Books & Magazines
Core Demand of the Question
|
The Indian independence movement saw diverse approaches, with leaders like Mahatma Gandhi advocating non-violence (ahimsa) and Bhagat Singh endorsing revolutionary resistance. While Gandhi’s ideology was rooted in truth (satyagraha) and civil disobedience, Bhagat Singh’s vision aligned with socialist revolution. Their contrasting strategies reflected deeper ideological debates shaping India’s freedom struggle.
| Aspect | Mahatma Gandhi | Bhagat Singh |
| Approach to Resistance | Gandhi advocated non-violence (Ahimsa) and civil disobedience to challenge British rule without bloodshed.
For example: The Dandi March (1930) was a peaceful protest against the salt tax, mobilizing masses without violent confrontation. |
Bhagat Singh believed in revolutionary methods to overthrow colonial rule and inspire mass resistance.
For example: The 1929 Assembly Bombing was meant to “make the deaf hear” without harming anyone but using direct action. |
| Philosophy of Change | Gandhi promoted gradual reform, believing in moral transformation of both oppressors and the oppressed.
For example: He sought reforms through dialogue, as seen in the Gandhi-Irwin Pact (1931), negotiating prisoner releases and civil disobedience terms. |
Bhagat Singh emphasized swift, radical change, rejecting appeals to the conscience of oppressors.
For example: He believed that revolutions require destruction of old oppressive systems to build new ones. |
| Role of Masses | Gandhi emphasized mass participation, mobilizing farmers, workers, and common people through non-cooperation and peaceful protests.
For example: The Non-Cooperation Movement (1920-22) engaged millions in boycotts, protests, and resignations from government jobs. |
Bhagat Singh believed in vanguard leadership, where youth and revolutionaries lead radical actions to awaken the masses.
For example: The Hindustan Socialist Republican Association (HSRA) was a small but dedicated group planning targeted revolutionary activities. |
| Vision for India | Gandhi sought a decentralized, self-sufficient village economy, based on Khadi, rural industries, and moral values.
For example: He promoted Swadeshi and Khadi, urging people to spin their own cloth instead of buying British goods |
Bhagat Singh envisioned a socialist India, eliminating economic disparity and abolishing class oppression.
For example: His pamphlet “To Young Political Workers” called for land redistribution and the end of capitalist exploitation. |
| View on British Rule | Gandhi wanted a peaceful transition to self-rule (Swaraj) without hostility, hoping for future cooperation with the British.
For example: He cooperated with the British in Round Table Conferences (1931), seeking gradual power transfer. |
Bhagat Singh saw British rule as inherently oppressive, advocating complete and violent overthrow of colonial structures.
For example: The Killing of Saunders (1928) was meant to directly punish British repression, rejecting dialogue. |
| Conflict Area | Gandhi’s View | Bhagat Singh’s View |
| Use of Violence | Gandhi strictly opposed violence, believing it corrupts both the victim and perpetrator, leading to an endless cycle of revenge.
For example: Gandhi condemned the Chauri Chaura incident (1922) and suspended the Non-Cooperation Movement after protesters killed police officers. |
Bhagat Singh saw violence as a necessary tool for revolution and a justified response to colonial oppression.
For example: Bhagat Singh defended revolutionary actions, justifying violence as a way to awaken the masses against British rule |
| Dealing with the British | Gandhi believed in negotiation and moral appeal, seeing the British as potential partners in India’s future.
For example: The Gandhi-Irwin Pact (1931) was a settlement that Gandhi agreed to despite British betrayal. |
Bhagat Singh considered the British irredeemable oppressors who had to be forcibly removed from India.
For example: He mocked negotiations, insisting that revolutionaries must directly overthrow colonial rule. |
| Economic Vision | Gandhi promoted self-sufficient rural economies, emphasizing handicrafts, cottage industries, and local production.
For example: Gandhi founded the All India Village Industries Association to promote rural crafts and self-reliance. |
Bhagat Singh envisioned industrialization and socialism, with state control over key industries to ensure economic equality.
For example: He called for abolishing landlordism and capitalism, arguing that wealth should belong to the workers. |
| Public Mobilization | Gandhi focused on mass mobilization through non-violent movements, engaging millions of Indians.
For example: The Civil Disobedience Movement (1930) united peasants, students, and workers against British laws. |
Bhagat Singh believed in selective revolutionary action, where small groups took bold steps to inspire the masses.
For example: The Assembly Bombing (1929) was meant to ignite fearless defiance in people. |
“The paths may be different, but the destination remains the same.” Gandhi’s philosophy of nonviolence and Bhagat Singh’s revolutionary zeal were two sides of the same coin, both driven by a vision of a free India. Their combined legacy shaped the spirit of India’s independence, blending resistance with resilience to achieve sovereignty.
To get PDF version, Please click on "Print PDF" button.
Connect with our experts to get free counselling & start preparing
Download Our App
Download Our App
Books & Magazines
Prelims Wallah (Q&A Bank)
Udaan
Udaan 500+
Budget & Economic Survey
Monthly Current Wallah
Weekly Current Wallah
Editorial Summary
Editorial Q&A Compilation
NCERT Wallah
Prahaar (Mains Wallah)
Marks Booster
Mains Wallah (Q&A Bank)
<div class="new-fform">
</div>
March 7, 2025
0
Latest Comments