Answer

The demand for a nationwide caste census in India has increased, especially after Bihar’s 2023 caste survey. While the decennial Census includes data on SCs and STs, it excludes OBCs and other caste groups, sparking debate on the political, constitutional, and social implications of conducting a full caste census.

Positive Political, Constitutional and Social Implications of a Nationwide Caste Census in India

• Enhanced Political Representation for Backward Groups: Updated data enables proportional political inclusion of OBCs, SCs, STs and EBCs in legislatures.
  For example: Bihar caste survey (2023) showed OBCs and EBCs together form over 63% of the population, guiding seat reservation demands.
• Data-Driven Affirmative Action: Empirical data helps tailor reservations and welfare schemes under Articles 15(4) and 16(4).
  For example: Rohini Commission (2023) noted unequal OBC benefit distribution, stressing the need for sub-categorisation.
• Promotion of Social Justice Goals: It aligns with Directive Principles like Article 46 to promote educational and economic interests of weaker sections.
• Transparency in Resource Allocation: Enables evidence-based budgeting and targeted public expenditure for marginalised communities.
• Filling Gaps Left by SECC 2011: Overcomes data gaps due to unreleased and flawed SECC data, reviving trust in inclusive governance.
• Boosting Constitutional Morality and Inclusion: Reinforces Ambedkarite vision of recognising structural disadvantages for genuine upliftment.
  For example: SC in Indra Sawhney (1992) stated caste is a valid indicator of backwardness and needs periodic re-evaluation.

Negative Political, Constitutional and Social Implications of a Nationwide Caste Census in India

• Intensification of Identity Politics: Political parties may exploit caste data for vote-bank mobilisation, weakening issue-based politics.
• Risk of Caste-Based Polarisation: Public release of caste numbers may trigger inter-group competition and social unrest.
• Undermining National Integration: Excessive emphasis on caste categories may hinder the vision of a unified Indian identity.
  For example: Social groups increasingly demanding quotas based on caste count may fragment national social fabric.
• Legal Complexity Over Quota Ceiling: Fresh data may lead to quota demands exceeding the 50% limit set by SC in Indra Sawhney (1992).
  For example: Tamil Nadu’s 69% reservation under Ninth Schedule faces renewed scrutiny as other states push to exceed the cap.
• Possibility of Data Misuse: Lack of data privacy laws may lead to political or commercial misuse of sensitive caste data.
  For example: Civil society groups flagged risks in 2023 about electoral profiling and algorithmic targeting using caste datasets.
• Administrative Burden and Accuracy Concerns: Massive data collection risks duplication, errors, and disputes over classification.
  

Nationwide Caste Census as instrument of Social Justice or Political Strategy

• Tool for Targeted Welfare Delivery: A caste census enables evidence-based policymaking to ensure equitable distribution of welfare schemes.
  For example: Socio-Economic Caste Census (SECC) 2011 guided schemes like PM Awas Yojana and rural skill programmes.
• Empowerment through Representation: Accurate caste numbers can ensure fair political and bureaucratic representation of marginalised groups.
• Recognition of Hidden Backwardness: It may identify deprived sub-castes that remain excluded due to lack of formal enumeration.
  For example: Rohini Commission (2023) revealed elite OBCs cornering a bulk of benefits, pushing for sub-categorisation.
• Strengthening Social Justice Mandate: A caste census aligns with constitutional goals under Articles 15(4), 16(4), and Directive Principles.
  For example: The Supreme Court (2021) in the Maratha case highlighted the need for reliable data to justify reservations.
• Dilution of Individual Identity: Institutionalising caste data risks reinforcing caste as a primary identity marker.
  For example: Scholars caution that repeated state recognition of caste identities may reverse efforts to build a casteless society.

A nationwide caste census can be a vital tool for social justice through data-driven policymaking and equitable resource distribution. However, its impact hinges on intent, transparency, and execution, lest it become a mere political strategy.

DOWNLOAD PDF