Shanta Kumar Committee 2014: PDS Changes, MSP Policy, Cash Transfers & Food Security Reforms in India

The Shanta Kumar Committee was formed in August 2014 to examine the working of the Food Corporation of India. The government wanted to improve how India manages food security and agricultural stocks. 

Chaired by Shanta Kumar, the Shanta Kumar Committee focused on building a more efficient food economy that India can depend on. The final report was submitted in 2015 and provided a roadmap for food policy reforms in India.

UPSC Online Classes

Why the Shanta Kumar Committee was Formed?

The Shanta Kumar Committee 2014 addressed deep-rooted FCI inefficiencies India faced for decades. While India moved from grain shortages to surpluses, the management systems remained outdated. 

Data showed that very few farmers actually benefited from price supports. Additionally, PDS leakage issues were very high, with nearly half of the grains failing to reach the poor. These problems created a massive foodgrain supply chain bottleneck in India that required urgent attention.

Key Issues Identified by Shanta Kumar Committee

The Shanta Kumar Committee found several structural problems:

• Limited reach of procurement under the agricultural procurement policy
• High PDS leakage issues in India are affecting delivery
• Poor grain storage infrastructure leads to wastage
• Inefficient buffer stock management.
• Large financial burden due to subsidies

These issues showed the need for strong agricultural policy reforms in India and better planning in agriculture and food security.

Food Corporation of India (FCI)

The Food Corporation of India is the central agency responsible for procurement, storage, movement, and distribution of foodgrains to ensure national food security.

• Establishment: FCI was established in 1965 under the Food Corporations Act 1964 to address food shortages and support India’s goal of self-sufficiency in foodgrains.
• Core Objectives: FCI has three main roles: providing price support to farmers, supplying grains for PDS distribution, and maintaining buffer stocks to stabilize foodgrain markets.
• Procurement System: FCI follows open-ended procurement, buying unlimited wheat and rice at MSP, often resulting in excessive accumulation of stocks beyond buffer norms.
• Role in Food Security: FCI ensures food availability for vulnerable populations and stabilizes the food economy in India through buffer stocks.
• Storage Challenges: Lack of adequate grain storage infrastructure in India leads to wastage, inefficiency, and higher subsidy burdens.
• Financial Burden: Excess procurement and storage inefficiencies have caused rising debts, estimated at around ₹2.55 lakh crore by March 2020.
• Operational Issues: Inefficient liquidation policies, high storage costs, and outdated systems like CAP storage contribute to overall FCI inefficiencies.

This background sets the stage for the Shanta Kumar Committee’s recommendations aimed at modernizing India’s foodgrain management system.

UPSC Online Preparation

Major Recommendations of Shanta Kumar Committee

The Shanta Kumar Committee gave clear and practical suggestions:

1. Decentralized Procurement

It recommended a decentralized procurement system in India where states take more responsibility. This would improve efficiency and reduce pressure on FCI. This step supports broader procurement and distribution reforms.

2. PDS Reforms

The committee suggested public distribution system reforms in India. It proposed reducing coverage under the food law, which led to the NFSA coverage debate. The goal was better targeting of benefits.

3. Cash Transfers

It supported cash transfer in PDS India in selected areas. This could help in food subsidy reduction in India and reduce leakages.

4. MSP Changes

The report called for MSP policy reforms in India. It suggested better price support for pulses and oilseeds and alignment with market conditions.

5. Storage Improvements

To address foodgrain storage issues, the committee advised modern silos and better warehouses. It also promoted the warehouse receipt system to help farmers store and sell at the right time.

6. Subsidy Rationalization

The committee pushed for subsidy rationalization to make spending more effective.

7. Institutional Reforms

It recommended the Food Corporation of India’s restructuring to improve efficiency and accountability.

Criticism and Concerns of the Shanta Kumar Committee

The recommendations of the Shanta Kumar Committee attracted criticism due to concerns over food security, federal balance, and the possible exclusion of vulnerable groups.

• Reduction in NFSA Coverage: The proposal to reduce beneficiaries led to the NFSA coverage debate in India, as many feared that poor households could lose access to subsidized food.
• Shift to Cash Transfers: The idea of cash transfer in PDS India raised concerns about its effectiveness in rural areas with weak banking systems and fluctuating food prices.
• Privatization Concerns: Greater private sector involvement created doubts about control over the system and its impact on government food schemes.
• Impact on Farmers: Changes in procurement and MSP policy reforms could affect farmers who depend on assured government buying.
• Federal Concerns: Moving towards a decentralized procurement system in India raised fears of uneven implementation across states with different capacities.

Click to Know UPSC Coaching Centres in India

Impact and Significance of the Shanta Kumar Committee

The Shanta Kumar Committee influenced major discussions on food security reforms. It brought focus on efficiency, transparency, and sustainability.

• Brought focus on improving efficiency in procurement, storage, and distribution processes.
• Encouraged transparency through digitization and better monitoring systems.
• Promoted the idea of a more sustainable and cost-effective food management system.
• Influenced policy debates on food subsidy reduction and better use of public funds.
• Supported the shift towards modern infrastructure to solve storage and supply chain issues.
• Increased attention on reducing leakages and improving targeting in welfare schemes.
• Encouraged coordination between the central and state governments for better implementation.
• Provided direction for long-term reforms in India’s food sector and governance system.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books

Visit PW Store

The recommendations of the Shanta Kumar Committee remain relevant even today in shaping India’s food policies. They highlight the need to improve systems and reduce inefficiencies. Its suggestions continue to support the goal of building a strong and efficient food management system in India.

DOWNLOAD PDF