Answer

The transgender community in India, estimated at over 4.8 lakh as per Census 2011, continues to face systemic exclusion despite the 2019 enactment of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act. While awareness and visibility have grown, deep-rooted social biases still hinder their legal recognition, employment opportunities, and economic empowerment.

Significant gaps that remain in the legal and economic empowerment of transgender individuals in India

Gaps in Legal Empowerment

• Inefficient Certification Process: The bureaucratic hurdles in obtaining identity certificates under the Transgender Persons Act hinder access to essential welfare schemes and recognition.
  For example: As of December 2023, over 3,200 applications on the National Portal for Transgender Persons were pending beyond the mandated 30-day period.
• Lack of Police Safeguards: The law fails to explicitly address police harassment, leaving many transgender individuals vulnerable to abuse without legal protection.
  For example: Despite repeated complaints by activists, the Act does not include specific provisions for redressal in cases of police violence or extortion.
• Neglect of Social Exclusion: The law lacks clarity on tackling family rejection and social ostracism, which are primary causes of homelessness and mental distress among transgender people.
  For example: In Delhi, although the 2011 Census reported around 4,200 transgender persons, only 23 identity cards were issued by April 2022 due to family and institutional neglect.

Gaps in Economic Empowerment

• High Unemployment Rates: Transgender persons face severe discrimination in hiring processes, leading to extremely high unemployment compared to the national average.
  For example: A 2022 study reported a 48% unemployment rate among transgender individuals, far higher than India’s average of 7%-8%.
• Widespread Job Biases: Even when employed, transgender individuals often face workplace hostility, lack of gender-neutral facilities, and harassment from colleagues.
  For example: Despite Tata Steel hiring over 100 transgender employees, most industries have not adopted inclusive workplace policies.
• Entrepreneurial Exclusion: Access to credit and financial support remains limited, discouraging entrepreneurship among transgender individuals.
  For example: While the Finance Ministry allowed joint bank accounts for LGBTQ+ individuals in 2024, broader financial access remains uneven and exclusionary.

Measures for Legal Recognition

• Streamline Certification Process: Simplify and decentralize the process of issuing transgender identity cards to reduce delays and bureaucratic hurdles.
• Adopt Self-Identification: Replace medical and bureaucratic gatekeeping with a self-identification model in line with international best practices.
  For example: Argentina’s Gender Identity Law allows individuals to legally change their gender without requiring medical or psychiatric approval.
• Legal Aid and Awareness: Ensure access to legal support and create awareness about transgender rights among law enforcement and the judiciary.
  For example: The National Legal Services Authority in India offers legal aid, but its reach and awareness among transgender people remain limited.
• Anti-Harassment Provisions: Amend existing laws to explicitly include protection from police harassment and institutional violence against transgender persons.
  For example: Activist groups like Sangama have long demanded inclusion of police accountability clauses in the Transgender Persons Act.
• Recognition of Chosen Family: Legally recognize transgender persons’ chosen family structures for social security, health benefits, and welfare entitlements.
  For example: The Madras High Court in 2021 recognized self-respect marriages and chosen families in a landmark ruling for LGBTQ+ rights.

Measures for Economic Inclusion

• Inclusive Hiring Policies: Mandate diversity hiring targets and create transgender employment cells in public and private sectors to promote workplace equality.
  For example: Tata Steel’s Diversity and Inclusion policy led to the employment of over 100 transgender persons, setting an industry benchmark.
• Entrepreneurship Schemes: Launch targeted schemes offering low-interest loans, mentorship, and training for transgender-led startups and small businesses.
  For example: Hyderabad established a Transgender Entrepreneurship Centre through the MoW&CD to provide skills training and business support to transgender individuals.
• Access to Financial Services: Simplify KYC norms and expand access to banking and insurance services tailored for transgender individuals.
• Skill Development Programs: Implement vocational training tailored to the needs of transgender youth in collaboration with NGOs and corporates.
• Workplace Sensitisation Drives: Regularly conduct gender sensitisation workshops to build inclusive work environments and reduce bias.
  For example: The ‘I Am Also Human’ campaign by Humsafar Trust conducts corporate sensitisation sessions to promote transgender acceptance at workplaces.

As awareness grows, the focus must shift from tokenism to transformative inclusion. Ensuring robust legal safeguards, affirmative action, and gender-sensitive skilling programs can bridge existing gaps. As Dr. B.R. Ambedkar said, “Political democracy cannot last unless there lies at the base of it social democracy.” True empowerment demands nothing less.

DOWNLOAD PDF