Understanding Flexible Exchange Rate Systems

A flexible exchange rate system allows currencies to fluctuate freely based on market forces, offering benefits such as automatic adjustments to trade imbalances. However, it can lead to exchange rate volatility, which may pose risks for international trade and investments. In contrast, a fixed exchange rate system provides stability but requires interventions to maintain the peg, potentially leading to foreign exchange reserves depletion and economic imbalances. 

What are the merits of a Fixed Exchange Rate System?

• Stability: Provides a stable environment for international trade and investment by maintaining a constant exchange rate.
• Predictability: Facilitates better planning and forecasting for businesses and investors due to the known exchange rate.
• Control of Inflation: Helps in controlling inflation by pegging the domestic currency to a stable foreign currency or a basket of currencies.
• Fiscal Discipline: Imposes fiscal and monetary discipline on governments to maintain the fixed rate.
• Prevention of Competitive Devaluation: Avoids a race to the bottom where countries competitively devalue their currencies to gain trade advantages.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Demerits of Fixed Exchange Rate System: Challenges and Considerations

• Costly Maintenance: Requires maintaining high levels of foreign reserves to defend the fixed rate, which can be economically unfeasible.
• Speculative Attacks: Prone to speculative attacks if there’s doubt about the government’s ability to maintain the exchange rate.
• Loss of Monetary Policy Independence: Limits the ability to tailor monetary policy to domestic economic conditions.
• Misalignment and Trade Imbalances: This can lead to misalignment of the exchange rate with economic fundamentals, causing trade imbalances.

Merits of Flexible Exchange Rate System: Empowering Economic Flexibility

• Flexibility: Allows for automatic adjustment of exchange rates in response to economic changes, providing more flexibility to the government.
• Monetary Policy Independence: Countries have the autonomy to conduct their monetary policies as per domestic economic conditions.
• Automatic Balance of Payments (BoP) Adjustment: Movements in the exchange rate automatically address surpluses and deficits in the BoP, reducing the need for governmental intervention.
• Reduced Need for Reserves: Governments do not need to maintain large stocks of foreign exchange reserves, freeing up resources for other uses.

What are the demerits of Flexible Exchange Rate System?

• Uncertainty: This can create uncertainty due to fluctuating exchange rates, which might deter international trade and investment.
• Potential for Volatility: Exchange rates can be highly volatile, subject to speculation and rapid short-term movements.
• Less Discipline: This may lead to less fiscal and monetary discipline as governments are not obliged to uphold a fixed exchange rate.
• Trade Shocks: Countries are more exposed to international financial and trade shocks due to fluctuating exchange rates.

Managed Floating: Balancing Flexible exchange rate and Central bank control

• The global economy has transitioned to a managed floating exchange rate system without any formal international accord.
• This system is a hybrid of both flexible (the floating aspect) and fixed exchange rate systems (the managed aspect), hence also referred to as “dirty floating.”
• Central Bank Intervention
  • Central banks play a proactive role by intervening in the foreign exchange market.
  • They engage in buying and selling foreign currencies to temper exchange rate fluctuations whenever deemed necessary.
  • Unlike a pure floating system, official reserve transactions in a managed floating system are not zero, indicating active central bank involvement.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Classes

Conclusion

• The discourse on exchange rate systems reveals a blend of governmental control and market forces shaping international trade.
• Fixed Exchange Rates offer stability at the cost of substantial reserves, while Flexible Exchange Rates allow market-driven adjustments with potential volatility. 
• Managed Floating serves as a middle ground, permitting central bank interventions to moderate extreme rate fluctuations.
• Factors like income levels, interest rates, and long-term price equalization further influence exchange rate movements, underscoring the importance of a well-considered exchange rate policy in cherishing  economic stability and robust international trade relations.

DOWNLOAD PDF