Answer

Despite significant advancements in science and technology, no Indian scientist based in India has won a Nobel Prize in the past 94 years, highlighting a persistent challenge in the country’s research ecosystem. The last laureate, C.V. Raman, won the Physics Nobel in 1930. Although several Indian-origin scientists have been awarded while working abroad, this gap underscores the need for a stronger research infrastructure.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Challenges within the Indian Research Ecosystem

• Lack of Focus on Basic Research: India prioritises applied research with immediate economic benefits over fundamental research, which is essential for scientific breakthroughs.
  For example: India’s investment in basic research is significantly lower compared to countries like the U.S. and Germany.
• Low Public Funding for Research: Limited funding hampers infrastructure and innovation, with inadequate resources for researchers.
  For example: India spends only around 0.7% of its GDP on R&D, much lower than China’s 2.1%.
• Bureaucratic Red Tape: Excessive administrative hurdles slow down the research process, discouraging innovation and creativity.
  For example: Researchers often face long delays in acquiring approvals for grants, hindering progress.
• Limited Private Sector Involvement: The private sector in India invests relatively little in R&D, limiting opportunities for groundbreaking research.
  For example: Unlike companies like Google or IBM, Indian firms focus less on high-risk, high-reward research initiatives.
• Underperforming Research Institutions: Indian universities prioritise teaching over research, and even top institutes underperform globally.
  For example: No Indian university ranks in the top 50 of the QS World University Rankings for research output.
• Small Talent Pool: India has a lower number of researchers per capita compared to global averages, reducing its potential for scientific breakthroughs.
  For example: India has only 255 researchers per million people, far below the United States’ 4245.
• Outdated Curriculum and Methods: Research in India is often held back by outdated teaching methods and a lack of exposure to global best practices.
  For example: Many institutions continue to follow traditional academic curricula without incorporating emerging technologies.

Other Underlying Factors

• Nobel Prize Nomination Process: The process for Nobel nominations is highly selective and not always transparent, limiting Indian nominations.
  For example: Renowned Indian scientists like S.N. Bose and Homi Bhabha were nominated multiple times but never won.
• Brain Drain: Many top Indian scientists move abroad for better research opportunities, reducing the talent pool within India.
  For example: Hargobind Khorana and Venkatraman Ramakrishnan won Nobel Prizes after relocating to the U.S. and U.K., respectively.
• Lack of Interdisciplinary Research: Indian research often lacks collaboration across disciplines, which is crucial for innovative discoveries.
  For example: Countries like the U.S. promote interdisciplinary research through institutes like the MIT Media Lab.
• Global Competition: India faces stiff competition from global research powerhouses like the U.S. and Europe, which have long dominated the Nobel landscape.
  For example: Over 80% of Nobel Prizes in Physics, Chemistry, and Medicine have been awarded to scientists from Europe and North America.
• Bias and Regional Disparities: Some argue that the Nobel Prize process is biased toward Western countries, though this claim remains controversial.
  For example: Israel and South Korea have also struggled to secure Nobel Prizes despite strong research capabilities.

Way Ahead

• Increase Funding for Basic Research: India must increase its investment in basic research to match global standards and foster scientific innovation.
  For example: Increasing public funding to at least 2% of GDP would bring India closer to countries like China in research.
• Encourage Private Sector Participation: The government should incentivize private companies to invest more in research and development.
  For example: Tax breaks for R&D investment, as seen in South Korea, could encourage Indian firms to contribute to research.
• Simplify Bureaucratic Processes: Streamlining administrative procedures and reducing bureaucratic hurdles can help researchers focus more on innovation.
  For example: Implementing a single-window clearance system for research grants and projects.
• Strengthen University-Industry Collaboration: Improving partnerships between universities and industries would bridge the gap between research and practical applications.
  For example: Collaborations like the Stanford-Silicon Valley model can be replicated in India.
• Foster a Research-Oriented Education System: A greater emphasis on research-based education will help develop the next generation of Indian scientists.
  For example: Programs like the INSPIRE Fellowship encourage students to pursue research careers.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store

To improve its global scientific standing and boost its chances of future Nobel laureates, India must focus on building a robust research ecosystem. This involves increasing funding, reducing bureaucratic hurdles, and fostering innovation through public-private partnerships. Strengthening basic research and interdisciplinary collaboration will help India achieve scientific breakthroughs and secure a Nobel Prize.

DOWNLOAD PDF