Answer:

Internal democracy within political parties is vital for transparency, accountability, and equitable representation in India’s multi-party system. Despite the Election Commission’s role in monitoring parties, challenges persist as many parties prioritise charismatic leadership over democratic decision-making, limiting new leadership and diverse voices.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Challenges of the Election Commission in Enforcing Internal Democracy

• Limited Legal Authority: The EC’s powers are constrained by the 2002 Supreme Court ruling, which limits its interference in the internal functioning of political parties, including internal elections.
  For instance: The Election Commission recently objected to the appointment of a permanent president for a political party, raising concerns about internal democracy, but its ability to enforce such rulings remains limited.
• Manipulated Internal Elections: Political parties often conduct managed elections, where outcomes are predetermined, reducing the effectiveness of the EC’s monitoring.
  For example: Internal elections in several parties often see the same individuals or families retaining control, limiting genuine competition.
• Bias Allegations: When the EC intervenes in party matters, it risks accusations of bias, which can undermine its credibility and neutrality.
  For example: Allegations of favouritism in setting election dates to benefit certain parties have occasionally surfaced, questioning the EC’s impartiality.
• Lack of Statutory Backing: The EC lacks a legal mandate to enforce internal democracy rules within parties, making it difficult to take corrective actions.
  For example: While the EC can advise parties to adhere to their constitutions, it cannot enforce penalties for violations of internal democratic principles.
• Resistance from Political Parties: Parties, especially those dominated by family leadership or individual leaders, resist EC’s attempts to promote internal democracy.
  For example: Several parties have leaders from the same family for generations, resisting reforms for internal elections.
• Practical Challenges in Oversight: Monitoring the internal affairs of thousands of political parties is a daunting task for the EC, given its limited resources.
  For example: Ensuring that parties conduct fair internal elections across states, districts, and regions is logistically challenging.
• Voter Indifference to Internal Democracy: Many voters prioritise immediate benefits over a party’s internal functioning, reducing the political incentive for parties to adopt internal democracy.
  For example: Voters may focus more on caste, religion, or short-term benefits like welfare schemes, rather than the internal dynamics of political parties.

Measures to Strengthen the Role of the EC in Enforcing Internal Democracy

• Legal Reforms to Empower EC: Amending laws to provide the EC with clear powers to regulate internal democracy within political parties can enhance its role.
  For instance: An amendment to the Representation of the People Act could include provisions for the EC to oversee internal elections within parties.
• Periodic Audits of Party Elections: The EC could mandate periodic audits of internal elections in political parties, ensuring compliance with democratic principles.
  For instance: The EC could require parties to submit election results and procedures to independent auditors.
• Penalties for Non-Compliance: The EC could be empowered to impose penalties or deregister political parties that do not follow internal democracy guidelines.
• Encouraging Public Disclosure: The EC could require political parties to publicly disclose their internal election processes, promoting transparency and accountability.
• Strengthening Election Tribunals: Establishing a robust mechanism for resolving disputes related to internal party elections could help the EC in ensuring fairness.
  For example: A dedicated tribunal for handling complaints related to party elections could provide a platform for addressing grievances.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store

Ensuring internal democracy within political parties is essential for strengthening India’s democratic fabric. While the Election Commission faces significant legal and practical challenges in enforcing these principles, targeted reforms can empower the EC to play a more effective role. Legal reforms, public disclosure, and periodic audits could ensure that political parties practise internal democracy, thus promoting merit-based leadership and furthering greater trust in democratic processes.

DOWNLOAD PDF