Answer

To promote ease of doing business and streamline the complex web of labor regulations, the government took a significant step by consolidating 29 of the 44 existing central labor laws into four comprehensive labor codes. These include the Code on Wages (2019), the Code on Social Security (2020), the Industrial Relations Code (2020), and the Occupational Safety, Health, and Working Conditions Code (2020), collectively referred to as the “Labour Codes.”  With Article 43 of the Constitution advocating for fair working conditions and wages, the Labour Codes strive for a balanced approach between worker rights and industrial flexibility.

Merits of the Four Labour Codes in Context of Labour Market Reforms:

• Enhancement of Worker Rights: The Codes address long-standing disparities, strengthening worker rights and access to benefits.
  For example: The online portal for interstate migrant workers ensures they are registered for social security benefits.
• Simplification of Compliance: The consolidation of multiple laws reduces bureaucratic hurdles, making compliance easier for employers and improving accountability.
  For instance: Small factories now need to comply with fewer regulations, reducing the burden on MSMEs while still maintaining worker protections.
• Improved Industrial Relations: Provisions for dispute resolution and collective bargaining promote smoother employer-worker negotiations, reducing the risk of industrial strikes.
  For instance: The Industrial Relations Code, 2020, introduces guidelines for strikes, ensuring more structured dispute resolution processes.
• Focus on Social Security: Expansion of social security coverage to previously excluded workers like migrants, gig, and platform workers.
  For example: Gig and platform workers are now legally recognised for social security benefits under the Code on Social Security, 2020.
• Promoting Safety and Health: New safety standards for industries, particularly hazardous ones, ensure improved working conditions.
  For instance: The Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020 mandates better safety provisions in high-risk industries like construction.
• Flexibility in Employment: Fixed-term employment contracts are encouraged, providing more job security to workers without compromising business flexibility.
  For example: Fixed-term employees will now be treated on par with permanent employees regarding wages and social security.

Demerits of the Four Labour Codes:

• Ambiguity in Definitions: Some definitions, like what constitutes a “worker” or “wages,” remain unclear, leaving room for misinterpretation.
  For instance: Ambiguity around the term gig worker mirrors issues faced in California, where Uber drivers had to fight for legal recognition.
• Limited Awareness and Implementation: Lack of awareness, particularly in the informal sector, limits the impact of these reforms.
  For example: Informal sector workers in rural areas are less informed about their rights under the Social Security Code, 2020.
• Resistance from Trade Unions: Trade unions have opposed provisions limiting the right to strike and introducing fixed-term employment, fearing job insecurity.
  For instance: Similar to the labour law reforms in Brazil in 2017, these Codes have seen strikes and protests by Indian trade unions.
• Impact on Informal Sector Workers: Although designed to benefit all workers, the Codes may disproportionately impact informal sector workers who are often underrepresented.
  For example: Migrant workers may still struggle to access benefits despite the new online registration
• Gradual Implementation: Phased implementation of the Codes creates uncertainty in both employers and employees, stalling their potential benefits.
  For example: Several states have yet to fully notify the new Codes, leading to uneven enforcement.

Progress So Far:

• Rollout of Codes: The rollout has been uneven across states, with some adopting the Codes quicker to attract investment, while others delay due to administrative challenges.
  For example: States like Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh have adopted reforms to attract foreign investment, while other states lag behind.
• Stakeholder Consultations: Extensive consultations have been conducted with trade unions, employers, and states, though consensus remains elusive.
  For instance: Consultations have revealed strong opposition to fixed-term employment provisions by trade unions.
• Awareness Issues: A lack of awareness among both workers and employers has hindered the effective implementation of the Codes.
• Partial Implementation: The pandemic and 2024 general elections have delayed the full implementation of the Codes.
  For instance: Although draft rules have been prepared in most states, they are yet to be fully enforced on the ground.
• Challenges in Enforcement: Employers, especially in the informal sector, face challenges in transitioning to the new legal framework.
• Digital Initiatives: The introduction of online portals for migrant workers and gig workers is a significant step towards inclusion, but adoption has been slow.

The Labour Codes are ambitious reforms aimed at improving ease of doing business and social security in India.However, their success depends on overcoming the challenges of awareness, swift implementation, and adaptation to feedback. An integrated approach focusing on digital literacy and stakeholder cooperation will be crucial in ensuring inclusive and sustainable reforms, driving India towards SDG Goal 8 (Decent Work and Economic Growth).

DOWNLOAD PDF