Answer

Elephants hold immense cultural and religious significance in India, yet many captive elephants face deplorable conditions due to illegal trade and inadequate welfare measures. The Captive Elephant (Transfer or Transport) Rules, 2024 aim to regulate the movement of privately-held elephants, addressing welfare concerns and curbing illegal trade, aligning with India’s commitment to biodiversity conservation and animal rights.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Elephants as Sacred Symbols of Wisdom and Strength in India

• Cultural Significance: Elephants are integral to Indian festivals, religious rituals, and traditions, symbolizing wisdom, strength, and prosperity.
  For example: The elephant-headed deity Ganesha is worshipped across India, representing wisdom, success, and the remover of obstacles.
• Mythological Importance: Elephants feature prominently in Indian mythology and epics, often depicted as divine beings or celestial creatures.
  For example: Airavata, the white elephant of Indra, is described as a protector of rain and fertility in Hindu texts.
• Temple Usage: Elephants are often kept in temples to participate in ceremonies, reinforcing their sacred status.
  For example: The Thrissur Pooram festival in Kerala showcases decorated elephants as a central attraction during temple rituals.
• Tourism and Heritage: Elephants symbolize India’s rich biodiversity and heritage, often showcased in cultural events and tourism campaigns.
  For example: The Jaipur Elephant Festival highlights the role of elephants in India’s cultural identity.
• Art and Literature: Elephants inspire Indian art, sculpture, and literature, reflecting their revered status in society.
  For example: Ancient carvings at Ajanta and Ellora Caves depict elephants as symbols of strength and wisdom.

Contradictions in the Condition of Privately-held Captive Elephants

• Cruel Training Methods: Captive elephants undergo isolation and abusive training methods to perform unnatural behaviors.
  For example: Elephants used in tourism in Rajasthan are often beaten into submission for rides and performances.
• Deprivation of Social Needs: These social animals are kept in isolation, denying them the company of other elephants.
  For example: Elephants in temples in Tamil Nadu are confined to small spaces without access to open environments.
• Forced Commercial Activities: Captive elephants are rented for religious ceremonies, weddings, and entertainment, reducing them to commodities.
  For example: Elephants rented for Kerala festivals endure long hours of parades under harsh conditions.
• Health Issues: Poor living conditions lead to injuries, malnutrition, and psychological stress among captive elephants.
  For example: An elephant at a Delhi temple reportedly suffered from chronic foot injuries due to hard concrete flooring.
• Exploitation under Loopholes: Legal ambiguities in rules allow owners to use elephants for profit without addressing welfare concerns.
  For example: Elephants are transported under the guise of “religious purposes,” as seen in cross-state gifting incidents.

Challenges of Illegal Trade and Welfare of Captive Elephants

• Ambiguous Rules: The rules allow the commercial transfer of elephants, leading to potential exploitation under legal cover.
  For example: Private owners in Assam transported elephants to Delhi temples, bypassing strict conservation measures.
• Microchip Misuse: Reused microchips legitimize illicit wild captures, perpetuating illegal trade networks.
  For example: Reports of wild elephants being implanted with recycled microchips surfaced in 2019 investigations.
• Lack of Accountability: The absence of mandatory post-mortem reports prevents monitoring of deaths during transport.
  For example: An elephant’s death during transportation in Kerala raised concerns about inadequate oversight in the process.
• Breeding in Captivity: Captive births legitimize the cycle of captivity, further exacerbating exploitation.
  For example: A rise in captive births in temples in Karnataka has been linked to increased commercial use.
• Inadequate Conservation Efforts: Loopholes in the Captive Elephant Rules undermine efforts to curb wild captures and promote welfare.
  For example: The 2024 office memorandum flagged illegal transfers but failed to close key gaps in the legislation.

Role of Captive Elephant (Transfer or Transport) Rules, 2024 in Addressing Challenges

• Regulation of Ownership Transfers: The Rules mandate a procedure for transferring elephant ownership, aiming to reduce arbitrary and undocumented transfers.
  For example: Private owners transferring elephants must now provide ownership documents, helping curb illegal transactions in various states.
• Facilitating Monitoring Through Microchips: The Rules require elephants to be microchipped, enabling tracking and potentially identifying cases of illegal trade.
  For instance: In Rajasthan, microchip implantation helped authorities trace a captive elephant illegally transported to another state.
• Interim Transportation Guidelines: The Rules provide interim transportation protocols to ensure legal compliance during cross-state elephant movement.
  For example: Elephants transported for Kerala temple festivals must follow procedures, minimizing risks of exploitation during transit.
• Addressing Commercial Exploitation: The Rules restrict commercial activities like leasing elephants for events but lack explicit prohibitions on monetization.
  For instance: Some states have started imposing restrictions on using elephants in public ceremonies under Rule provisions.
• Digitization and Oversight Improvements: The mandate for genetic profiling and digitization enhances monitoring and minimizes undocumented elephant transfers.
  For example: The MoEFCC’s directive in 2024 emphasized creating a national genetic database for captive elephants to improve transparency.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store

Recommendations for Effective Implementation

• Ban on Commercial Transfers: Explicit prohibition of trade and leasing of elephants for commercial purposes is necessary.
  For example: The Elephant Project’s memorandum emphasized restricting transfers for religious or tourism purposes.
• Destruction of Microchips: Mandatory removal and destruction of microchips posthumously should be enforced under supervision.
  For example: Wildlife activists proposed microchip disposal protocols to curb illegal replacements.
• Humane Population Control: Non-invasive methods to control captive elephant births must be implemented.
  For example: Birth control initiatives in private elephant shelters in Karnataka show potential for humane management.
• Strict Transport Guidelines: Clear criteria for temporary transport and transfer should prevent misuse.
  For example: Elephant movements for entertainment events in Rajasthan highlight the need for stringent transport protocols.
• Stronger Penalties: Introduce punitive measures for violations to deter illegal activities and ensure compliance.
  For example: Higher fines and jail terms for offenders in elephant trafficking cases have been suggested by conservation groups.

The Captive Elephant (Transfer or Transport) Rules, 2024 mark a progressive step toward addressing illegal trade and improving elephant welfare in India. By ensuring stringent monitoring, transparent documentation, and ethical treatment, they uphold conservation goals while aligning with cultural reverence. Future efforts should focus on community participation, habitat restoration, and robust enforcement to harmonize wildlife protection and sustainable coexistence.

DOWNLOAD PDF