Answer

The U.S.-India Civil Nuclear Deal, signed in 2008, marked a historic shift in bilateral relations, ending India’s decades-long nuclear isolation. It recognized India as a responsible nuclear state, facilitating access to nuclear technology and fuel. This deal not only strengthened energy security but also laid the foundation for enhanced defence collaboration and deepened strategic cooperation in the Indo-Pacific region.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Significance of the U.S.-India Civil Nuclear Deal as a Watershed Moment in Bilateral Relations

• Strengthened Strategic Partnership: The deal elevated U.S.-India relations to a strategic partnership, promoting trust between the nations post-Cold War estrangement.
  For example: The signing of the deal in 2008 opened avenues for enhanced defense cooperation, including military exercises and arms purchases.
• Defense and Security Cooperation: It laid the groundwork for deep defense collaboration, including intelligence sharing and joint military operations.
  For example: The U.S. sold advanced defense systems like Apache helicopters and P-8I maritime patrol aircraft to India post-deal.
• Nuclear Energy Development: The deal enabled India to access international nuclear technology and fuel markets, boosting its energy security.
  For example: India signed agreements with countries like France and Russia for nuclear reactor development after the deal.
• Removal of Trade Restrictions: The removal of Indian entities from the U.S. Entity List allowed greater technological and industrial collaboration.
  For example: In 2023, the U.S. removed additional restrictions, facilitating cooperation in nuclear energy and dual-use technologies.
• Global Recognition of India’s Nuclear Program: It marked international recognition of India’s nuclear program despite being a non-signatory of the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT).
  For example: India gained a special waiver from the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG), allowing access to nuclear trade globally.

Shortcomings of the U.S.-India Civil Nuclear Deal in Bilateral Relations

• Unresolved Liability Issues: The 2010 Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Act placed liability on suppliers, deterring U.S. companies from participating.
  For example: U.S. firms Westinghouse and GE have refrained from nuclear projects in India, unlike Russian-backed projects like Kudankulam.
• Limited Commercial Progress: Despite high expectations, the deal has not translated into large-scale nuclear reactor construction or energy production.
  For example: The proposed six nuclear reactors by Westinghouse in 2016 remain unbuilt due to liability and cost concerns.
• High Technology and Cost Barriers: U.S. nuclear technology and equipment are often expensive, impacting feasibility for Indian energy projects.
  For example: U.S. civil nuclear projects like Vogtle reactors in Georgia faced massive cost overruns, raising concerns for Indian adoption.
• Dependence on Fossil Fuels Persists: The failure to expand nuclear energy leaves India reliant on fossil fuels, undermining climate change commitments.
  For example: India’s coal-based power generation still constitutes over 70% of its energy mix, despite nuclear aspirations.
• Geopolitical and Regulatory Challenges: Concerns over dual-use technology transfer and geopolitical tensions limit the full potential of the deal.
  For example: The U.S. restricted certain Indian nuclear research entities due to fears of technology leakage to adversaries like Russia.

Ways in which U.S.-India Civil Nuclear Deal Shaped Defence and Strategic Cooperation

• Enhanced Military Ties: The trust built through the deal enabled deeper military collaboration, including joint exercises and sharing of advanced defense systems.
  For example: The annual Malabar Naval Exercise, involving the U.S., India, and Japan, strengthened maritime security in the Indo-Pacific region.
• Increased Defense Purchases: India emerged as a major buyer of U.S. defense equipment, enhancing its military capabilities and interoperability with U.S. forces.
  For example: India purchased C-17 Globemaster aircraft, and P-8I Poseidon planes to bolster its air and naval strength.
• Technology Transfer and Co-Development: The deal paved the way for defense technology sharing and co-production under initiatives like Defense Technology and Trade Initiative (DTTI).
  For example: The U.S. and India collaborated on projects like the aircraft carrier technology transfer and development of unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs).
• Strategic Alignment in Indo-Pacific: The partnership advanced shared strategic goals, particularly countering Chinese influence in the Indo-Pacific region.
  For example: The formation of Quad (India, U.S., Japan, Australia) strengthened joint efforts for regional security and economic stability.
• Intelligence Sharing and Counterterrorism: Improved trust fostered intelligence-sharing agreements for counterterrorism and addressing regional threats.
  For example: The Communications Compatibility and Security Agreement (COMCASA) allowed secure data exchange, enhancing joint operations and surveillance.
• Bilateral Defense Agreements: Key agreements have been signed to enhance defense cooperation and technology sharing.
  For example: BECA (Basic Exchange and Cooperation Agreement), signed in 2020, allowing India to access geospatial intelligence for precision targeting.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store

The U.S.-India civil nuclear deal has redefined bilateral relations, fostering defence and strategic cooperation. To sustain this momentum, both nations must focus on technology transfers, clean energy collaborations, and regional security initiatives. Strengthening mutual trust and expanding partnerships in critical technologies will ensure a robust, future-oriented alliance for global stability.

DOWNLOAD PDF