Answer

Introduction

The United Nations (UN) was established in 1945 to prevent wars, uphold international law, and promote global cooperation. While it has achieved notable successes such as averting a third world war, its effectiveness has increasingly come under scrutiny due to structural, financial, and geopolitical challenges.

Body

Factors Contributing to the Declining Effectiveness of the UN

• Veto Power of Permanent Members: Any of the five permanent members (US, UK, Russia, China, France) can block resolutions, limiting UN’s ability to act in crises.
  Eg: UN could not deploy peacekeepers in Ukraine in 2014 due to Russia’s veto.
• Overreliance on Major Contributors: Heavy financial dependence on countries like the US and China makes the UN vulnerable to political or budgetary decisions of these nations.
  Eg: Proposed 2026 US budget aims to cut UN financing by over 80%, threatening SDG implementation. (US contributes around 20% of UN’s budget)
• Failure in Conflict Prevention: UN has repeatedly been unable to prevent wars, genocide, and humanitarian crises, undermining credibility.
  Eg: Inaction during Israel-Gaza, Sudanese, and earlier Rwandan crises.
• Bureaucratic Inefficiency: Large-scale operations and administrative overheads reduce responsiveness and agility.
  Eg: UN has spent over half a trillion dollars in 80 years, yet coordination in field missions remains slow.
• Geopolitical Bias and Distance from Ground Realities: Headquarters in New York and influence of powerful nations make it less connected to conflict zones and local needs.
  Eg: Critiques suggest relocating HQ closer to conflict-prone regions for better situational response.

Reforms to Strengthen the UN

• Limit or Reform Veto Power: Reducing veto influence can allow faster decision-making in crises and improve neutrality.
• Enhance Operational Efficiency: Streamline bureaucratic processes, reduce redundancies, and improve resource allocation.
  Eg: UN80 reform plan targets 20% reduction in core budget and thousands of job cuts to improve efficiency.
• Strengthen Peacekeeping and Rapid Response: Equip UN missions with autonomous rapid deployment capabilities, less reliant on Security Council approvals.
  Eg: Creation of standing rapid-response brigades for conflict hotspots.
• Relocate or Regionalize Operations: Establish regional hubs closer to conflict and disaster zones for better coordination and ground-level impact.
  Eg: Temporary rotating offices in regions like Kigali, Aleppo, or Kyiv to ensure operational relevance

Conclusion

While the UN has notable achievements, structural and operational limitations have weakened its relevance. Strategic reforms like particularly around veto power, financing, efficiency, and ground-level engagement can strengthen the UN, making it a more effective instrument for global peace, security, and sustainable development.

DOWNLOAD PDF