In the last three months, various cases of dowry-related deaths have been reported from across India.
- Recent incidents from Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Chandigarh, and Delhi highlight the grim reality- young women continue to face harassment, assault, and even death due to dowry demands.
Understanding Dowry & Dowry Death
- Dowry: As per the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961, “dowry” is defined as any property or valuable security given or agreed to be given, either directly or indirectly:
- By one party to a marriage to the other.
- By the parents of either party, or any other person, to either party or any other person, at or before or after the marriage, in connection with the marriage.
- Dowry Death: As per Section 80 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) (formerly IPC Section 304B), a woman’s death caused by burns, bodily injury, or occurring under unnatural circumstances within seven years of marriage is classified as a dowry death.
- This classification applies if it’s established that she was subjected to cruelty or harassment in connection with dowry demands shortly before her death.
- Punishment: Rigorous imprisonment for a minimum of 7 years, which may extend to life imprisonment.
The Evolution of the Dowry System in India
- Ancient Practices: Dowry began as a custom of voluntary gifts to the bride, intended to provide her with financial support.
- Kanyadan: A religious custom where the bride’s father voluntarily gave her away in marriage along with gifts to the groom’s family. These were symbolic and not forced demands.
- Stridhan: Property, clothes, or jewelry given to the bride, which was considered her exclusive financial security after marriage.
- Historical accounts, such as those by traveler Megasthenes (Indica in 300 BCE), suggest that dowry was not a common or coercive practice in ancient India; gifts were typically given out of affection, not pressure.
- Changes During the Medieval Period: Dowry became more prevalent, especially within royal and upper-caste families. Practices like child marriage also grew, contributing to a more rigid system.
- British Rule and the Rise of Coercion: British legal reforms inadvertently formalized dowry, particularly in upper-class marriages.
- Loss of Property Rights: A significant factor was that women were often not allowed to own or inherit land. Dowry then became a compensatory mechanism, providing for daughters in the absence of property rights.
From Gift to Demand: What was once a voluntary gift gradually transformed into a mandatory demand. Grooms’ families began explicitly asking for money, goods, or land, placing immense pressure on brides’ families. The aspiration to marry into a higher social or caste status (hypergamy) further fueled these demands.
- Post-Independence Escalation: The problem worsened significantly after India gained independence. Before 1940, dowry was involved in an estimated 35–40% of marriages. By 1975, this figure had soared to nearly 90%, with increasingly larger amounts being demanded.
- Increased Violence: The inability to meet these escalating demands often led to severe abuse, harassment, and even deaths, frequently disguised as accidents or suicides.
The Grim Reality: Statistics on Dowry Deaths
- National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) Data (2017–2022): India witnesses an average of 7,000 dowry deaths annually, though actual figures are likely much higher due to widespread underreporting.
- In 2022 alone, 6,450 dowry deaths were reported nationally. A shocking 80% of these occurred in Uttar Pradesh (the highest), Bihar, Jharkhand, Odisha, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, and Haryana.
- Urban Hotspots: Delhi accounted for 30% of all dowry deaths in major cities, followed by Kanpur, Bengaluru, Lucknow, and Patna.
- Dowry as a Leading Motive for Murder: Over 6,100 murders between 2017 and 2022 had dowry as the primary motive, with 60% concentrated in West Bengal, Odisha, and Bihar.
- National Commission for Women (NCW) Data (2024): A staggering 4,383 cases of dowry harassment were reported to the NCW, accounting for 17% of all complaints received. Additionally, 292 cases of dowry deaths were recorded.
- Alarmingly, over 60% of these dowry-related murders occurred in just three states: West Bengal, Odisha, and Bihar.
Root Causes of Dowry Deaths
- Cultural and Social Factors
- Cultural Entitlement & Traditions: Despite being illegal since 1961, dowry persists, often disguised as “gifts” or streedhan. A girl’s worth is wrongly judged by the dowry she brings, perpetuating this harmful norm.
- Patriarchy & Gender Inequality: Women are often viewed as economic burdens. Patriarchal mindsets lead to coercion, control, and violence when dowry demands are unmet.
- Patrilocality: After marriage, women move into the husband’s family, often losing the immediate support system of their natal home, making them more vulnerable to abuse.
- Hypergamy & Caste Pressure: The desire to marry into higher-status families increases dowry expectations, particularly under existing caste and kinship systems.
