Answer:

Introduction:

The Election Commission of India (ECI) plays a crucial role in ensuring the integrity and fairness of India’s electoral process. However, while it possesses significant powers, it also faces certain limitations.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Body:

Powers of the Election Commission of India:

• Constitutional Authority: The ECI is a constitutional body, governed by Article 324 of the Indian Constitution, giving it the authority over the superintendence, direction, and control of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures, and the offices of the President and Vice-President​​.
• Appointment and Tenure: The President appoints the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners, who have a tenure of six years or up to the age of 65 years, enjoying the same status as Judges of the Supreme Court of India. The Chief Election Commissioner can only be removed through impeachment by Parliament​​.
• Advisory Jurisdiction and Disqualification Powers: The ECI can advise on post-election ineligibility of members of Parliament and State Legislatures and can recommend disqualification for dishonest practices at elections. It can also prohibit candidates who fail to lodge an account of their election expenses within the set time and manner​​.
• Delimitation and Electoral Rolls: It decides the territorial areas of electoral constituencies and organizes and amends electoral rolls. It also sets dates and schedules for elections, scrutinizes nomination papers, and grants recognition to political parties, allotting election symbols to them​​.
• Model Code of Conduct: The ECI issues the Model Code of Conduct during elections to maintain the decorum of democracy, regulates political parties, and monitors campaign expenditure limits​​.
• Appointment of Officers: The ECI appoints various officers like the Chief Electoral Officer, District Election Officer, Returning Officer, and Electoral Registration Officer to supervise election work at different levels​​.
• General Election Management: The Commission supervises, directs, controls, and conducts all elections to the Parliament and State Legislatures, as well as the offices of the President and Vice-President of India​​.

Limitations of the Election Commission of India:

• Crisis of Credibility and Inaction: Instances like the breach of the Model Code of Conduct during the 2019 general election raised concerns about the ECI’s effectiveness and its perceived inability to act decisively against powerful political entities​​.
• Lack of Autonomy in Appointments: The appointment of Election Commissioners by the government of the day can lead to perceptions of bias or obligation towards the appointing government, affecting the institution’s perceived independence​​.
• Vulnerability of Election Commissioners: The differing security of tenure between the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners can impact their independence and effectiveness. Proposals to rectify this issue have not been actioned​​.
• Limited Enforcement of Model Code of Conduct: The MCC, while influential, lacks legal enforceability, limiting the ECI’s capacity to impose significant penalties for violations​​.
• Inability to De-register Political Parties: Despite being the registering authority, the ECI does not have the power to de-register political parties, even for serious violations, limiting its control over party conduct​​.
• Challenges in Adapting to Modern Campaigning: The ECI needs to continually adapt to new forms of voter manipulation and campaigning, particularly in the digital age​​.
• Voter Awareness: While voter awareness initiatives like SVEEP and cVigil App are important, they place the onus of ensuring fair elections partly on voters, indicating a need for greater direct control by the ECI​​.

Conclusion:

The Election Commission of India, despite its extensive powers and constitutional mandate, faces significant challenges in maintaining its autonomy, credibility, and effectiveness. Addressing these limitations requires not only institutional reforms but also a commitment to uphold the principles of democratic fairness and integrity. The ECI’s continuous adaptation, enhanced enforcement capabilities, and strengthened legal framework are essential to ensure the conduct of free and fair elections in the world’s largest democracy.

DOWNLOAD PDF