Recently, a Rajya Sabha MP has proposed introducing the Right to Recall in Parliament, arguing voters should remove non-performing representatives before their term ends.
What is the Right to Recall?
- The Right to Recall is a democratic mechanism that empowers voters to remove an elected representative before the completion of their fixed term through a prescribed legal process.
- It is typically initiated by a recall petition supported by a specified percentage of voters, followed by a recall vote. If a majority supports removal, the representative vacates office.
Rationale Behind the Right to Recall
- Enhancing Democratic Accountability: The mechanism strengthens vertical accountability by ensuring that elected representatives remain responsive to voter expectations throughout their tenure rather than only at the time of the next election.
- Curbing Corruption and Non-Performance: It acts as a deterrent against corruption, misconduct, or serious neglect of duty by creating a mid-term corrective tool in addition to existing parliamentary mechanisms such as no-confidence motions.
- Deepening Participatory Democracy: The Right to Recall aligns with the broader principle that sovereignty ultimately resides with the people, allowing them to directly intervene if their mandate is perceived to have been betrayed.
Countries with the Right to Recall
- Globally, more than 20 countries provide some form of recall mechanism, though its scope and thresholds vary significantly.
- United States of America – Available in many states for governors and local officials.
- United Kingdom – Recall of MPs permitted under specific legal conditions.
- Switzerland – Certain cantons provide recall provisions.
- Venezuela, Peru, Ecuador – Constitutional provisions allow recall of elected officials.
- Japan and Taiwan – Recall provisions exist at different administrative levels.
- Canada (British Columbia) – Recall mechanism for Members of the Legislative Assembly.
Provision of Right to Recall in India
- No Constitutional Provision: The Indian Constitution does not provide for recall of Members of Parliament (MPs) or Members of Legislative Assemblies (MLAs).
- The Representation of the People Act, 1951 allows removal only upon disqualification or conviction for specified offences, not for non-performance.
- State-Level Provisions (Local Bodies): Several states provide for recall at the Panchayat or municipal level, including Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Bihar, Rajasthan, and Jharkhand.
- In 2008, Chhattisgarh witnessed one of the first instances of recall where three local body chiefs were removed through the statutory process.
- Advocacy and Directions on Right to Recall
- M.N. Roy’s Proposal (1944): He recommended for Right to Recall in the Draft Constitution of Free India with provision for a decentralized, partyless democracy empowering citizens to recall elected representatives who violated their mandate.
- Jayaprakash Narayan’s Advocacy (1974): During the Total Revolution Movement, he demanded the Right to Recall to enhance political accountability and curb corruption in representative democracy.
- Mohan Lal Tripathi v. District Magistrate, Rae Bareilly (1993): The Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of recall provisions at the local level, observing that removal by representatives of voters does not violate democratic principles.
- Smt. Ram Beti v. District Panchayat Raj Adhikari (1998): The Allahabad High Court emphasized the need for stringent safeguards to prevent misuse and suggested that recall decisions should ideally involve direct participation of electors.
- State of Madhya Pradesh v. Shri Ram Singh (2000): The Supreme Court underlined the importance of a corruption-free and accountable governance framework while cautioning against mechanisms that may destabilize democratic functioning.
Conclusion
The Right to Recall strengthens accountability but requires strict safeguards to prevent instability, political misuse, and erosion of representative democracy.
13 Feb 2026
.png)
Current Affairs
GS Foundation
Optional Course
Combo Courses
Degree Program
