Cultural Change: Internal Innovations and External Influences

Cultural change is the process through which societies alter their cultural patterns. This change can be instigated by internal or external factors. For instance, internal causes like innovations in farming techniques can lead to increased agricultural production, transforming food consumption and the quality of life within agrarian communities. 

On the other hand, external events such as conquests or colonization can impose profound changes in the cultural practices and behaviours of a society.

Dynamics of Cultural Change: Nature, Interactions, and Media Impact

Cultural change can manifest through various mechanisms, including shifts in the natural environment, interactions with other cultures, and processes of adaptation. 

• Natural Forces: Changes in the natural environment, such as alterations in ecology, have the potential to significantly impact the way of life of a community. 
  • Example:  When forest-dwelling communities in Northeast and Middle India lose access to forests and their resources due to legal restrictions or deforestation, it can have devastating consequences on their livelihoods and cultural practices.
• Evolutionary and Revolutionary Change: Cultural change can also take on an evolutionary or revolutionary nature. 
  • Evolutionary change occurs gradually over time, while revolutionary change involves rapid and radical transformations in culture. 
  • Specifically, revolutionary change can be instigated by political interventions, technological innovations, or ecological transformations. 
  • Example: The French Revolution in 1789 brought about revolutionary change by dismantling the estate system, abolishing the monarchy, and promoting values like liberty, equality, and fraternity.
• Media Influence on Cultural Change: In recent years, the media, both electronic and print, has played a significant role in shaping cultural change.
  • However, whether this change is evolutionary or revolutionary is a matter of debate. 

Challenges of Cultural Diversity: Inequalities and Identity Struggles

• Definition: Cultural diversity refers to the presence of various social groups and communities within a nation, characterized by differences in language, religion, sect, race, or caste. 
• Diversity vs. Inequality: Diversity highlights these differences, it doesn’t necessarily address the issue of inequalities. 
  • Cultural diversity can pose challenges because when diverse communities coexist within a larger entity like a nation, competition and conflict can arise among them. 
  • The Power of Cultural Identities: Cultural identities are powerful and can evoke strong emotions, often mobilizing large groups of people. 
  • Complex Interplay: Sometimes, cultural differences are accompanied by economic and social inequalities, which further complicate the situation. 
• Navigating Conflict: Efforts to address these inequalities or injustices faced by one community can lead to opposition from others, especially when there’s a need to share limited resources like river waters, job opportunities, or government funds.

Cultural Change: Ethnocentrism, Cosmopolitanism, and Fusion

• Cultural Contact and Ethnocentrism: Cultures come into contact with each other, and this leads to the issue of ethnocentrism, where one evaluates other cultures using their own cultural values as a standard. 
  • Ethnocentrism often implies considering one’s own cultural values as superior, which can be seen in colonial contexts.
  • Example:  In Thomas Babbington Macaulay’s famous Minute on Education (1835) to the East India Company, he advocated for the creation of a class of individuals who would serve as intermediaries between the British rulers and the Indian population. 
    • He envisioned these individuals as being “Indian in blood and colour but English in tastes, in opinions, morals, and intellect.” 
• Ethnocentrism vs. Cosmopolitanism: Ethnocentrism stands in contrast to cosmopolitanism, which appreciates and values other cultures for their differences without trying to impose one’s own standards. 
  • Fostering Cultural Enrichment: A cosmopolitan perspective encourages cultural exchange and the enrichment of one’s own culture through interactions with others.
  • Cultural Fusion in Modern Societies: Modern societies often embrace cultural differences and incorporate foreign influences in a distinctive manner, which enriches their identity. 
  • Example: The English language has absorbed foreign words, and Hindi film music has incorporated elements from Western pop music and various traditions like bhangra and ghazal while maintaining its distinct character.
  • In today’s globalized world, a cosmopolitan outlook allows diverse cultural influences to enhance one’s own culture.

Policies of Assimilation and Integration: Assimilation, Integration, and Cultural Paradox

• Nation-Building Strategies: States have tried to establish and enhance their political legitimacy through nation-building strategies by seeking to secure the loyalty and obedience of their citizens through policies of assimilation or integration.
• Policies of Assimilation: Often involving outright suppression of the identities of ethnic, religious or linguistic groups – try to erode the cultural differences between groups.
• Policies of Integration: This seek to assert a single national identity by attempting to eliminate ethnonational and cultural differences from the public and political arena while allowing them in the private domain.
• Forging Unity: Assimilationist and integrationist strategies try to establish singular national identities through various interventions like:
  • Centralization of Power: Centralizing all power to forums where the dominant group constitutes a majority, and eliminating the autonomy of local or minority groups.
  • Legal Uniformity and Judicial Imposition: Imposing a unified legal and judicial system based on the dominant group’s traditions and abolishing alternative systems used by other groups;
  • Linguistic Uniformity: Adopting the dominant group’s language as the only official ‘national’ language and making its use mandatory in all public institutions;
    • Promotion of the dominant group’s language and culture through national institutions including state-controlled media and educational institutions;
  • Symbolic Representation: Adoption of state symbols celebrating the dominant group’s history, heroes and culture, reflected in such things as choice of national holidays or naming of streets etc.;
  • Land Appropriation and Resource Declaration: Seizure of lands, forests and fisheries from minority groups and indigenous people and declaring them ‘national resource’. 
• The Paradox of Cultural Suppression: Suppressing cultural diversity can alienate minority or subordinated communities and intensify community identity, making diversity a valuable and principled policy choice.

DOWNLOAD PDF