligning national policies with global standards.
• Tailored Interventions: A granular national platform for monitoring and accountability would allow for more effective responses to local needs and enable the development of policies tailored to regional environmental health challenges.

Check Out UPSC NCERT Textbooks From PW Store

Conclusion

Establishing an Environmental Health Regulatory Agency (EHRA) in India could effectively tackle pollution and public health issues. Despite potential challenges such as bureaucratic resistance and industry pushback, a well-structured, scientifically guided framework for coordination and clear objectives can ensure the agency successfully prioritises and enforces policies that safeguard public health.

DOWNLOAD PDF

The role of social media in democracy is debated, with its ability to empower citizens countered by concerns over misinformation, hate speech, and manipulation. Recently, The Guardian labelled Twitter (X) as a “toxic media platform” under Elon Musk’s ownership.

Key issues associated with the Impact of Social Media in democracy

• Political Bias and Discourse Manipulation: For instance, Elon Musk’s control has allowed the prioritization of his posts and specific narratives through algorithmic adjustments, shaping public discourse and potentially skewing democratic debates.
• Centralized Control and Government Censorship: The monopolistic power of a few tech giants facilitates easier government censorship. 
  • Platforms like X often align with government demands, restricting the free flow of diverse opinions and stifling dissent.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

• Insufficient Moderation Infrastructure
  • Removal of Trust and Safety Teams: X’s decision to eliminate teams responsible for addressing harmful content has led to unchecked hate speech, misinformation, and dangerous narratives.
  • Underinvestment in Localization: Platforms like Facebook and WhatsApp lack adequate local language moderators, especially in linguistically diverse regions like India. 
    • For example, during the Sri Lankan riots, moderation was outsourced to an office in India, leading to delays and contextual misinterpretations.
  • The absence of region-specific moderation exacerbates issues such as “dog whistling,” where coded language incites violence or hatred. 
• Virality of Fake News: Apps like WhatsApp amplify the rapid spread of misinformation, leveraging features like large group messaging. This unchecked virality has significant consequences in shaping public opinion, often without accountability or fact-checking mechanisms.
• Algorithmic Manipulation: Algorithms on platforms like X prioritize content that aligns with the owner’s interests or specific narratives. 
  • This not only influences user perception but also undermines the democratic principle of impartial access to information.

The Role of Social Media in Democracy

Positive Effects

• Voice to the People: For instance, the Anna Hazare Movement effectively mobilized public support for anti-corruption reforms, enabling direct communication of public demands to the government.
• Rapid Information Sharing: Platforms facilitate real-time updates, especially in crises. 
  • During COVID-19, social media disseminated critical information on oxygen supplies and hospital resources, helping individuals respond swiftly to emergencies.
• Community Mobilization: Social media fosters grassroots organization during disasters. 
  • For example, during the Chennai floods, the hashtag #ChennaiRains coordinated relief efforts, mobilizing over 25,000 volunteers to support affected communities.
• Enhanced Government Accountability: Viral social media posts often compel authorities to act. For instance, widespread sharing of police misconduct incidents has led to prompt disciplinary actions, ensuring increased accountability and transparency.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store

Negative Effects 

• Spread of Misinformation: Social media facilitates rapid dissemination of fake news. 
  • During COVID-19, misinformation about treatments and vaccines caused panic and harmful behaviors due to inadequate moderation.
• Echo Chambers and Polarization: Algorithms create echo chambers, exposing users only to like-minded views, reinforcing biases, and fueling political and ideological polarization, reducing exposure to balanced perspectives.
• Political Manipulation: The Cambridge Analytica scandal highlighted the misuse of personal data for targeted political ads, distorting electoral processes and misleading voters.
• Hate Speech and Violence: Unchecked inflammatory content often incites real-world violence, as seen in riots and communal unrest triggered by social media posts.
• Digital Divide: Limited internet access in rural areas and developing regions exacerbates inequality, restricting access to information and opportunities.
• Mental Health Issues: Excessive exposure to negative content, cyberbullying, and comparisons on social media increase anxiety, depression, and stress, lowering well-being.
• Time Wastage: Prolonged, unproductive scrolling reduces productivity and time for meaningful activities like education or social interaction.
• Foreign Interference: Cases like the 2016 US elections show how foreign entities use social media to spread propaganda, manipulate public opinion, and undermine democratic processes.

Alternatives and Solutions to Address Social Media Issues

Individual Level

• Fact-Checking: Actively engage in fact-checking and verify information before sharing.
• Increased Awareness: Stay informed and critically evaluate content.
• Platform Choices: Opt for platforms like Bluesky, which prioritise ethical management and civil discourse.
  • Explore decentralised systems like Mastodon, though they need further user-friendly improvements to increase adoption.

Platform Level

• Transparent Algorithms: Platforms must ensure algorithm transparency to avoid bias and manipulation.
• Quick Action on Violations: Swift enforcement against content violations to maintain trust.
• Local Language Support: Offer moderation and content options in regional languages.
• Better Content Moderation: Invest in human moderators and AI systems to handle diverse languages and cultural nuances.
• Policies on Hate Speech: Implement uniform, effective policies to combat hate speech and harmful content.

Government Level

• Stronger Laws: Enforce stronger regulations to govern online content and behavior.
• Clear Guidelines: Set clear guidelines for platform accountability.
• Promote Digital Literacy: Strengthen digital literacy programs to help users navigate online content responsibly.
• Fair Access Policies: Ensure equal access to information and prevent monopolistic control over digital spaces.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Classes

Community Level

• Promote Positive Content: Encourage the sharing of constructive and informative content.
• Flag Harmful Content: Empower users to report harmful or false content to ensure safer online environments.
• Better Fact checking units: Establishing better fact-checking units that are politically neutral, transparent, and independent.

Conclusion

Social media, a vital pillar of democracy, empowers citizens and fosters communication, yet poses risks like misinformation and manipulation. To harness its potential, transparent algorithms, effective moderation, and robust regulations are essential for safeguarding democratic values.

DOWNLOAD PDF