Answer:

Long-term Capital Gains Tax (LTCG) refers to the tax levied on the profit gained from the sale of assets held for a longer period, generally exceeding 12 months (equities) and 36 months (other assets). Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT) is imposed on the dividends that companies distribute to their shareholders from their profits. In the Union Budget of 2018-19, significant changes were introduced: LTCG was reinstated at 10% on gains exceeding ₹1 lakh from the sale of listed equity shares, and a 10% tax on dividend  income by equity oriented mutual funds.

The Advantages of the Significant Changes Introduced in the LTCG and DDT:

• Improved Tax Base: By reintroducing LTCG on equities, the government has broadened its tax base, enhancing its revenue without increasing the tax burden excessively on any single group.
  For instance: Post-reintroduction, LTCG was expected to significantly enhance government finances, supporting large-scale infrastructural projects and national development initiatives.
• Fairness in Taxation: The changes ensure that all forms of income are taxed, which promotes a more equitable treatment among different investment avenues.
  For instance: The uniform tax treatment of both listed and unlisted equity shares has corrected a long-standing disparity in investment taxation.
• Reduction in Market Volatility: LTCG encourages investors to hold their investments longer, reducing market volatility and fostering a more stable stock market environment.
  For instance: After the tax change in 2018, there was a noticeable decrease in speculative trading activities, leading to a more stable and less volatile market.
• Encouragement of Manufacturing Investments: With higher taxes on capital gains from equities, investments are more likely to flow into manufacturing and other sectors.
  For instance: Following the tax adjustments, there was an observed increase in investments in sectors like manufacturing, supporting the government’s Make in India initiative.
• Prevention of Tax Evasion: Implementing DDT on equity-oriented mutual funds closed a loophole that allowed tax-free income distribution, ensuring all dividend income is taxed.
  For example: Prior to 2018, wealthy investors frequently exploited the absence of DDT on dividends to conduct dividend stripping, thereby evading taxes legally.
• Rational Investment Choices: By removing the bias toward investing solely in equities for tax benefits, investors are encouraged to make decisions based on the actual performance and potential of the assets.
  For example: This led to a more diversified investment portfolio across different asset classes, such as bonds and real estate, enhancing overall market stability.
• Harmonization with Global Practices: Aligning India’s tax regime with global standards helps in attracting foreign investments and prevents the misuse of the tax code.
  For example: This alignment has made India a more attractive investment destination for global investors, who prefer stable and predictable tax regimes.

The Disadvantages of the Significant Changes Introduced in the LTCG and DDT:

• Reduced Investor Sentiment: The immediate reaction to reintroducing LTCG was a negative sentiment in the stock market, as investors adjusted to the reduced returns. 
• Disincentive for Middle-Class Investors: Middle-class investors, who form a significant base for mutual funds and equities, might feel discouraged due to reduced post-tax returns.
  For instance: There was a noticeable decline in mutual fund subscriptions and stock market participation among middle-class investors following the tax changes.
• Complexity in Tax Compliance: These changes add layers to tax filing procedures, potentially deterring investment due to the complexity of compliance.
  For instance: The new tax rules have increased reliance on financial advisors and tax consultants to navigate the more complex filing requirements.
• Potential for Short-Term Investment Bias: While LTCG encourages long-term investments, the introduction of the tax might push some investors towards short-term trading where tax implications are different.
  For example: There has been an uptick in day trading and other short-term investment activities, as investors seek to avoid the LTCG tax implications.
• Impact on Corporate Dividend Policies: Companies might reconsider their dividend policies, which could lead to lower dividend payouts.
  For example: Many corporations have started retaining more profits rather than distributing them as dividends, in order to minimize the tax impact on shareholders.
• Adverse Impact on Start-Ups and Unlisted Companies: Start-ups and unlisted companies might find it challenging to attract investment due to less favorable LTCG conditions compared to listed companies.
  For instance: Venture capital and private equity flows into startups and unlisted companies have diminished, as these investments are now seen as less tax-efficient.
• Double Taxation Concerns: Even though DDT is intended to tax dividends at the source, issues of double taxation arise as investors also pay taxes on the same income.
  For instance: Investors end up facing higher effective tax rates than intended, as they pay both DDT at the corporate level and income tax on the dividends received.

The reintroduction of LTCG and the imposition of DDT in the Union Budget of 2018-19 have been steps towards rationalizing the tax structure, broadening the tax base, and bringing more fairness to the investment landscape. However, these changes also pose challenges such as potential reductions in market participation and increased complexity in compliance. Balancing these outcomes will require continuous adjustments and considerations by policymakers to ensure the robust growth of India’s financial markets and the equitable distribution of tax liabilities.

DOWNLOAD PDF