Big Tech companies are seen to be back-tracking on their DEI goals in wake of the new Donald Trump administration in the US Office.

• An executive order has been issued titled, ‘Ending Radical And Wasteful Government DEI Programs And Preferencing,’ where DEI initiatives were referred to as “illegal and immoral discrimination programs by the Trump administration.
• Big Tech Companies: Companies like Google, Meta, and Amazon have either announced or quietly made changes to their existing DEI initiatives like,
  • Meta: It scrapped its fact-checking programme and DEI programmes for employees and diversity efforts for suppliers, apart from ending representation goals for women and ethnic minorities
  • Google: Not meeting its diversity hiring goals and also removing references to Pride Month and Black History Month from Google’s Calendar
  • NASA: It is also taking down DEI-related terms from its website.

About Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI)

• Diversity, Equity & Inclusion (DEI) refers to a wide range of principles and practices which encompasses the philosophy and culture of acknowledging, embracing, supporting, and accepting those of all racial, sexual, gender, religious and socioeconomic backgrounds.
• Components:
  • Diversity: The presence and participation of individuals with varying backgrounds and perspectives, including those who have been traditionally underrepresented
  • Equity: Equal access to opportunities and fair, just, and impartial treatment
  • Inclusion: A sense of belonging in an environment where individuals from all backgrounds feel valued, respected, and empowered to contribute their unique perspectives and talents and provide psychological safety to all individuals
• Measures Constituting DEI: DEI includes a no. of benefits like,
  • Access to Opportunities: Visa sponsorship for foreign job applicants,refugess etc
  • Ensuring Representation: Hiring diverse individuals, funding their training, or reserving specific opportunities for them 
  • Inclusive Infrastructure: Company cafeteria menus that cater to a range of diet restrictions (Google), wheelchair-friendly elevators and toilets
  • Work life balance: Hybrid work mode for caretakers/parents, remote work options for people with disabilities or medical conditions
  • Maintaining Privacy: Corporate protection from inappropriate questions about one’s body, religious beliefs, sexual orientation, or marital status.
  • Celebrate Diversity: Recognize important dates and holidays for different employee groups.
• Measuring DEI:
  • Measure Diversity Data: To understand the demographic composition of the organisation across various dimensions such as gender, race, ethnicity, age, sexual orientation, disability status, and more. 
    • Examining diversity data will help identify underrepresented groups and ensure equitable representation across all levels and departments.
  • Treatment of diverse groups: To assess the quality of interactions and experiences within the workplace by evaluating inclusive behaviours such as respect, fairness, and equal employee opportunities.
  • Employee Experience: To measure employees’ feelings of belongingness involves assessing their satisfaction, engagement, and sense of inclusion within the workplace and identify barriers to inclusion.
    • Questions: Do employees feel supported and accepted for who they are? Do they have access to resources and opportunities for growth? 
• Impacts:
  • Spur Innovation Culture: Diverse points of view spurs innovation, make teams more adaptable, lead to creative solutions, and create unique opportunities for collaboration with team members and clients.
    • A Harvard Business Review survey of 79 large companies found that a 0.1-point increase in a company’s DEI ratings correlates to a 13-percent increase in that company’s ability to change.
  • Higher Employee Retention: Companies with a diverse, equitable and inclusive workplace tend to reduce employee turnover and enjoy a more stable workforce through the years.
  • Improved Business Outcomes: When people feel welcomed for who they are, they perform at a higher level. Firms that display culturally and ethnically diverse executive teams are 33 percent more likely to lead their industries in profitability.
    • A Forbes report has shown that increasing female partners’ shares by 10 percent often leads to a 10 percent rise in revenue. 
  • Against Discrimination: DEI can help promote representation and reduce discrimination and harassment at the workplace promoting a more inclusive environment.
  • Better Talent Acquisition: A commitment to DEI attracts a wider pool of qualified candidates from diverse backgrounds as the organisation values attributes like promoting work life balance, non discrimination, equal opportunity etc. 
  • Customer Satisfaction: DEI helps them be more responsive to customers’ needs, boosting customer perceptions of the organization, improving the customer experience, and increasing customer satisfaction.
• Criticisms of DEI Initiatives:
  • Diversity v/s Meritocracy: Unqualified individuals risk being hired or promoted simply to meet diversity quotas, undermining the principle of meritocracy.
  • Address Systemic Issues: Corporate DEI measures will only act as band-aids on a bullet wound if the company’s culture fails to address the systemic injustice prevalent in the society.
  • Tokenism: Many organizations engage in tokenism and only hire a few individuals from minority groups to appear diverse, without making meaningful changes to create an inclusive environment
  • Ineffective training: Concerns exist that DEI training programs can be superficial and not address the root causes of bias, leading to limited impact and a perception of “check-the-box” compliance. 
  • Reinforce stereotypes: The presence of DEI programmes can also lead to meritorious women, ethnic minority workers, or LGBTQIA+ employees facing more discrimination as others assume they were hired due to their identities, rather than their skills.
  • Lack of focus on inclusion: Overemphasis on achieving diversity metrics without considering the qualitative impact on employee experience and organizational culture can be problematic.
  • Poor implementation: Criticisms can arise when DEI initiatives are poorly designed, not integrated into the organization’s culture, or not adequately supported by leadership, leading to a lack of sustained change
  • Lack of Commitment: Some DEI programs fail to establish long-term sustainability because of lack of commitment to issues such as the ensuring quality of DEI educators, the reliability of the research behind these initiatives, and the persistence of discrimination despite ongoing training efforts.

DOWNLOAD PDF