Can Green Credits Benefit India’s Forests?

Context

The Green Credit Programme has raised concerns from experts due to their potential adverse impact on forest ecology. 

About Green Credits

• Green Credit Programme: It was initiated by the Environment Ministry in October 2023 and presents a market-based mechanism to incentivize individuals and companies for their contributions to environmental and ecological restoration. 
• Aim: The programme aims to incentivize green and sustainable actions among various stakeholders, fostering a culture of environmental responsibility.
• Role of Incentives: By offering incentives such as green credits, the programme encourages participation in activities like water conservation and afforestation, involving both individuals and corporations.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Major Concerns Associated with Green Credit Programme

• Impact on Forest Ecosystems: Afforestation efforts must consider potential negative consequences, such as monocultures and unsuitable vegetation for specific regions.
• Challenges in Implementation: Concerns have been raised regarding its potential to circumvent existing environmental laws, particularly those related to forest conservation.
  • The programme’s potential to bypass existing environmental laws, such as the Forest Conservation Act, is highlighted as a significant issue.
• Fungibility of Credits: One of the major challenges lies in the lack of fungibility among different types of green credits, making it difficult to equate various environmental benefits on the same platform.
• Challenges in Measurement: Recognition of measurement difficulties, particularly regarding biodiversity impact assessment requires acknowledging the evolving scientific understanding and ongoing challenges in achieving a perfect measure.

Way Forward to Forest Conservation: Regeneration, Community Engagement, and Private Sector Involvement

• Awareness Generation: There is a need for generation of awareness among implementers regarding ground-level challenges and advocates for a broader perspective beyond mere tree plantation.
  • There is a need for a nuanced understanding of measurement issues and the role of social science in assessing the effectiveness of such programmes.
• Regeneration vs. Plantations: A regeneration approach, emphasizing the protection of natural areas from disturbances to allow for natural forest growth.
  • Over a span of 10-15 years, natural forests can regenerate, supporting biodiversity and providing benefits to local communities.
• Leveraging Private Sector: Despite complexity, there is a need for leveraging private sector resources through market-based incentives.

Conclusion

Concerns regarding monoculture, biodiversity loss, and clashes with existing laws underscore the need for careful execution of Green Credit Programme while ensuring regulatory alignment.

DOWNLOAD PDF