The year 2025 began with high expectations for Indian diplomacy, particularly with Donald Trump’s return, but ended with significant challenges.
The United States- Strategic Friction
- America First Policy: Under Trump, the US has become a challenging partner for India.
- Trade Barriers: India faces a 25% reciprocal tariff on goods, particularly affecting labour-intensive sectors like textiles, gems, and seafood.
- An additional 25% surcharge was imposed on oil imports from Russia.
- GSP Removal & H1B Visa Restrictions: The revocation of India’s Generalised System of Preferences (GSP) status and new H1B visa restrictions threaten remittance flows.
- GSP provides preferential duty-free treatment to products from developing countries, promoting economic growth.
- US National Security Strategy (NSS):
-
- 2017 NSS: India recognised as a Leading Global Power; China as a Revisionist Power.
- 2025 NSS: India’s role narrowed to the Indo-Pacific region and mineral security.
- US-China Dynamics: The US’ soft posture toward China and Russia hints at a potential G-2 world order, which could reduce India’s strategic influence.
Performative Diplomacy- China and Russia
- China: Despite high-level meetings, no security guarantees emerged on the LAC; stapled visa incidents, such as the 2025 Shanghai case, continue to strain ties. Stapled visa signals non-recognition of nationality.
- Russia: Symbolic “bear hugs” dominate bilateral optics; no major new deals in defence, nuclear, or space sectors have materialised, and Russia is increasingly aligning with China.
Pakistan- Rising Threats
- Terror Attack in Pahalgam (April 2025): India responded with Operation Sindoor, a retaliatory strike.
- Global Reaction: While the attack was condemned internationally, India’s retaliation failed to gain diplomatic support.
- Strategic Shifts: Pakistan, Turkey, and Azerbaijan formed a new strategic axis; the Saudi-Pak defence pact contributes to India’s strategic encirclement.
Other Neighbours of India- Regional Instability
- Bangladesh and Nepal: Regime changes in both countries led to the formation of transitional governments. Relations in the region are at their lowest ebb and are not friendly toward India.
- Myanmar: In Myanmar, the junta is holding sham elections in December 2025. India’s democratic appeal failed to stabilise the region.
- Kautilya’s Mandala Theory: Kautilya’s Mandala Theory remains relevant, the theory states that “your neighbor is your natural enemy.”
Way Forward
- Move Beyond Performative Diplomacy: Public gestures must be backed by tangible outcomes in trade, security, and strategic cooperation.
- Adopt a Consistent Values-Based Approach: Ensure messaging aligns with actions to avoid perceptions of hypocrisy.
- Diplomatic Stance: India should project itself as Vishwamitra—constructive global friend—while avoiding a Vishwa-victim narrative.
Conclusion
India’s foreign policy in 2025 reflects a complex interplay of trade frictions, regional instability, and symbolic diplomacy. To safeguard strategic interests, India must prioritise outcomes over optics, maintain a values-driven approach, and actively balance global power dynamics while reinforcing its role as a credible and constructive global actor.