India’s Second 1991 Moment: Trump’s Tariffs & Economic Reforms

PWOnlyIAS

April 12, 2025

India’s Second 1991 Moment: Trump’s Tariffs & Economic Reforms

US President Donald Trump’s reciprocal tariffs, targeting China (125%) and others (10%) is a potential turning point for India’s economy, similar to the 1991 economic reforms.

Tariffs

Trump Tariffs (TT)

  • US President Donald Trump announced reciprocal tariffs (April 2, 2025), targeting China (125%) and others (10%).
  • Aim: Counter China’s mercantilist policies (export-led growth, import restrictions, reserve accumulation).
  • These tariffs aim to reduce the US trade deficit, which currently stands at $1.2 trillion.
  • A base tariff of 10% applies to all countries, while country-specific tariffs are imposed from April 9.
  • The US has announced the suspension of additional tariffs on India for 90 days until July 9, 2025.

China’s mercantilism:

  • Mercantilism, an economic system prevalent from the 16th to 18th centuries, aimed to increase national wealth and power through a combination of government regulation and protectionist trade policies, emphasizing exports over imports. 
  • Export-led growth model: China maintained a consumption-to-GDP ratio of just 35% in 2010, prioritizing exports over domestic demand​.
  • World’s largest exporter: China’s share of global manufactured goods exports rose from 4% in 1996 to 30% today, reflecting its aggressive export strategy​.
  • Persistent trade surplus: China has sustained massive trade surpluses for decades, stockpiling foreign reserves — a classic mercantilist move.
  • Limited market access for imports: China imposes non-tariff barriers and subsidies to restrict imports while promoting domestic champions.
  • Strategic currency policy: The managed undervaluation of the yuan for years boosted export competitiveness and discouraged imports.

Geopolitical Reactions to US Tariffs

  • China’s resolute opposition: China will impose 125 per cent tariffs on US goods.
    • This comes after the US decided to pause tariffs for 90 days on many countries, but hit China with a 145 percent tariff amid the ongoing trade wars.
  • Japan opts for negotiated settlement: Japan chose a diplomatic route, sending a team to negotiate with the US. 
    • Its goal was to protect economic interests through peaceful dialogue.
  • EU considering both options: The EU adopted a balanced approach—open to negotiations while preparing retaliatory measures. 
    • It emphasized the importance of safeguarding its €1.5 trillion trans-Atlantic trade relationship.

India’s Stance on US Tariffs

Tariffs

  • Strategic Restraint: India did not retaliate against US tariffs; instead, it opted for dialogue and negotiation.
  • Bilateral Trade Agreement (BTA): Actively negotiating a BTA with the US to expand trade from $191 billion to $500 billion by 2030.
  • Government Response: Commerce Minister urged exporters to stay calm and emphasized India’s image as a trusted and stable trade partner.
  • Tariff Pause Advantage: US paused 26% reciprocal tariffs on India for 90 days (till July 9, 2025), recognizing India’s cooperative approach.
  • Opportunity Focus: India views the situation as a chance to boost manufacturing, attract investment, and integrate into global supply chains.

Impact on Indian Economy

  • Stock Market Volatility: Sensex plunged over 2,000 points on April 7, 2025, after tariff announcement.
    • Indian markets fell less than others but reflected global trade tension sensitivity​.
  • Export Sector Disruption: India faces a 26% reciprocal tariff; sectors like auto (3% of exports) and IT are hit.
    • Nifty IT fell by over 3% due to fears of reduced discretionary spending in the US​.
    • Though temporarily exempted, India’s $12.2B pharma exports to the US are vulnerable to future tariff hikes​.
  • Reduced Export Competitiveness: Higher tariffs increase product prices abroad, making Indian exports less competitive, especially in metals, electronics, and chemicals.
  • Pressure on Monetary Policy: RBI cut repo rate by 25 bps to 6% on April 9, citing global uncertainty and impact on exports​.
  • Risk of Inflation: Tariff-induced global inflation could spill into India via imported goods, affecting household budgets and input costs.
  • Uncertainty in FDI & Investor Sentiment: Unstable global environment may deter new investments.
    • India already saw FDI dip to <1% of GDP by 2025​.

1991 LPG Reforms (Liberalization, Privatization, Globalization)

  • LPG reforms, announced on July 24, 1991, marked a shift from a heavily regulated, socialist-inspired economy to a more market-oriented one.
  • The primary goals of the LPG reforms were to address the economic crisis, increase economic growth, and build foreign exchange reserves.
  • Liberalization: This involved reducing government control and regulations in various sectors, including industry, trade, and finance. 
    • This meant lowering tariffs, relaxing import restrictions, and allowing greater freedom for businesses.
  • Privatization: Ownership of government-owned enterprises transferred to the private sector
    • This was done through disinvestment and the encouragement of private sector participation in various industries.
  • Globalization: This involved opening up the Indian economy to international trade and investment. 
    • This included reducing trade barriers, attracting foreign direct investment, and integrating the Indian economy with the global market.

