Answer:

Introduction             

Probity in public service refers to adherence to the highest standards of ethical conduct, integrity, and honesty. It fosters public trust and effective governance, ensuring decisions are made impartially and transparently. This probity was exemplified by esteemed leaders like Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam and T.N. Seshan. 

Body 

Challenges to its implementation in Indian public service:

• Complex bureaucratic system: Layered administrative structures create delays, lack of accountability, and opportunities for discretion-based manipulation.Example: In the land acquisition process, multiple layers of approvals create delays and opportunities for rent-seeking through manipulation of documents or demands for bribes.
• Corruption: A primary challenge is pervasive corruption, undermining the principles of probity. Eg. high-profile cases like the 2G spectrum scandal illustrate how corruption can permeate the highest levels, leading to a significant loss of public funds and eroding trust in public institutions.
• Political Interference: Undue political influence often disrupts the impartial functioning of public services. Eg. The coal allocation scandal serves as a stark example where political intervention led to unethical distribution of resources, compromising fairness and transparency.
• Inadequate Accountability: The lack of strong accountability measures, as seen in the aftermath of the Commonwealth Games scandal, creates an environment where unethical behaviour can thrive without fear of repercussions, leading to misuse of power and public resources.
• Ineffective Whistleblower Protection: The risks faced by whistleblowers, exemplified by the challenges encountered by officers like Sanjiv Chaturvedi, highlight the need for stronger protective measures. Without such protections, potential whistleblowers may be deterred from exposing unethical practices.
• Poor Public Perception: Scams like Vyapam have contributed to a negative public perception of the public service sector, making it challenging to instill a culture of probity. Such perceptions can demotivate honest public servants and deter talented individuals from entering public service.
• Ethical Ambiguity: Situations with unclear legal directives, such as the ethical dilemmas faced by intelligence agencies in handling sensitive information, pose significant challenges. These ambiguities make it difficult for public servants to balance legal obligations with ethical considerations.
• Lack of transparency: Lack of transparency in decision-making processes facilitates rent-seeking behavior and hinders public scrutiny. Example: Non-transparent tender processes for government contracts create opportunities for bid rigging and manipulation by favored companies.

Measures that can be implemented to overcome these challenges: 

• Robust Accountability Systems: Strengthening institutions like the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) to ensure diligent oversight of government expenditures and actions can enhance accountability.
• Merit-Based Recruitment and Promotion: Ensuring fair and transparent recruitment processes in civil services can combat nepotism. The Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) exams in India are an example of a merit-based system that upholds ethical standards in recruitment.
• Streamlining Bureaucratic Processes: Initiatives like the e-Governance projects can reduce bureaucratic red tape, enhancing transparency and efficiency. Eg: Recently launched the Revamped Probity Portal for Government Employees ensures the right attitude towards public service. 
• Implementing Citizen’s Charters: These charters, outlining the services provided by government departments and the standards to be adhered to, like the ones used in Indian Railways, can enhance transparency and accountability in public service.
• Strengthening Anti-Corruption Laws: Enforcing stringent laws, similar to the Lokpal and Lokayukta Act, can deter corruption. The effectiveness of Lokayuktas in states like Karnataka in curbing corrupt practices serves as a model for other regions.
• Fostering a Positive Work Culture: Encouraging a culture of ethical behavior and efficiency in government departments, similar to the practices adopted in the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO), can significantly improve public service delivery.
• Adopting a Code of Ethics: Implementing a comprehensive code of ethics for public servants, as recommended by the 2nd Administrative Reforms Commission, would provide clear guidelines for ethical conduct in public service.
• Public awareness campaigns: Promoting a culture of anti-corruption through mass media campaigns and community engagement initiatives. Example: Launch targeted campaigns in local communities and media highlighting the negative consequences of corruption and promoting ethical values.

Conclusion

The implementation of probity, despite challenges, is achievable through robust reforms and systemic changes. Strengthening accountability, ensuring merit-based practices, enhancing transparency, and fostering an ethical culture will pave the way towards a more honest, efficient, and trustworthy public service, epitomizing the ideals of integrity and ethical governance.

DOWNLOAD PDF