- Social Acceptance & Fear of Shame: Dowry is often socially accepted. Families fear social stigma if they don’t comply, leading them to yield to pressure.
- Economic Factors
- Greed & Financial Gain: Marriages are frequently treated as opportunities for financial gain, with demands for cash, vehicles, or property from the groom’s side.
- Consumerism & Grand Weddings: Rising consumer culture and social media pressure for lavish weddings inflate dowry expectations.
- Unemployment & Income Insecurity: When grooms are unemployed or face financial insecurity, their families may view dowry as a means of achieving financial stability, intensifying demands.
- Women’s Financial Dependence: Despite legal rights to property, women often lack real control over money, making it difficult for them to resist or escape abuse.
- In 2022, 70% of charge-sheets were filed after two months, highlighting procedural inefficiencies.
- Lack of Legal Awareness: Many women, especially in rural areas, are unaware of their legal rights or fear retaliation.
- Illiteracy exacerbates their vulnerability.
- Inadequate Victim Support: There are insufficient shelters, or legal aid centers, leaving victims with few safe spaces to escape abuse.
- Normalization of Violence: Domestic abuse, including verbal, emotional, and physical cruelty, is often accepted as a part of marital life, keeping women silent.
- This normalization leads directly to dowry-driven murders, accounting for over 6,100 deaths between 2017 and 2022, primarily in West Bengal, Odisha, and Bihar.
Consequences of the Dowry System
- Severe Financial Burden on the Bride’s Family: Dowry demands often push families into debilitating debt, distress sales of assets, or long-term financial hardship, particularly among economically weaker sections.
- Gender-Based Abuse and Violence: Women face escalating physical, emotional, and psychological abuse when dowry expectations are unmet. This includes domestic violence, intimidation, and constant harassment by in-laws.
- Reinforcement of Patriarchal Norms: Dowry solidifies patriarchal structures, treating women as inferior and economically dependent, thereby perpetuating gender inequality from the very beginning of marriage.
- Marital Breakdown: Dowry-related conflicts frequently lead to discord, separation, or divorce, especially when disputes turn violent or demands remain unfulfilled.
- Dowry Deaths and Suicides: In extreme cases, prolonged torture and mental trauma result in dowry deaths, bride burning, or suicide, tragically often within the first few years of marriage.
- Women’s Financial Dependence: The dowry system undermines women’s control over assets and promotes economic dependency on husbands and in-laws, severely limiting their autonomy and decision-making power.
- Hindrance to Girls’ Education: Families may prioritize saving for dowry over investing in girls’ education, thereby limiting their personal growth, career opportunities, and life choices.
- Perpetuation of Harmful Stereotypes: The practice reinforces the demeaning belief that women are liabilities or commodities, eroding their dignity and personhood in both public and private spheres.
Key Challenges in Addressing Dowry Deaths
- Legal and Institutional Gaps
- Weak Law Enforcement: Laws like the Dowry Prohibition Act and Sections 80 & 86 of the BNS exist but are often poorly enforced.
- Low Conviction Rates: Despite thousands of reported cases, very few perpetrators are punished.
- Of the 6,500 cases sent to trial annually, only approximately 100 result in convictions, with the rest remaining pending or dismissed.
- Delayed Justice: Slow investigations and lengthy trials discourage families from pursuing justice. Only 4,500 of 7,000 annual cases are charge-sheeted, with many dismissed as “false” or facing investigation delays exceeding six months.
- Underreporting: Fear of social stigma, immense family pressure, and perceived police indifference often result in cases going unreported, especially in rural and conservative settings.
- Victim-Blaming & Social Pressure: Victims are frequently disbelieved, blamed for their situation, or pressured to reconcile, which silences complaints and undermines justice.
- Police-Judiciary Disconnect: Lack of coordination, slow charge sheet filing (often taking over two months), and mediation over legal action dilute the seriousness of the crime.
- Inadequate Investigations: Many cases are mishandled or dismissed for lack of evidence, often due to lack of police training in sensitive investigation or systemic biases, further eroding trust in the justice system.
Efforts to Combat Dowry Deaths
- Legal Provisions in India
- Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961: The cornerstone legislation that criminalizes both giving and receiving dowry. Its key provisions:
- Section 2 – Definition of Dowry: “Dowry” includes any property or valuable security given at, before, or after marriage, in connection with the marriage.
- Excludes: Mahr under Muslim Personal Law.
