Answer

The Palk Bay is a narrow stretch of water between India and Sri Lanka, vital for both countries’ fisher communities due to its rich marine resources. However, disputes have frequently arisen due to overfishing, environmental degradation, and conflicting fishing practices. The Palk Bay dispute presents complex challenges that impact livelihoods and bilateral relations. Addressing these requires cooperation and sustainable practices involving local communities on both sides.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Major Challenges in Addressing the Palk Bay Fishing Dispute

• Conflicting Fishing Practices: Indian fishermen primarily use bottom trawling, a technique harmful to the seabed and marine resources, which is prohibited in Sri Lanka. This practice has led to tension between the two nations.
  For example: Indian trawlers are often seized by Sri Lankan authorities due to illegal trawling activities, straining diplomatic relations.
• Frequent Arrests of Fishermen: Indian fishermen frequently cross into Sri Lankan waters, leading to arrests and detention, creating humanitarian concerns and tension between governments.
  For example: The Ministry of External Affairs has reported multiple cases of Indian fishermen detained by Sri Lankan authorities, affecting the livelihoods of fishing communities.
• Depletion of Marine Resources: Overfishing and trawling practices have led to significant depletion of fish stocks in the Palk Bay, reducing income for both Indian and Sri Lankan fishermen and pushing them further into each other’s territories.
  For example: Studies by India’s National Institute of Ocean Technology indicate declining fish stocks, causing greater competition and conflict.
• Political Sensitivities: The issue is sensitive due to national pride and concerns over sovereignty, making it difficult for both countries to reach a consensus and take meaningful action.
  For example: Local political leaders often highlight the issue, advocating for the rights of their fishermen, which complicates diplomatic efforts.
• Environmental Damage: Trawling damages the marine ecosystem, including the coral reefs and seabed, which are critical for maintaining marine biodiversity in the Palk Bay.
  For example: Reports from the Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute (CMFRI) highlight that trawling has led to the destruction of natural habitats, impacting biodiversity.
• Lack of Mutual Agreements on Boundaries: The International Maritime Boundary Line (IMBL) is often crossed inadvertently by Indian fishermen due to the narrow width of the Palk Strait, resulting in disputes over territorial waters.
  For example: Fishermen argue that the 1974 IMBL agreement has failed to consider traditional fishing grounds, leading to frequent boundary disputes.
• Economic Dependence on Fishing: Many communities on both sides of the Palk Bay rely heavily on fishing as their primary livelihood, making it hard for fishermen to shift to alternative income sources.
  For example: Government records show that thousands of families in Tamil Nadu depend on fishing, highlighting the economic stakes involved in the dispute.

Role of Joint Approach Involving Fisher Communities for Sustainable Resolution

• Cross-Border Dialogue Platforms: Engaging fisher communities in regular dialogue fosters understanding and helps build trust, enabling shared solutions to emerge that respect each community’s needs.
  For example: The India-Sri Lanka Fishermen’s Forum has facilitated exchanges that allow fishermen to voice their concerns, fostering cooperative strategies.
• Promoting Sustainable Fishing Practices: Both governments can work together to promote sustainable practices, such as banning trawling and encouraging alternative fishing methods that preserve marine resources.
  For example: Tamil Nadu and Northern Province officials have explored sustainable practices, aiming to balance ecological protection with livelihood needs.
• Collaborative Marine Conservation: Involving local communities in conservation projects can help protect the ecosystem while ensuring that fishermen understand the importance of sustainable resource use.
  For example: Initiatives by the Indian Ocean Tuna Commission (IOTC) include community-led conservation efforts that help regulate fishing practices.
• Introducing Joint Monitoring Mechanisms: Deploying joint patrols and surveillance can help reduce territorial disputes by preventing fishermen from crossing the boundary inadvertently, ensuring compliance on both sides.
• Developing Livelihood Alternatives: Introducing programs that provide alternative income sources, like aquaculture or eco-tourism, can lessen the reliance on fishing, reducing pressure on marine resources.
  For example: Tamil Nadu’s Department of Fisheries has initiated pilot projects on seaweed farming as an alternative income source for fishermen.
• Joint Training and Awareness Programs: Educating fishermen about sustainable practices and the consequences of overfishing can lead to greater awareness and voluntary compliance with eco-friendly practices.
  For example: Workshops conducted in collaboration with the Bay of Bengal Programme (BOBP) have helped fishermen adopt sustainable fishing methods.
• Empowering Local Leadership: Empowering leaders within the fisher communities to mediate disputes and ensure adherence to agreed-upon practices helps in conflict resolution at a grassroots level.
  For example: Local leaders from Tamil Nadu and the Northern Province of Sri Lanka have been instrumental in de-escalating tensions and promoting dialogue among fishermen.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store

A collaborative approach involving fisher communities is essential for resolving the Palk Bay fishing dispute sustainably. By integrating local voices, fostering sustainable practices, and encouraging cross-border cooperation, India and Sri Lanka can protect the ecology of the Palk Bay while preserving livelihoods. This multi-stakeholder approach holds the potential to transform a conflict-ridden area into a model of shared resources and cooperation between the two nations.

DOWNLOAD PDF