India’s industrial growth over the past few decades has positioned the country as a major global manufacturing hub. However, this rapid industrialization has been accompanied by recurring industrial accidents, underscoring significant deficiencies in factory inspection mechanisms. The recent explosion in a chemical unit in Thane, Maharashtra, which tragically killed 11 people, has brought these issues back into sharp focus.

Current State of Factory Inspection in India:

• Low Inspection Rates: Low inspection rates lead to unchecked safety violations and hazardous conditions, increasing the risk of industrial accidents and undermining worker safety.
  For instance:  In 2021, only 14.65% of registered factories and 26.02% of hazardous factories nationwide were inspected.
• Inadequate Staffing: The number of factory inspectors is insufficient relative to the vast number of factories, leading to infrequent and superficial inspections.
  For instance:  The appointment rate for sanctioned officer positions across India was only 67.58%, indicating a severe shortage of personnel contributing to the low inspection rates.
• Selective Enforcement: Enforcement is sometimes selective, influenced by political and economic pressures, leading to uneven application of safety standards.
  For example: Fire at the Anaj Mandi factory in Delhi in December 2019. Despite safety regulations, the factory lacked proper fire safety measures and clearances. Inspections were reportedly lax, influenced by political and economic pressures, leading to the tragedy that claimed 43 lives.
• Outdated Legislation: The primary legislation governing factory inspections, the Factories Act of 1948, is outdated and does not adequately address the complexities of modern industrial operations.

Challenges in Factory Inspections in India:

• Bribery and Collusion: Corruption is a significant issue, with reports of inspectors accepting bribes to overlook violations, which undermines the integrity of the inspection process. 
• Skill Gaps: Many inspectors lack specialised training in the latest industrial safety standards and technologies, reducing their effectiveness in identifying and mitigating risks.
  For instance: The 2020 gas leak at the LG Polymers plant in Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, revealed that many factory inspectors lacked specialised training in the latest industrial safety standards and technologies.
• Weak Penalties: Penalties for non-compliance with safety regulations are often too lenient to deter violations,resulting in many factories finding it more economical to pay fines rather than implement necessary safety measures, undermining the deterrent effect of regulations.
• Lack of Accountability: There is little accountability for inspectors who fail to perform their duties effectively, often resulting in continued unsafe practices in factories.
  For example : In a 2021 Dhampur Sugar mills case in Uttar Pradesh, repeated safety violations were found despite regular inspections, with no consequences for the inspectors who failed to enforce regulations.
• Limited Worker Involvement: Workers often have little involvement in safety committees or inspection processes, leading to a lack of grassroots input on safety issues. 
• Insufficient Investment in Worker Safety: In an effort to cut costs, some industries often neglect essential safety equipment and infrastructure, such as proper ventilation and fire safety measures.
  For example: A 2023 IIT Kanpur study highlights the critical need for increased investment in worker safety to reduce industrial accidents.
• Underutilization of Technology: The potential of modern technologies, such as IoT and AI, to enhance safety, monitoring and predictive maintenance is largely untapped within the current inspection framework. 
• Neglected Maintenance: Failing to maintain equipment and systems leads to deterioration, increasing the risk of malfunctions and failures.
  For example: Neyveli thermal power plant accident in Tamilnadu where a boiler unexpectedly exploded while being revived, highlights critical failures in maintaining equipment.

Way Forward:

• Increase Inspector Staffing: Hire and train more inspectors to ensure adequate coverage and reduce the burden on existing staff, enabling more frequent and thorough inspections. 
• Enhance Training Programs: Implement continuous training programs for inspectors to keep them updated on the latest industrial safety standards and technologies.
  For instance: The National Safety Council of India (NSCI) highlights that comprehensive training programs with regular drills are critical to reducing industrial accidents.
• Strengthen Anti-Corruption Measures: Establish stringent anti-corruption policies and regular audits to prevent bribery and collusion, ensuring integrity in the inspection process.
  For instance: According to a report of Transparency International ,robust anti-corruption frameworks in Chile have significantly reduced corruption in industrial inspections.
• Improve Accountability Mechanisms: Introduce robust accountability measures for inspectors, including performance evaluations and penalties for negligence, to ensure thorough and responsible inspections.
  For instance: Clearly defined responsibilities for both employers and employees regarding safety, as outlined in the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020 
• Increase Penalties for Non-Compliance: Implement stricter penalties for safety violations to deter non-compliance and encourage factories to adopt necessary safety measures rather than opting to pay fines.
  For instance: The IIM Ahmedabad report on Industrial accidents highlights the need for improved enforcement to prevent industrial accidents.
• Promote Worker Involvement: Encourage worker participation in safety committees and inspection processes to ensure grassroots input on safety issues. 
• Leverage Modern Technology: Invest in IoT and AI technologies for safety monitoring and predictive maintenance, enabling more efficient and proactive identification of potential hazards. 
• Centralised Data Management: Create a centralised, computerised database to store the list of hazardous materials and the inventory of major hazard workplaces.
  For example: OECD promotes the Global Harmonized System of Classification and Labelling of Chemicals (GHS) to standardise risk assessments and improve compliance.
• Public Transparency: Increase transparency by publicly disclosing inspection reports and safety records of factories, promoting accountability and encouraging better compliance with safety regulations. 

The recurring industrial accidents highlight significant challenges, including inadequate staffing, insufficient training, corruption, outdated legislation, and limited worker involvement. Addressing these shortcomings requires a comprehensive approach, incorporating international best practices, robust regulatory frameworks, enhanced accountability, and leveraging modern technologies. By adopting these measures, India can improve its industrial safety standards, protect its workforce, and sustain its economic growth with a more secure and compliant industrial environment.

DOWNLOAD PDF