The Reserve Bank of India’s ban on rupee non-deliverable derivative (NDD) contracts signals a decisive move to curb speculative manipulation and enhance transparency in the forex market.
- The ban on NDD is aimed at curbing offshore speculation that often leads to rupee volatility.
UPSC Online Classes
Implications of the Ban on NDD Market
Positive Impacts
- Stabilisation of Rupee: The ban is expected to stabilise the rupee by reducing speculative pressure from offshore market participants.
- Lower exchange rate volatility: It will lead to lower exchange rate volatility, particularly in the short term, by curbing excessive speculative trades.
- Transparency: The measure enhances transparency in forex transactions, ensuring more accountable and regulated market practices.
- Boosting Investor Confidence: It is likely to boost investor confidence by aligning India’s forex framework with global best practices.
Negative Impact
- Limit Hedging avenues: The restriction may limit hedging avenues for foreign investors, making risk management more difficult.
- Reduce liquidity in offshore markets: It could reduce liquidity in offshore markets, potentially affecting overall market efficiency.
|
About Non-Deliverable Derivative (NDD)
- An NDD is a derivative contract where two parties agree on a future exchange rate for the rupee, but settle the difference in cash, usually in US dollars.
- As India has capital controls, offshore investors can’t freely trade in the rupee in physical form. This led to the creation of the NDD markets in the rupee.
- Key Participants: The NDD market is widely used by foreign investors, hedge funds and global banks who cannot freely access and play in the Indian rupee market, as well as by firms looking to hedge currency risk.
- Offshore Trading Centres: These are typically traded outside India in financial hubs like Singapore, Hong Kong, London or Dubai, allowing participants to bet on the rupee’s direction without actual delivery of the currency.
Types of Non-Deliverable Derivative (NDD) Instruments
- Non-Deliverable Forwards (NDFs): Agreement to settle the difference between a fixed and market exchange rate in cash without actual currency delivery.
- Non-Deliverable Options (NDOs): Provide the right to benefit from exchange rate movements with cash settlement, without obligation to transact.
- Non-Deliverable Swaps (NDSs): Involve exchange of cash flows based on currency or interest rate differences, settled without exchanging the underlying rupee.
Benefits of Non-Deliverable Derivative (NDD) Market
- Hedging Exchange Rate Risk: Enables foreign investors and firms to manage rupee volatility without accessing onshore markets.
- Access Despite Capital Controls: Provides a mechanism to trade and hedge the rupee even when full convertibility is restricted.
- Enhanced Liquidity: Increases overall trading volume and depth in global rupee markets.
- Price Discovery: Reflects market expectations about future rupee movements, aiding better exchange rate assessment.
- Flexibility for Global Investors: Allows participation across time zones and jurisdictions without regulatory constraints of domestic markets.
Click to Know UPSC Coaching Centres in India
Criticism
- Distortion in Price Discovery: These instruments have long been criticised for distorting price discovery and manipulation as such an offshore sentiment can diverge sharply from domestic fundamentals and movements.
- Misuse of NDD Market: The NDD market was also misused by some market participants. Previously, some participants would cancel and re-enter contracts to take advantage of favourable movements, effectively turning hedging tools into speculative instruments
- Impact of Geopolitical and Trade Tensions: During periods of geopolitical or trade tensions, large offshore traders take significant positions betting on rupee depreciation, influencing the onshore exchange rate.
- For Example: Such trends were observed during the West Asia conflict in late February.
- Limited Regulatory Control over Offshore Markets: Offshore NDD markets operate outside the direct jurisdiction of the Reserve Bank of India, allowing external price discovery to influence the rupee exchange rate without adequate domestic oversight.
- For Example: Trading hubs like Singapore can determine rupee expectations overnight, impacting the opening rates in Indian markets.