- Section 3 – Penalty for Giving or Taking Dowry: Minimum 5 years imprisonment and ₹15,000 fine (or value of dowry, whichever is higher) for giving, taking, or abetting dowry.
- Section 4 – Penalty for Demanding Dowry: Demanding dowry—directly or indirectly—is punishable with 6 months to 2 years imprisonment and up to ₹10,000 fine.
- Section 6 – Dowry for Wife’s Benefit: Dowry received by others must be transferred to the wife within time. If she dies, it goes to her heirs.
- Section 7 – Cognizance of Offences: Only Metropolitan or First-Class Judicial Magistrates can try dowry offences.
- Section 8A – Burden of Proof: In dowry cases, the accused must prove innocence once the prosecution establishes basic facts.
- Section 80, Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) (formerly IPC 304B): Defines and punishes dowry death.
- Section 86, Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) (formerly IPC 498A): Penalizes cruelty by husband or in-laws.
- Cruelty: As per Section 86 of the BNS (formerly IPC Section 498A), cruelty refers to any willful conduct that could drive a woman to commit suicide or cause grave harm to her physical or mental well-being.
- It also includes harassment aimed at coercing her or her family to fulfill unlawful demands for money or property, or harassment due to failure to meet such demands.
- Section 113B, Indian Evidence Act: Creates a legal presumption of dowry death under certain conditions, easing the burden of proof for the prosecution.
- Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA): Offers civil remedies to women facing domestic violence, including that linked to dowry demands, enabling them to seek protection orders, monetary relief, and other forms of support.
- Government Schemes and Initiatives
- Beti Bachao Beti Padhao (BBBP): Aims to empower girls through education and prevent child marriage. Indirectly, it counters the gender discrimination that often fuels dowry.
- Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana: Encourages families to save for their daughters’ future, potentially reducing financial burden and dowry-related pressures at the time of marriage.
- Pradhan Mantri Mahila Shakti Kendra (PMMSK): Offers legal aid, skill training, and counseling at the block level, supporting victims of gender-based violence, including dowry abuse.
- One Stop Centres (OSCs) – “Sakhi”: Established in every district to provide integrated support to women affected by violence, offering medical, legal, police, psychological, and shelter services under one roof.
- National Legal Services Authority (NALSA): Provides free legal aid and organizes awareness campaigns for women, supporting those facing dowry harassment or violence.
- Women Helpline (181) and Emergency Response Support System (ERSS – 112): 24/7 services for women facing violence, offering immediate assistance and referrals.
- Fast Track Special Courts (FTSCs): Set up to expedite trials of cases related to crimes against women, including dowry deaths.
- Mission Shakti: An integrated women empowerment program focusing on safety, security, and empowerment, encompassing schemes like the OSCs.
- Judicial Pronouncements
- S. Gopal Reddy v. State of A.P. (1996): Affirmed that both demanding and receiving dowry are punishable; highlighted the gender bias behind the practice.
- Vishaka vs. State of Rajasthan (1997): While primarily known for workplace sexual harassment guidelines, the Supreme Court in this context has repeatedly requested the Law Commission of India to take a “fresh look” to bring “more teeth” to the law against dowry.
- Satvir Singh v. State of Punjab (1998): Termed dowry a “social stigma” and emphasized the need for societal change alongside stronger legal enforcement.
- K. Prema S. Rao v. Yadla Srinivasa Rao (2003): Stressed the importance of effective implementation of laws and urged courts and police to act decisively.
- Sanjay Kumar Jain v. State of Delhi (2011): Supreme Court condemned dowry deaths as a “curse on society,” urging strict action to curb the menace.
- Rajesh Sharma v. State of U.P. (2017): Introduced safeguards against potential misuse of Section 498A, proposing Family Welfare Committees for pre-arrest scrutiny, though this has seen subsequent legal clarifications.
- State of Haryana v. Satbir Singh (2021): Expanded the interpretation of ‘cruelty’ under Section 498A (now Section 86 BNS) to include indirect and circumstantial evidence, strengthening victim protection.
- NGO Actions Against Dowry Deaths
- Breakthrough India: Runs community programs and campaigns (e.g., #DakhalDo) to challenge gender norms, promote legal awareness, and prevent dowry violence, engaging communities directly.
- All India Democratic Women’s Association (AIDWA): Focuses on grassroots mobilization, providing legal aid, and advocating for policy changes. It pressures governments for stricter anti-dowry implementation.
