Answer

The Durand Line, established in 1893 between British India and Afghanistan, remains a contentious border issue between Afghanistan and Pakistan, impacting regional stability and international relations. The recent news of tensions and skirmishes along this border has heightened concerns, affecting India, given its complex ties with both Afghanistan and Pakistan. This dispute continues to shape South Asian geopolitics.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

How the Durand Line Issue Complicates Relations

• Strained Afghanistan-Pakistan Relations: The Durand Line divides the Pashtun population, leading to resistance from Afghanistan in recognizing it as a legitimate border, which fuels tensions.
• Pashtun Nationalism: The division of Pashtuns has intensified nationalist sentiments, affecting both Afghanistan and Pakistan, complicating bilateral relations.
  For example: The Pashtun Tahafuz Movement (PTM) in Pakistan advocates for greater autonomy, challenging Islamabad’s control over Pashtun areas.
• Impact on India-Pakistan Relations: Afghanistan’s rejection of the Durand Line has implications for India, which seeks stability in the region while opposing Pakistan’s influence.
  For example: India’s development projects in Afghanistan are often hampered due to instability linked to Durand Line tensions.
• Taliban’s Position: The Taliban, now in power in Afghanistan, have not officially accepted the Durand Line, complicating Pakistan’s strategy in maintaining influence over its western neighbour.
  |For example: Taliban forces have clashed with Pakistani troops along the border, signalling resistance to Pakistan’s territorial claims.
• Security Concerns: Cross-border terrorism and militant movements are aggravated due to the porous nature of the Durand Line, affecting regional security.
• India’s Strategic Calculus: India views the instability along the Durand Line as an opportunity to counter Pakistan’s influence in Afghanistan by supporting Afghan sovereignty.
  For example: India’s diplomatic engagements with Afghan leaders often emphasise the importance of Afghan territorial integrity, indirectly challenging Pakistan’s position.

Historical Significance of the Durand Line Dispute

• Colonial Legacy: The Durand Line was drawn without consulting local populations, leaving a legacy of division and resentment.
  For example: The 1893 agreement between British India and Afghanistan ignored ethnic divisions, creating long-term discord.
• Soviet-Afghan War: During the Soviet invasion, the Durand Line became a significant passage for mujahideen fighters, intensifying its strategic importance.
  For example: Pakistan, with U.S. support, used the border to funnel aid to Afghan fighters, embedding the line in Cold War geopolitics.
• Partition of India: The 1947 partition further complicated the Durand Line issue, as newly formed Pakistan inherited the contentious border.
  For example: Afghanistan was the only country to oppose Pakistan’s admission to the United Nations, citing border disputes.
• 1961 Diplomatic Break: Afghanistan and Pakistan broke off diplomatic relations over the Durand Line, showcasing the depth of the dispute.
  For example: The closure of consulates and trade routes during this period significantly affected bilateral ties.
• Pashtun Identity and Politics: The Durand Line has always been a focal point for Pashtun identity, influencing political movements in both countries.
  For example: Leaders like Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan opposed the division, advocating for Pashtun unity across the border.

Current Significance of the Durand Line Dispute

• Taliban-Pakistan Tensions: The Taliban’s reluctance to recognize the Durand Line undermines Pakistan’s strategic depth policy.
  For instance: Recent clashes between Taliban and Pakistani forces indicate the Taliban’s unwillingness to accept imposed borders.
• Cross-border Militancy: The porous border facilitates militant activities, affecting regional stability and counter-terrorism efforts.
  For instance: The TTP’s use of Afghan sanctuaries poses a significant threat to Pakistan’s internal security.
• Economic Implications: Border instability disrupts trade and transit routes, affecting Afghanistan and Pakistan’s economic prospects.|
• India’s Strategic Interests: The dispute indirectly benefits India by keeping Pakistan embroiled in its western front, limiting its focus on the eastern border.
• Regional Geopolitics: The Durand Line remains a critical factor in South Asian geopolitics, influencing the policies of major powers like China and the U.S.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store

The Durand Line dispute continues to be a major impediment to regional stability in South Asia, affecting the relationships between Afghanistan, Pakistan, and India. While its historical roots lie in colonial missteps, its current impact is evident in cross-border militancy and geopolitical manoeuvring. Resolving this issue requires a balanced approach that respects ethnic identities and promotes regional cooperation.

DOWNLOAD PDF