Reforming Civil Services is Key to Improving Delivery

If the Indian State is to meet 21st-century needs, it will need an ample supply of fresh thinking and knowledgeable personnel.

Overview of India’s Present Situation

• New Government: The new government in New Delhi will take charge at a time when the geopolitical winds are blowing in India’s favour. 
• India as Investment Destination: The Sino-American trade war has made it increasingly attractive for companies to invest in emerging markets outside the Chinese sphere of influence. India’s large market is an added attraction.
• Major Challenge: Will the new government be able to seize the moment? A lot will depend on how far the government succeeds in upgrading the plumbing of the Indian State. If the big challenge in 1991 was to get an overly intrusive State out of the lives of people and businesses, the challenge now is to make it deliver critical lines of support to people and to companies.
• Lack of State’s Capacity: Be it negotiating trade deals or monitoring communicable diseases, the Indian State often fails to deliver where it is needed most. The lack of State capacity is “the major binding constraint” to national progress today.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Actions that Corrode the Steel Frame of India

• Roles and Functions: It is the police and magistracy, judicial courts and other regulatory agencies, not politicians, which have been authorised and empowered by law to take preventive action against potential troublemakers, enforce the laws relating to criminal, economic and other offences, and maintain public order.
• Guiding Principles: In mature democracies, self-respecting public officials normally discharge their constitutional and legal responsibilities with honesty, integrity and their own conscience, firmly resisting the dictates of the vested interests. What is happening in our country?

An Erosion in India- Can this happen in India?

• Erosion in Civil Service Standards: Lack of erosion in standards might have been possible in the early years when Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel created independent India’s civil services, but no longer.
  • The deterioration in standards was very visible during the National Emergency declared in 1975.
• Lack of Civil Service Neutrality: The civil services, like other institutions including the judiciary, just caved in; the trend might have accelerated over the years; now, no one even talks of civil service neutrality, although there is the rare purist who could be sticking to the old standards of behaviour.
  • Earlier, during communal or caste riots, the Administration focused on quelling the disturbances and restoring peace in the affected locality, without ever favouring one group over the other.
  • Now, there are allegations of local officers taking sides in a conflict.
• Politicisation of Bureaucracy: For civil servants who work with ruling politicians directly, following a political master’s diktats and identifying with his interests, anticipating his views in official work and acting on them and pandering to his narrow political interests, often become easy options that put them out of harm’s way.
  • The politician, lacking the vision and intellectual grasp of a Sardar Patel, could also reward a compliant bureaucrat by offering prized and lucrative assignments both within and outside the country.
  • He could also have him placed in an inconvenient position or even punish him if he does not follow his line.
  • This can happen despite the protection and safeguards in Article 311 of the Constitution.
  • That a civil servant’s pliant and submissive behaviour means an end to civil service neutrality and the norms and values that this trait demands, does not seem to bother either the political or bureaucratic leadership.

Check Out UPSC NCERT Textbooks From PW Store

Lessons from Partygate

Perhaps, a reference to the recent events in Great Britain will serve to clarify things, as the main features of our governance system the – cabinet system with accountability to Parliament and a permanent civil service with political neutrality as its hallmark – are patterned on the English constitutional model.

• Recently, Britain’s two top Ministers, Prime Minister Boris Johnson and the Chancellor of the Exchequer (Finance Minister), Rishi Sunak, were accused of violating their own lockdown regulations for COVID-19 by attending Christmas and other parties at 10, Downing Street, London (Prime Minister’s residence) in the months of November to December 2020.
• A career civil servant was asked to inquire into the veracity of the charges, she would never want to tarnish her reputation by claims of a cover-up or a shoddy investigation.
• She came to the finding that against the background of the restrictions on all citizens, the gatherings held were inappropriate and represented a serious failure to observe the high standards expected from top public functionaries.
• The public and the political establishment accepted the integrity of the exercise.
• Then, another wing of the civil service, the London Metropolitan Police, imposed fines on the Prime Minister and the Chancellor of Exchequer for their misdemeanour, and again both the top Ministers accepted the penalty.

Non-Negotiable Values

• This objective may, however, be at a discount when politicians are eager to serve their personal and party interests, and overzealous and ambitious officials dance to their tune, thereby leading to a dilution of standards. It could also create favourable conditions for both political and bureaucratic corruption.
• “Constitutional morality is not a natural sentiment,” wrote B.R. Ambedkar, the architect of the Constitution and added, “It has to be cultivated. We must realise that our people have yet to learn it. Democracy in India is only a top dressing on an Indian soil which is essentially undemocratic.”
• The norms that define neutrality are: 
  • Independence of thought and action. 
  • Honest and objective advice. 
  • Candour and ‘speaking truth to power’ even if it is done in the privacy of a Minister’s chamber.
• Associated with these norms are the personal values that a civil servant cherishes or ought to cherish, namely, self-respect, integrity, professional pride and dignity.
• All these together contribute to the enhancement of the quality of administration that benefits society and the people.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Classes

Conclusion

India’s governance faces challenges of capacity and integrity. Upholding civil service neutrality and constitutional morality is vital for democratic functioning.

DOWNLOAD PDF