Answer

Populist welfare measures, like direct cash transfers, aim to provide immediate relief to vulnerable sections of society. For instance, schemes like PM-KISAN have supported rural households. However, these measures often raise concerns about fiscal sustainability, crowding out productive investment, and undermining job creation, thus posing challenges to long-term economic growth and employment generation in India.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Implications of Populist Welfare Measures on Long-term Economic Growth and Employment Generation in India

• Economic Distortion: Populist measures divert resources from productive investments, leading to short-term gains but hindering long-term sustainable growth and industrial development.
  For example: Direct cash schemes like PM-KISAN focus on immediate relief but reduce capital for long-term agriculture infrastructure development.
• Limited Employment Creation: Such measures fail to generate durable jobs as they do not address systemic issues like skill gaps and employment ecosystem diversification.
  For instance: In Madhya Pradesh, despite cash transfers, limited job diversification keeps unemployment high among youth, especially in rural areas.
• Inflationary Impact: Increased disposable incomes can trigger demand-pull inflation, particularly when supply-side issues persist in essential goods and services markets.
  For example: Tamil Nadu’s Magalir Urimai Thogai faced criticism for raising prices of essential goods in certain rural areas due to increased purchasing power.
• Weakening Public Institutions: Cash transfers can undermine investments in education, health, and infrastructure, which are crucial for equitable economic development and skilled workforce growth.
  For example: Delhi’s Mukhyamantri Mahila Samman Yojana prioritizes cash benefits over earlier investments in school and healthcare systems, limiting institutional development.
• Dependency Culture: Over-reliance on transfers creates dependency, reducing incentives for skill acquisition or entrepreneurship, essential for self-reliance and innovation-driven economic growth.
  For example: Studies in Maharashtra highlight that recipients of welfare schemes showed reduced participation in employment skill training programs.

Way Ahead

• Balanced Resource Allocation: Combine cash transfers with investment in infrastructure, focusing on job creation and regional balance to foster inclusive, long-term growth.
• Strengthen Public Services: Focus on education, healthcare, and skill development to improve human capital, making the workforce more competitive in global and domestic markets.
  For example: Kerala’s focus on universal education alongside limited welfare schemes has ensured higher literacy and employment rates among women.
• Promote Employment-intensive Sectors: Develop policies for labor-intensive industries such as textiles, construction, and food processing to enhance job opportunities at scale.
• Build Regional Economic Diversification: Encourage regional specialization and cluster development to reduce dependence on welfare in poorer states through self-sustaining industrial ecosystems.
  For example: Madhya Pradesh could replicate Punjab’s agricultural-agribusiness integration model to expand rural job creation.
• Empower Self-help Groups (SHGs): Support SHGs with financial inclusion and market linkages to enhance women’s economic participation and reduce reliance on subsidies.
  For example: The National Rural Livelihood Mission (NRLM) has empowered women in Bihar, boosting household incomes sustainably without long-term welfare dependency.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store

While populist welfare measures offer immediate relief, their long-term impact on economic growth and employment generation hinges on targeted policy integration. To ensure sustainable growth, these measures must be coupled with structural reforms, investment in skill development, and fostering entrepreneurship. A balanced approach can align welfare with long-term development objectives, reducing dependence on handouts and promoting inclusive growth.

DOWNLOAD PDF