Answer

Introduction

India’s rising demand for critical minerals like lithium, cobalt, nickel, and rare earths is vital for clean energy, defence, and manufacturing. With domestic mining slow and costly, recycling from e-waste, battery scrap, and vehicles offers a near-term cushion. The ₹1,500 crore NCMM scheme strengthens resource security and reduces import dependence.

Body

Significance of Recycling Critical Minerals in India’s Strategy for Resource Security

• Immediate supply augmentation: Recycling provides a quicker pathway to access critical minerals compared to the long gestation period of mining and exploration.
• Reduction in import dependence – India is heavily reliant on imports for 30 identified critical minerals; recycling reduces vulnerability to external supply shocks.
  Eg: The Indian government noted that India relies entirely on imports for lithium, with China supplying 70–80%, and on China for 60% of natural graphite, both vital for batteries and the EV industry.
• Support for Clean Energy Transition: Critical minerals are essential for solar panels, wind turbines, and batteries. Recycling reduces dependence on imports.
  Eg: Recovered nickel and cobalt from battery scrap can strengthen India’s National Electric Mobility Mission.
• Strategic Autonomy in Defence Manufacturing: Defence technologies require rare earths and specialized minerals. Recycling ensures partial independence from volatile global markets.
• Economic Efficiency and Job Creation: Recycling builds a domestic circular economy, reducing foreign exchange outflow on imports.
  Eg: The Scheme is expected to attract approximately ₹8,000 crore in investment while generating nearly 70,000 direct and indirect employment opportunities.
• Complementary Path to Mining: Recycling supplements domestic mining by bridging immediate supply gaps until mines become operational.

Limitations of Relying Solely on Recycling to Meet India’s Critical Mineral Demand

• Insufficient scale: Recycling alone cannot meet the growing demand for critical minerals driven by industrial expansion and clean-energy goals.
  Eg: Annual recycling yields of ~40 kilo tonnes are inadequate relative to domestic demand projections.
• Challenges in Collection Systems: India lacks efficient infrastructure for gathering e-waste and end-of-life batteries at scale.
• Purity and Quality Issues: Recycled minerals may not always meet the standards required for advanced technologies.
  Eg: Battery-grade lithium requires extremely high purity, which recycling plants often struggle to deliver.
• Economic Viability Concerns: Recycling can be cost-intensive without proper incentives, making imports appear cheaper.
  Eg: Processing catalytic converters to recover platinum-group metals requires expensive technology.
• Not a Substitute for Mining: Recycling is a stop-gap, but mining remains crucial for long-term needs.
  Eg: Despite recycling initiatives, India is still negotiating supply agreements with Australia for lithium.

Conclusion

Recycling provides India with a short-term cushion for critical mineral security but cannot fully meet the rising demand. The way forward is to pursue an integrated approach that strengthens domestic mining, expands recycling capacity, and builds international supply partnerships to secure long-term self-reliance and strategic resilience.

DOWNLOAD PDF