Answer:

BIMSTEC (Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation) is a regional organisation comprising Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Myanmar, Nepal, Sri Lanka, and Thailand. Formed in 1997, BIMSTEC aims to promote multifaceted technical and economic cooperation among its member states. With a combined GDP of over USD 3.8 trillion and a population of around 1.5 billion, BIMSTEC plays a crucial role in fostering regional integration and economic development.

BIMSTEC vs. SAARC: Why BIMSTEC Holds More Promise for India:

1. Geopolitical Stability: BIMSTEC excludes Pakistan, reducing geopolitical tensions that often hinder SAARC’s progress.
   For instance: SAARC summits are frequently postponed due to Indo-Pak conflicts, disrupting regional cooperation.
2. Economic Potential: BIMSTEC includes rapidly growing economies like Thailand and Myanmar, enhancing economic cooperation prospects.
   For example: Thailand’s robust manufacturing sector offers investment opportunities, boosting regional economic ties.
3. Focus Areas: BIMSTEC covers diverse sectors such as trade, technology, energy, and security, aligning with India’s strategic interests.
   For instance: Energy cooperation with Myanmar and Bangladesh enhances regional energy security and supports India’s energy needs.
4. Connectivity Projects: BIMSTEC prioritises connectivity projects which are vital for India’s Act East policy.
   For example: The Kaladan Multi-Modal Transit Transport Project improves connectivity with Myanmar, facilitating trade and movement.
5. Regional Balance: BIMSTEC bridges South Asia and Southeast Asia, providing a balanced regional platform.
   For example: Enhances India’s outreach to ASEAN countries, fostering greater regional integration and cooperation.

Reasons why BIMSTEC Cannot Replace SAARC:

1. South Asian Identity: SAARC represents the collective identity of South Asia, addressing unique regional challenges.
   For instance: Common issues like poverty and health crises are better addressed collectively through SAARC’s initiatives.
2. Established Mechanisms: SAARC has established mechanisms and frameworks for cooperation that BIMSTEC lacks.
   For example: SAARC Disaster Management Centre provides regional cooperation in disaster response and resilience.
3. Inclusivity: SAARC’s inclusivity ensures all South Asian nations, including Afghanistan and Maldives, have a platform.
   For instance: Addressing Afghanistan’s unique geopolitical issues through SAARC’s inclusive dialogue.
4. Conflict Resolution: SAARC offers a platform for dialogue and conflict resolution among South Asian countries.
   For instance: Promoting peace initiatives between India and Pakistan to resolve bilateral tensions.
5. Comprehensive Scope: SAARC’s broader agenda includes social, cultural, and environmental issues beyond economic cooperation.
   For example: SAARC Social Charter focuses on social development, addressing poverty, health, and education.

Way Forward:

1. Strengthen BIMSTEC Cooperation: Enhance collaboration in sectors like trade, technology, and security to maximise benefits.
   For instance: Establishing Centers of Excellence in member states to drive innovation and cooperation.
2. Leverage SAARC Framework: Utilise established SAARC mechanisms for addressing broader regional issues.
   For instance: Using SAARC’s health network for regional health crises, ensuring a coordinated response.
3. Complementary Roles: Promote complementary roles of BIMSTEC and SAARC to avoid redundancy and maximise regional benefits.
   For instance: SAARC focusing on social issues, BIMSTEC on economic integration for comprehensive regional development.
4. Promote Connectivity: Invest in regional connectivity projects to enhance economic integration and development.
   For instance: Expanding the BIMSTEC transport connectivity network to facilitate trade and movement.
5. Inclusive Dialogue: Facilitate inclusive dialogue platforms involving both BIMSTEC and SAARC members for comprehensive regional cooperation.
   For example: Joint forums for addressing cross-cutting issues like climate change and regional security.

BIMSTEC holds significant promise for enhancing regional integration and cooperation, particularly aligning with India’s strategic interests. However, it cannot fully replace SAARC due to its broader regional mandate and established frameworks. By fostering complementary roles and strengthening both organisations, South Asia can achieve holistic regional development and stability.

DOWNLOAD PDF