The LPG reforms in India attracted many Western companies, bringing in capital, advanced technology, and their work cultures.
- This workplace culture adopted from Western corporate practices is having a negative impact in India.
- A 26-year-old employee of Ernst & Young (EY) in Pune died, reportedly due to an “overwhelming workload,” raising concerns about the company’s work culture.
- A former employee shared experiences that contributed to their decision to leave the firm, highlighting the toxic environment.
Max Weber’s Protestant Ethics
- Max Weber linked the Reformation in northern Europe to changes in work attitudes, suggesting that Protestantism viewed worldly activities for economic gain as morally significant, contributing to early capitalism.
Enroll now for UPSC Online Course
MNCs in India
- Multinational companies (MNCs) established in India don’t possess significant power or authority to make decisions. The decisions are made by the main office.
- For instance, if a US-based MNC opens an office in India, then the US office has the authority to make major decisions.
- Such a company would impose an American work culture rather than adopting the local culture.
- This clearly shows that the term, multinational, can be misleading.
- In reality, every multinational company is tied to a specific country, and national governments actively support the interests of their MNCs.
Is American Work Culture the Only Available Model?
- Many Western European countries offer more favorable working hours and vacation time, demonstrating that embracing only American work culture isn’t the sole path to progress for a country.
- Other approaches can also contribute to a healthier and more productive workforce.
Article 21
- Article 21 asserts that no person shall be deprived of their life except according to the procedure established by law.
- The article also emphasizes the importance of a safe and dignified workplace as part of the right to life.
- However, the incidents in Pune demonstrate that this has not been followed consistently throughout the country.
|
Government’s Dilemma
- The government’s dilemma in regulating work culture lies in the need to attract foreign investments, which often depend on MNCs setting up operations in India.
- India needs these investments for economic growth; however, enforcing robust labor laws could discourage MNCs from setting up operations.
- This can create a conflict between promoting a supportive work environment and maintaining a competitive economic landscape.
MNCs Impact on India’s Economic Sovereignty and Federalism
- Multinational companies (MNCs) impact India’s economic sovereignty by exerting significant influence over local markets and labor practices, often imposing their work culture i.e. prioritizing profit over local interests.
- The “Big Four” accounting firms often receive major assignments from the central government as well as state governments.
- For instance, governments of some southern States favor external consultants over local experts who are far more knowledgeable on economic matters.
Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store
Way Forward
- There should be a strong regulatory mechanism that protects employees from harassment.
- Working hours and practices in the multinationals working in India must be regulated by the government.
- Provisions must be introduced to address mental health challenges.
- Local sovereignty must be protected and local expertise must be promoted.
| The Big Four global accounting firms include Deloitte, Ernst & Young (EY), PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC), and Klynveld Peat Marwick Goerdeler (KPMG). |
Conclusion
India must critically assess the influence of toxic workplace cultures and actively choose to cultivate environments that value employee well-being and inclusivity. By prioritizing a supportive atmosphere, organizations can enhance productivity and foster sustainable growth.
November 1, 2024
