Answer

Internal democracy within political parties is essential for ensuring the participatory nature of the political system in India. The absence of internal democratic processes undermines transparency, accountability, and citizens’ confidence in the system. Reports from bodies like the Election Commission of India and Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) reveal the alarming lack of internal elections, leading to centralized power within parties, which disrupts democratic practices.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Absence Of Internal Democracy Within Political Parties Undermines The Democratic Process In India

• Centralized Power: Internal democracy ensures leadership is accountable, but family-driven parties concentrate power, stifling new leadership.
• Nepotism and Favoritism: Absence of internal elections fosters favoritism, breeding corruption and unqualified leadership.
• Reduced Accountability: Without transparent decision-making, leaders are unaccountable, making governance ineffective.
• Fragmentation of Parties: Lack of ideological clarity and internal unity results in divisions, weakening the party’s foundation.
• Public Disillusionment: When parties don’t function democratically, citizens lose trust in the political system, affecting voter turnout.

Analyze The Challenges In Ensuring Internal Democracy In Political Parties

• Dynastic Politics: Family-centric leaderships discourage open elections and participation from diverse members, stifling leadership competition.
  For example: DMK’s succession struggles often prevent newer voices from rising, as family members dominate crucial party positions.
• Centralized Financial Control: Family-dominated parties control party funds, limiting financial transparency and accountability.
  For example: TMC’s centralized financial structure discourages party workers from independent fund-raising, concentrating decision-making in the hands of a few.
• Lack of Party Election Regulations: Inadequate legal framework allows political parties to operate without mandatory internal elections, making reforms difficult.
  For example: Despite reforms, CPI(M) continues to see undemocratic internal appointments due to the lack of a legal structure mandating regular leadership elections.
• Internal Resistance to Change: Established leaders and family members resist reforms, fearing a loss of control.
  For example: NCP’s internal resistance to electoral reforms often prevents young members from assuming leadership roles, ensuring dynastic control remains intact.
• Low Public Participation: Voter apathy and lack of awareness about party dynamics reduce pressure on parties to democratize internally.
  For example: In Bihar, voter participation remains low in local elections, as many see party leadership as fixed by family ties rather than merit.

Suggest measures to make them more transparent and participatory

• Mandatory Internal Elections: Introduce legal mandates requiring regular internal elections in political parties to ensure democratic leadership selection.
  For example: The Congress Party should implement regular leadership elections to open avenues for emerging leaders, reducing dynastic control.
• Financial Transparency: Political parties should publish annual financial reports and disclose all sources of funding to promote transparency
• Decentralization of Power: Empower state and district-level leaders to make crucial decisions, reducing centralization and ensuring wider participation.
• Formation of an Independent Election Commission for Parties: Establish an independent body to oversee elections within political parties, ensuring fairness.
  For example: The Election Commission of India can extend its role to include party elections, reducing internal manipulation and fostering democratic values.
• Public Involvement in Decision-Making: Enable party members and the public to participate in key decisions through online platforms or public consultations.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store

To strengthen internal democracy, it is crucial to enforce laws requiring regular internal elections and transparency in party funding. Measures like public disclosure of party decision-making processes, implementing the RTI Act in political parties, and enhancing electoral reforms can make political parties more inclusive and accountable, aligning with democratic ideals. The Election Commission’s intervention in this matter will be vital.

DOWNLOAD PDF