Opportunities for Indian Economy

  • Second 1991 Moment – Trigger for Reforms: External pressure provides the political cover needed to push trade, FDI, and industrial reforms​.
  • Boost to Manufacturing & PLI Schemes: US-China decoupling accelerates “China+1” strategy, India can attract global firms in electronics, pharma, and EVs.
    • Apple aims to shift 25% iPhone production to India by 2025.
    • PLI schemes target $520 bn manufacturing output by 2026.
  • Repositioning as Global Supply Chain Hub: China’s 125% US tariff creates space for India in manufacturing.
    • India is seen as a “trusted and reliable partner” in global trade​.
  • Boost to Bilateral Trade Talks with US: India–US BTA in progress, aiming to grow trade from $191B to $500B by 2030.
    • India’s non-retaliatory diplomacy helped pause the 26% tariff for 90 days​.
  • Greater Leverage in FTA Negotiations: Simultaneous FTA discussions with EU, UK, and CPTPP being explored.
    • India is now negotiating from a position of strategic necessity and opportunity.

The “China+1” strategy is a business approach where companies diversify their manufacturing and supply chain operations beyond China, rather than relying solely on it. 

  • Demographic & Workforce Edge: India’s prime-age (25-54), AI-ready workforce set to surpass China’s in coming years — making India more attractive to industries relocating from China​.
  • Textiles & MSME Export Boost: Indian textiles ($9.6B to US) may gain edge over China (21%) and Vietnam (19%) under new tariff regime​.
  • Rupee Trade Settlement Expansion: Rising dollar volatility and US-centric risk offers India a chance to expand rupee trade with Russia, Iran, UAE, Africa.
    • Reduces dollar dependency & improves sovereign economic autonomy.
  • Tech, Innovation & Startup Ecosystem Gains: India can attract venture capitalists (VC) and tech giants diversifying away from China.
    • Startup India, DPI (Digital Public Infrastructure), Open Network for Digital Commerce (ONDC), UPI have already created global interest.
  • Agricultural Market Access: Bilateral Trade Agreement (BTA) may open up US agri markets for Indian rice, spices, and organic produce.
    • Push for farm sector R&D and tech-backed productivity growth​.

Way Forward & Reforms Needed for India 

  • Trade Policy Modernization: India’s trade-weighted import duties (12%) are among the highest globally (vs. 2.2% US, 3% China).
    • High tariffs make Indian goods less competitive, inflate costs for domestic industries, and hinder integration into global value chains.
    • Pursue “zero-for-zero” industrial goods agreements, starting with the India-US BTA as a template for upcoming EU/UK deals and eventual CPTPP accession.
  • Reform and Liberalise FDI and BITs: FDI inflows have fallen below 1% of GDP, from 2–2.5% over two decades.
    • The 2015 “model” bilateral investment treaty (BIT) mandates Indian courts for dispute resolution — a major deterrent for foreign investors.
    • Revamp BITs to include neutral arbitration mechanisms and attract long-term capital investment​.
  • Deepen Trade Integration via Strategic FTAs: India’s global export share remains low (1.8% in 2023), far below China (15.4%).
    • Expedite trade agreements with the US, UK, EU, and consider joining the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP).
  • Reform Land, Labour, and Agriculture Laws: Outdated laws constrain ease of doing business and industrial competitiveness.
    • Rollback of 2020–21 farm laws under political pressure stalled essential agricultural reform.
    • Reintroduce these reforms with better consensus-building and implementation strategies​.
  • Boost Export-Oriented Manufacturing: Job creation in India depends on scaling manufacturing exports, especially in labour-intensive sectors like textiles and toys.
    • Make in India struggled due to protectionism and neglect of such sectors.
    • India holds just 6% of the US textile market, vs. Vietnam (19%) and China (21%). TT could shift supply chains — India must seize this opportunity​.
  • Invest in R&D and AI-Ready Workforce: India’s demographic dividend is peaking; its prime-age labour force will soon exceed China’s.
    • Invest in skilling, R&D, and digital infrastructure to ride the AI and innovation wave.
    • The West is increasingly looking at India as a counterweight to China; building a skilled, export-capable workforce is critical now​.
  • Diversify International Trade Partnerships: Resume and conclude negotiations for the long-pending India-EU Free Trade Agreement by 2026 to access Europe’s $18 trillion market, particularly for pharmaceuticals, IT services, and automotive exports.
    • Proactively lead developing nations in WTO reforms while expanding rupee trade settlements to 50+ countries, building on the successful Russia-UAE payment mechanisms that bypass dollar dependence.

Conclusion

India must leverage US-China trade tensions to push long-pending reforms. Strategic alignment with the West can accelerate growth to 8%+. Second 1991 moment hinges on bold economic policy shifts.

To get PDF version, Please click on "Print PDF" button.

Need help preparing for UPSC or State PSCs?

Connect with our experts to get free counselling & start preparing

Aiming for UPSC?

Download Our App

      
Quick Revise Now !
AVAILABLE FOR DOWNLOAD SOON
UDAAN PRELIMS WALLAH
Comprehensive coverage with a concise format
Integration of PYQ within the booklet
Designed as per recent trends of Prelims questions
हिंदी में भी उपलब्ध
Quick Revise Now !
UDAAN PRELIMS WALLAH
Comprehensive coverage with a concise format
Integration of PYQ within the booklet
Designed as per recent trends of Prelims questions
हिंदी में भी उपलब्ध

<div class="new-fform">






    </div>

    Subscribe our Newsletter
    Sign up now for our exclusive newsletter and be the first to know about our latest Initiatives, Quality Content, and much more.
    *Promise! We won't spam you.
    Yes! I want to Subscribe.