Nobel laureate Kailash Satyarthi has emphasized that climate policies must integrate compassion to ensure that the socially and economically weak are not disproportionately affected. 

• Compassion in climate action ensures ethical policymaking, social justice, and sustainable development.

What is Compassion?

• It is a deeper level of empathy which involves not only understanding but also a desire to help alleviate the suffering of other persons. The emphasis here is on the action.
  • Empathy: It involves, first, seeing someone else’s situation from his/ her perspective, and, second, sharing that person’s emotions, including, if any, his distress.
  • Sympathy: It is an instinctive reaction to kindness that is momentary in nature. It is spontaneous and a real understanding of the problem is not there.

Need for Compassion in Climate Action

1. Unequal Vulnerability: Climate change impacts are unevenly distributed, disproportionately affecting women, low-income groups, indigenous communities, and marginalized populations.
   • According to World Bank report over 80% of India’s population lives in districts at risk from climate-induced disasters
2. Preventing Exacerbation of Inequalities: Without compassion, climate policies risk widening socio-economic disparities.
   • Example: Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana (PMUY) aims to provide clean cooking fuel to women in rural areas, reducing health risks associated with traditional cooking methods and empowering women.
3. Ethical Imperative: Compassion ensures ethical decision-making, reflecting moral responsibility to protect the weak and promote justice.
   • Kantian Ethics (Duty-based): Policies should be guided by moral duty to protect vulnerable groups, regardless of convenience or cost.
   • Ethics of Care: Emphasizes interdependence between humans, ecosystems, and future generations, ensuring policies nurture relationships and well-being.
4. Intergenerational Responsibility: Compassion promotes long-term sustainability, safeguarding resources and opportunities for future generations.
   • Example: Renewable energy and water management policies protect the environment for future citizens 
5. Inclusive Governance: Encourages participation of marginalized communities in policy-making, ensuring their voices are heard and needs addressed.
   • SHE Changes Climate India (SCC India) empowers women and marginalized communities by advocating for their inclusion in climate policy and decision-making to ensure gender-just transitions and equitable solutions to climate change

Ensuring Ethical Decision-Making 

1. Moral Responsibility: Policies driven by compassion reflect the ethical obligation to protect vulnerable groups.
   • Example: Ethical stocktake initiatives under COP30 evaluate whether climate actions reduce inequalities (UNFCCC, 2025).
2. Minimizing Harm: Climate policies often have unintended consequences; a compassionate approach anticipates and mitigates negative impacts.
   • Example: Renewable energy projects sometimes displace local communities; assessing social impact ensures fairness (ILO, 2024).
3. Human-Centric Approach: Compassion ensures that climate policies prioritize human well-being alongside environmental goals.

Challenges in Adopting Compassion in Climate Action

1. Conflicting Development Priorities: Compassionate policies often require balancing environmental protection with economic growth.
   • Example: Coal remains central to India’s energy security (coal ~55% of commercial energy, CEA 2023). Rapid phase-out could harm livelihoods (~6 million workers, NITI Aayog 2023).
   • Ethical Dilemma: Duty to protect vulnerable workers vs. obligation to mitigate climate change.
2. Resource Constraints and High Costs: Implementing equitable, compassionate policies (e.g., just transition, social safety nets) demands significant financial and institutional resources.
   • Data: India may require >$1 trillion over three decades to transition coal/thermal power sectors (Just Finance, 2024).
   • Ethical Challenge: Ensuring fairness while managing limited budgets.
3. Policy Gaps and Institutional Weaknesses: Existing climate policies frequently overlook marginalized groups’ needs.
   • Example: Urban climate adaptation plans often fail to address informal settlements or tribal communities (MoHUA, 2022).
   • Ethical Challenge: Upholding justice and equity within weak institutional frameworks.
4. Short-Term Political and Economic Pressures: Compassionate policies often require long-term thinking, but governments face short electoral cycles and industrial pressures.
   • Example: Fossil fuel subsidies persist despite climate targets due to political considerations (Ministry of Finance, 2023).
   • Ethical Dilemma: Balancing immediate citizen demands with long-term intergenerational ethics.
5. Cultural and Social Barriers: Ethical perspectives like compassion may conflict with entrenched practices, societal hierarchies, or profit-driven mindsets.
   • Example: Gendered access to clean energy or water remains unequal, limiting women’s participation in decision-making (UN Women India, 2023).
   • Ethical Challenge: Promoting inclusion and justice against systemic biases.
6. Complexity in Global Coordination: Global climate actions require coordination, yet principles like CBDR-RC and carbon debt (historical responsibility) complicate implementation of compassionate measures.
   • Example: India emphasizes that developed countries should lead just transitions to create equitable carbon space (COP29, 2024).
   • Ethical Dilemma: Ensuring fairness while negotiating across nations with differing priorities.

Way Forward

1. Institutionalize Justice and Equity: Climate policies must ensure fairness in burden-sharing and prioritize the most vulnerable.
   • Example: Just Transition Roadmap (NITI Aayog, 2023) incorporates equity and distributive justice by retraining ~6 million coal-sector workers.
2. Embed Integrity and Probity in Policy Implementation: Transparent and accountable frameworks prevent misuse of climate funds and ensure resources reach marginalized groups.
   • Example: Tracking mechanisms in PM-KUSUM ensure accountability in renewable energy subsidies.
3. Strengthen Empathy and Compassion in Governance: Policymakers must anticipate unintended harms and design safeguards for displaced communities and climate migrants.
   • Example: NDMA’s climate displacement data (~20 million annually) demands empathy-driven rehabilitation measures.
4. Promote Participatory and Inclusive Decision-Making: Citizen-centric governance involving women, indigenous groups, and local bodies enhances legitimacy.
5. Cultivate Emotional Intelligence among Policymakers: Training civil servants in self-awareness, compassion, and ethical reasoning ensures balanced decision-making in crisis situations.
   • Example: NCERT’s inclusion of empathy-based environmental education (2023) promotes long-term value-orientation.
6. Apply Gandhian Trusteeship and Sarvodaya: Corporate and political leaders should act as trustees of natural resources, ensuring welfare of all.
   • Example: CSR-linked renewable energy projects can prioritize energy access for the poorest households.

Conclusion

Compassion in climate action is not just moral but pragmatic. A compassionate approach to climate action is rooted in foundational values of ethics like justice, empathy, integrity, probity, transparency, accountability, and care for future generations. Such policies not only reduce inequalities but also foster trust, legitimacy, and social harmony.

• By aligning climate action with Gandhian values of sarvodaya, non-violence, trusteeship, and the Global Ethical Stocktake initiative, India can demonstrate that true climate leadership lies in integrating efficiency with ethics, science with humanity, and growth with justice.

DOWNLOAD PDF