Answer:

India’s growing stature as a defence exporter raises questions about how to balance national interests with international obligations. As India aspires to become a significant player in the global arms market, it faces the challenge of ensuring that its exports do not contribute to human rights violations or conflicts. Enhancing India’s credibility as a responsible defence exporter requires careful alignment of domestic policies with international humanitarian laws (IHL).

Steps to Enhance Credibility as a Responsible Defence Exporter (National Interests Focus):

• Develop a Comprehensive Legal Framework: India should introduce laws similar to the UK’s Export Control Act, which mandates an assessment of international humanitarian law compliance before approving arms exports.
  For instance: This would ensure that exports align with India’s national security and foreign policy objectives.
• Strengthen Export Controls: By improving regulations under the Foreign Trade Act and the The Weapons Mass destruction And Delivery Systems Act 2005 India can ensure that defence exports are monitored effectively and that high-risk sales are restricted.
  For instance: Establishing stricter export criteria for conflict zones.
• Promote Ethical Standards in Arms Trade: India must prioritise human rights and ethical considerations when approving defence exports.
  For example: Creating an independent review board to assess the risks of exports to volatile regions, balancing national interest with ethical standards.
• Diversify Defence Export Markets: To avoid dependency on conflict-prone regions, India should expand its defence export markets to stable nations.
  For example: Strengthening ties with Southeast Asian nations for non-combat equipment.
• Engage in Multilateral Defence Forums: Active participation in international defence forums will allow India to shape global defence export norms while safeguarding its national interests.
  For example: India’s involvement in Defence Technology and Trade Initiatives (DTTI) with the U.S.
• Safeguard Strategic Autonomy: India must balance its role as a defence exporter with its strategic autonomy by avoiding over-reliance on any single export market.
  For example: Maintaining a balance between exports to West Asian countries and fostering relations with Africa and South America.
• Enhance Domestic Defence Manufacturing: Strengthening indigenous production capabilities under the Make in India initiative will allow India to export responsibly while reducing its own dependency on foreign arms imports.
  For example: Promoting DRDO-developed technologies for export while prioritising self-reliance.

Steps to Enhance Credibility as a Responsible Defence Exporter (International Obligations Focus):

• Incorporate International Humanitarian Law (IHL) in Export Policies: India should incorporate IHL principles into its export policies, ensuring that arms exports are not used to commit war crimes.
  For example: Mandating a rigorous IHL compliance review before exporting defence equipment.
• Align with the Arms Trade Treaty (ATT): While India is not a signatory to the Arms Trade Treaty, adhering to its principles would enhance India’s reputation as a responsible exporter.
  For instance: Voluntarily adopting Article 6 of the ATT, which prohibits arms exports if they could be used to commit war crimes.
• Transparent Reporting and Accountability: India should adopt transparent mechanisms for tracking arms exports to ensure compliance with global standards.
• Commitment to Peacekeeping Operations: India’s active participation in UN peacekeeping missions can reinforce its image as a responsible arms exporter.
  For instance: Supporting conflict-resolution mechanisms and UN peacekeeping efforts.
• Enhance Multilateral Cooperation on Arms Control: Engaging with international arms control frameworks and forums to ensure that India’s defence exports contribute to global security and stability.
  For example: Collaboration with ASEAN Defence Ministers’ Meeting-Plus (ADMM-Plus) for regional stability.
• Adopt Best Practices from Responsible Exporters: Studying and implementing the best practices of leading defence exporters like the Netherlands or Germany, which integrate ethical considerations into their arms exports.
• Leverage International Partnerships for Training: Collaborating with international bodies to provide ethical training for India’s defence manufacturers and exporters.
  For example: Partnering with the UN Institute for Disarmament Research (UNIDIR) to train policymakers in IHL compliance.

India’s journey towards becoming a credible and responsible defence exporter hinges on balancing national security with adherence to international humanitarian obligations. By implementing robust legal frameworks, promoting transparency, and ensuring ethical practices, India can build its global reputation while safeguarding its national interests. This balanced approach will allow India to strengthen its standing in the international arms trade market without compromising its commitment to global peace and security.

DOWNLOAD PDF