Answer

Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) is a system where government subsidies, welfare benefits, and payments are directly transferred to the bank accounts of beneficiaries, eliminating intermediaries. The system aims to enhance the efficiency of welfare programs, ensure transparency, and reduce leakages. However, it faces criticism for being politically motivated, especially during election periods.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) schemes aim to enhance social welfare but face criticism as election-time initiatives

• Efficient Targeting of Benefits: DBT helps in targeting benefits directly to the intended recipients, ensuring that welfare schemes reach the right people.
  For example: The PM-KISAN scheme, which transfers income support directly to farmers, ensures that subsidies are provided to eligible farmers, eliminating middlemen.
• Reduction in Corruption and Leakages: By bypassing intermediaries, DBT significantly reduces the chances of corruption and leakages, ensuring that benefits reach the poor and needy.
  For example: The implementation of DBTs amounting to Rs 34 lakh crore led to savings of Rs 2.7 lakh crore for the government, demonstrating the efficiency of DBTs in reducing financial mismanagement 
• Politicization of Welfare: DBT schemes are sometimes perceived as election-time tools used to influence voters, as governments roll out large welfare programs just before elections.
• Short-Term Focus: Critics argue that DBT schemes are often implemented with a short-term political focus, rather than long-term welfare planning.
• Limited Impact on Structural Issues: Critics claim that DBT may not address underlying structural issues such as poverty, unemployment, or inequality, which persist even after financial transfers.
  For example: Despite the widespread use of DBT in rural areas, malnutrition and lack of basic healthcare continue to be persistent issues in many parts of India.

Efficacy of DBTs in Achieving Long-Term Social Welfare

Achievable

• Promoting Efficient Welfare Delivery: DBT reduces dependency on middlemen and ensures that welfare funds reach the beneficiaries directly, promoting efficient use of public resources.
  For example: The DBT-based LPG subsidy scheme eliminated delays in fuel subsidies, benefitting poor households directly with timely transfers.
• Encouraging Financial Literacy: By incentivizing citizens to open bank accounts, DBT helps increase financial literacy and empowerment.
  For example: The Jan Dhan Yojana has opened more than 53 crore accounts, making financial services more inclusive for rural and urban populations alike.
• Promoting Inclusive Growth: DBT helps in targeting welfare for marginalized groups, improving access to healthcare, education, and housing for those in need.
  For example: The Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY) uses DBT to directly transfer funds for the construction of affordable housing, benefiting economically weaker sections.
• Long-Term Economic Growth: DBT reduces the burden on government departments and ensures more effective and transparent use of public funds, which can be reinvested in long-term social and economic development.
  For example: DBT-based schemes like Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) have helped enhance rural incomes and employment.

Concerns

• Exclusion Errors: One of the major challenges of DBT is exclusion errors, where eligible beneficiaries are not included in the scheme due to inaccurate data or poor targeting.
• Infrastructure Limitations: Many remote areas still lack basic banking infrastructure, making it difficult for citizens to access DBT benefits effectively.
• Unintended Disruption: The shift to DBT has caused disruptions for citizens who are not familiar with digital systems, leading to delays in benefit transfers.
  For example: Rural women under the Ujjwala Yojana faced challenges in receiving LPG subsidies due to banking issues during the initial rollout of DBT.
• Short-Term Benefits: While DBT provides immediate financial relief, it may not necessarily address long-term structural issues such as lack of jobs, quality education, or healthcare.
  For example: PM-KISAN provides direct income support, but it doesn’t solve the root problems of land ownership or agrarian distress.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store

Way Forward

• Improved Data Verification: Ensuring accurate beneficiary data and streamlining the identification process would reduce exclusion errors and enhance the targeting of benefits.
  For example: Implementing Aadhaar-based identification in rural areas can ensure better inclusion.
• Enhancing Digital Literacy: Increasing digital literacy and improving banking infrastructure in remote areas would make DBT schemes more accessible to marginalized populations.
  For instance: Providing mobile banking services in rural areas and conducting financial literacy programs can help bridge the digital divide.
• Long-Term Structural Reforms: Alongside DBT, addressing structural issues such as land reform, education, and healthcare will ensure sustainable growth.
  For instance: Linking DBT schemes to employment generation initiatives will provide long-term socio-economic security.
• Regular Auditing and Monitoring: Ensuring that DBT schemes are audited and monitored regularly would help identify and rectify issues such as delayed transfers and corruption.
  For instance: Independent monitoring bodies like the CAG (Comptroller and Auditor General) could regularly audit the effectiveness of DBT schemes.

To sustain the efficacy of Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) schemes beyond elections, robust beneficiary identification, seamless digital infrastructure, and continuous monitoring are crucial. Integrating DBTs with broader developmental policies and ensuring equitable access will enhance their role in achieving long-term social welfare. Additionally, the PM Jan Dhan Yojana (PMJDY) can further strengthen financial inclusion and ensure the equitable distribution of welfare benefits for lasting socio-economic development.

DOWNLOAD PDF