- Shakti Vahini: A proactive NGO working to prevent dowry-related violence, human trafficking, and gender-based exploitation. It engages in rescue operations, legal advocacy, and extensive awareness campaigns, especially in high-risk regions.
- Maitri: Works to empower women and prevent domestic violence, including dowry harassment. It provides counseling, legal support, and community engagement programs to foster safer environments for women.
- Women’s Legal Initiative (WLI): Focused on legal empowerment, WLI ensures access to justice for women facing dowry-related abuse and other forms of gender-based violence. It offers legal aid, rights education, and advocacy for systemic reforms.
- Jagori: Offers counseling, legal aid, and safe spaces for survivors of domestic violence. It emphasizes feminist education and rights awareness, working to shift mindsets.
- Sayfty: Utilizes digital platforms to promote self-defense, legal rights, and reporting mechanisms, encouraging young women to speak out against dowry culture.
- Direct Victim Support: Many NGOs provide essential services like shelter homes, crisis centers, medical assistance, and comprehensive rehabilitation programs for survivors.
- Economic Empowerment: They conduct skill development programs, facilitate microfinance, and offer livelihood support to help women achieve financial independence, thereby reducing their vulnerability to dowry demands.
International Framework Against Dowry-Related Violence
- Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), 1948: Establishes right to life, equality, and dignity (Articles 2, 3, 7), which are violated in dowry deaths.
- International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), 1966: Guarantees right to life (Article 6) and freedom from cruel treatment (Article 7)—applicable to dowry violence.
- Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), 1979: Acts as an international bill of rights for women. Dowry is seen as a form of gender-based discrimination (Article 2) and impacts marital rights (Article 16). State parties must enact laws to eliminate such practices.
- Declaration on the Elimination of Violence Against Women (DEVAW), 1993: Explicitly defines violence against women, including dowry-related abuse, and urges preventive, punitive, and protective state action.
- UN Women: Leads global efforts on gender equality, legal reform, and anti-dowry campaigns, and supports NGOs addressing violence against women.
- Beijing Platform for Action, 1995: Calls on states to prevent and respond to dowry-related violence through laws, services, and education.
|
Way Forward
- Strengthen Investigation & Fast-Track Justice: Prioritize timely charge-sheeting, enhance forensic capacity, and establish more fast-track courts to reduce judicial delays and increase conviction rates.
- Empower Women Economically: Scale up access to quality education, vocational skilling, and financial inclusion through schemes like Beti Bachao Beti Padhao, Mudra Yojana, and Sukanya Samriddhi.
- Strictly enforce laws like the RTE Act and PCMA (Prohibition of Child Marriage Act) to delay early marriages and promote women’s autonomy.
- Safe & Tech-Based Reporting: Launch and widely publicize anonymous digital portals and WhatsApp helplines. Crucially, ensure robust legal protection for complainants and whistleblowers to encourage reporting without fear of retaliation.
- Police Sensitization & Legal Enforcement: Provide specialized training to police to treat dowry-related cases with sensitivity and as serious criminal offenses.
- Ensure prompt FIRs, thorough investigations, and strict action against perpetrators from the outset, moving away from mediation in criminal cases.
- Shelters & Exit Support: Expand the network of district-level shelters, counseling services, legal aid centers, and livelihood support programs to provide safe havens and comprehensive assistance for women to safely leave abusive marriages.
- Community Vigilance & Legal Literacy: Promote grassroots awareness campaigns, form active community vigilance committees, and widely disseminate legal literacy programs to enable early intervention and support for victims.
- Targeted Social Reform: Launch sustained public awareness campaigns to de-normalize dowry, directly challenge patriarchal norms, and promote dignity-based marriages that celebrate equality over material demands.
- Engage men and boys as allies in this movement, emphasizing their crucial role in refusing dowry and advocating for gender equality.
- Leverage Education and Media: Integrate gender equality and anti-dowry education into school curricula from a young age. Encourage media to positively portray dowry-free marriages and actively challenge regressive social norms, rather than inadvertently promoting consumerism that fuels dowry.
Conclusion
Dowry deaths violate constitutional rights to equality (Article 14), life and dignity (Article 21), and obstruct SDG 5 (Gender Equality) and SDG 16 (Justice). Eliminating them requires legal enforcement, gender sensitization, and societal reform rooted in equality and dignity.
Read More About: Women’s Safety In India
Read More About: Violence Against Women in India/World
To get PDF version, Please click on "Print PDF" button.