Answer

India’s emphasis on undersea warfare capabilities highlights its strategic focus on strengthening naval power in the Indo-Pacific. With growing maritime ambitions, the country aims to enhance its deterrence capabilities and secure vital sea lanes. However, challenges like technological limitations, budgetary constraints, and dependence on foreign suppliers pose significant obstacles to achieving self-sufficiency in this critical area.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

India’s Pursuit of Undersea Warfare Capabilities and Maritime Aspirations

• Strategic Deterrence: India seeks credible nuclear deterrence to counter threats from adversaries like China and Pakistan through nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarines (SSBNs).
  For example: INS Arighaat, commissioned in 2024, enhances the nuclear triad, making India the only non-P5 nation operating SSBNs and SSNs.
• Securing Maritime Trade Routes: Protecting critical shipping lanes in the Indo-Pacific ensures free movement of goods and counters threats like piracy.
  For example: Operation Sankalp expanded to the Red Sea in 2024, showcasing India’s role in maritime security in strategic waters.
• Enhancing Regional Influence: Advanced undersea capabilities bolster India’s status as a preferred security partner in the Indo-Pacific and reinforce SAGAR principles.
  For example: Cooperation with friendly nations through joint naval exercises like Milan highlights India’s leadership in promoting maritime stability.
• Developing Indigenous Technology: Strengthening domestic defense manufacturing aligns with India’s push for self-reliance under Atmanirbhar Bharat, reducing dependency on foreign suppliers.
  For example: The Scorpene-class submarines under Project-75 feature 60% indigenous content, including advanced sonar systems and air-independent propulsion.
• Strategic Depth: Expanding capabilities in underwater warfare helps secure India’s maritime boundaries and counters rival naval advancements effectively.
  For example: Testing of the K-4 SLBM with a 3,500 km range places major parts of China within India’s strategic reach.
• Multilateral Collaboration: Partnerships with nations like Spain and Germany for submarine technology ensure global collaboration and capability enhancement.
  For example: Project 75(I) involves Thyssenkrupp Marine Systems and Navantia, incorporating transfer of technology and advanced submarine-building techniques.

Challenges in Indigenous Development and Budgetary Constraints

• Limited funding for long-term projects: India faces budgetary constraints in managing multiple large-scale defense projects with extended timelines.
  For example: The construction of nuclear-powered submarines like INS Arighaat is delayed due to the high costs involved in nuclear propulsion systems.
• Delayed technological advancements: India struggles to keep up with the rapid technological advancements in undersea warfare, affecting the pace of indigenization.
  For example: Project-75(I) for AIP-enabled submarines is delayed due to prolonged technical evaluations and challenges in transferring technology from foreign partners.
• Lack of skilled workforce: Indigenous defense manufacturing is hindered by a shortage of highly skilled engineers and specialists needed for advanced military technologies.
• Increased dependency on foreign partners: While India seeks to increase indigenous content, some critical technologies still depend on foreign partners, limiting full self-reliance.
  For example: The Scorpene-class submarines under Project-75 required technology transfer from France, reflecting India’s reliance on foreign expertise for complex defense systems.
• Bureaucratic delays: Lengthy procurement processes and administrative hurdles slow down the progress of defense modernization projects.
  For example: The Cabinet Committee on Security took years to approve Project-77 for SSN construction, delaying the acquisition of nuclear-powered attack submarines.

Balancing Competing Demands for Naval Power in the Indo-Pacific

• Addressing Budgetary Constraints: Efficient allocation of resources and sustained funding are crucial for long-gestation projects like nuclear-powered submarines and unmanned underwater vehicles.
  For example: The ₹40,000 crore P-77 project for SSNs requires long-term financial commitment to deliver India’s first indigenous SSN by 2036-37.
• Streamlining Processes: Simplifying acquisition procedures reduces delays and ensures timely induction of critical systems for operational readiness.
  For example: Faster tender evaluations for Project 75(I) will accelerate induction of AIP-enabled submarines, ensuring capability upgrades to counter growing threats.
• Promoting Indigenous Content: Increasing local manufacturing content reduces costs and enhances self-reliance, aligning with Atmanirbhar Bharat goals.
  For example: The sixth Scorpene-class submarine, INS Vaghsheer, showcases over 60% indigenous content, including critical subsystems like sonar and propulsion.
• Expanding International Cooperation: Collaborating with global partners provides access to advanced technologies while maintaining strategic autonomy in the Indo-Pacific.
  For example: Agreements with France, Germany, and Spain facilitate the transfer of submarine-building expertise under Project 75 and 75(I).
• Investing in Niche Technologies: Focused R&D in technologies like unmanned underwater vehicles ensures high returns on investment while addressing diverse operational challenges.
  For example: Development of 100-tonne UUVs with ₹2,500 crore funding strengthens low-cost surveillance and anti-submarine warfare capabilities.
• Maintaining Operational Balance: Integrating nuclear and conventional submarine forces ensures versatility, with each platform catering to specific mission requirements.
  For example: INS Arighaat complements conventional submarines like INS Vaghsheer, creating a balanced underwater warfare fleet.

Measures to Maintain India’s Position as a Credible Naval Power

• Focus on strategic partnerships: India should prioritize strategic collaborations with trusted international partners to enhance its naval capabilities.
  For example: India’s cooperation with France under Project-75 has led to the successful development and induction of Scorpene-class submarines.
• Increasing indigenous content in defense projects: India should enhance domestic production by investing in research and development to reduce dependency on foreign suppliers. 
• Streamlining defense procurement processes: India must simplify bureaucratic procedures to expedite procurement and reduce delays in acquiring critical naval platforms. 
• Investing in advanced technology and innovation: India should continue investing in niche technologies like Unmanned Underwater Vehicles (UUVs) for cost-effective solutions to maritime security challenges. 
• Enhancing naval training and human resource development: India should focus on building a skilled workforce for defense manufacturing and operational management in advanced naval technologies.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store

India must adopt a phased approach, focusing on strategic partnerships for technology transfer and joint development while simultaneously investing in indigenous R&D to ensure self-reliance. Budgetary constraints can be mitigated through prioritizing high-impact projects and leveraging private sector innovation. By balancing these efforts, India can solidify its naval strength and maintain a dominant position in the Indo-Pacific.

DOWNLOAD PDF