The Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) will introduce open-book assessments (OBE) in Class 9 from 2026-27, after a pilot study showed strong “teacher support” for the idea.

About Open Book Exam (OBE)

• An open-book exam is an assessment format where students are permitted to use approved resources like textbooks, class notes, or other specified material during an assessment, rather than mainly testing memory. 
• The core principle of OBEs is not to test a student’s ability to recall facts from memory, but rather to evaluate their capacity to locate information, comprehend its meaning, and effectively apply it to solve problems. 
• For instance, in a science exam, while the necessary facts might be readily available in a book, the true assessment lies in a student’s ability to connect these facts logically to arrive at a conclusion. 
• OBEs aim to provide a format that accommodates diverse learning styles and offers constructive feedback, ultimately improving overall learning outcomes.

CBSE’s New Approach and Its Rationale

• The decision to implement OBEs was based on a pilot study conducted in November-December 2023, which revealed strong support from teachers. 
• The pilot covered English, Mathematics, and Science for Classes 9 and 10, and English, Mathematics, and Biology for Classes 11 and 12. 
• The CBSE Governing Body formally approved this plan in June.
• This initiative aligns directly with the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 and the National Curriculum Framework for School Education (NCERT). 
• These policies advocate for a departure from rote learning and a shift towards competency-based learning. 
• The objective is to ensure students genuinely grasp concepts, understand underlying processes, and can explain how they apply this knowledge in various situations. 

History of Open-Book Exams

• Global Context: Open-book exams have been in use for decades, with Hong Kong introducing them as early as 1953. 
  • Studies conducted in the US and UK between 1951 and 1978 also experimented with allowing textbooks and notes in various university courses. 
  • Research consistently showed a positive impact on the internalisation of knowledge rather than mere memorisation. 
  • Weaker students often performed better in OBEs, and these exams were found to measure different abilities compared to traditional closed-book tests. 
  • However, OBEs have remained rare in high-stakes school examinations globally, such as the UK’s GCSEs or the US SATs. 
  • The COVID-19 pandemic temporarily altered this, as many universities shifted to online, open-book, or open-web exams, although students initially struggled due to their unfamiliarity with the format.
• Indian Context: India has also experimented with OBEs previously.
  • CBSE’s Open Text-Based Assessment (OTBA): In 2014, CBSE launched the OTBA for Class 9 (Hindi, English, Mathematics, Science, and Social Science) and Class 11 final exams (Economics, Biology, and Geography) to reduce rote learning. 
    • Students were provided with reference material four months in advance. 
    • However, CBSE discontinued this initiative by the 2017-18 academic year, concluding that it had not successfully fostered the “critical abilities” it intended to promote.
  • Higher Education: Open-book formats have a stronger presence in Indian collegiate education. 
  • The All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE) approved their use in engineering colleges in 2019. 
  • During the pandemic, several prominent universities like Delhi University, Jamia Millia Islamia, Jawaharlal Nehru University, and Aligarh Muslim University, along with IIT Delhi, IIT Indore, and IIT Bombay, implemented OBEs, often online. 
  • Delhi University conducted its first OBE in August 2020 and returned to physical exams by January 2022. 
  • More recently, Kerala’s higher education reforms commission has proposed using the format specifically for internal or practical examinations.

Benefits of Open-Book Exams for Students

• Reduces Rote Memorisation: It helps students focus less on memorising facts and more on understanding and applying what they learn, since unused information is often forgotten.
• Fosters Analytical and Application Skills: OBEs compel students to think critically and apply their knowledge to real-life situations. 
  • The focus shifts to how students can utilise information, rather than just recalling it.
• Encourages Deeper Understanding: Students are more likely to look for connections between ideas and go beyond simply finding information on a page.
• Longer Retention of Knowledge: When knowledge is applied practically, it tends to be retained for a longer duration than through rote learning.
• Reduces Stress and Anxiety: Students experience less pressure and anxiety associated with memorising vast amounts of information before exams. The knowledge that reference materials are available can significantly reduce exam-related stress.
• Alignment with Educational Policies: It directly supports the NEP 2020’s call for competency-based learning over rote memorisation.

Challenges and Concerns Associated with OBEs

• Difficulty in Question Setting: Crafting questions that truly assess analytical skills and learning outcomes, rather than just direct retrieval from books, requires significant effort and skill from teachers. 
  • There is a risk that teachers might set simple questions, leading to inflated scores if not properly designed.
• Student Over-Dependence: Students might become overly reliant on books and reduce their study efforts, assuming they can find all answers during the exam. This could lead to a “shallow” preparation approach.
• Unequal Access to Resources: A potential concern is that students from wealthier backgrounds might afford more expensive or comprehensive reference books, creating an unfair advantage. However, this can be mitigated by specifying and limiting the types of books allowed in the exam.
• Need for Pedagogical Shift: For OBEs to be effective, the entire teaching methodology throughout the academic year must also adapt. 
  • If students are taught through traditional rote learning methods but tested with OBEs, they may struggle to apply knowledge they were never taught to use analytically. 
  • Schools must focus on developing analytical skills and critical thinking continuously.
• Initial Familiarity Issues: As seen during the pandemic, students may initially struggle with the format if they are unfamiliar with it. 
  • Real gains require specific training on how to approach and break down questions, analyse concepts, and apply them, rather than just looking up answers.

Conclusion

CBSE’s move towards open-book exams signifies a progressive shift in the Indian education system.

• The success of this initiative will hinge on a systemic overhaul that supports the development of genuine competencies, preparing students not just for exams, but for real-world challenges.

DOWNLOAD PDF