Answer

The 2024 Economics Nobel Prize was awarded to Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson, and James A. Robinson for their influential research on how institutions shape a nation’s economic success. Their findings highlight the importance of inclusive institutions that promote secure property rights, democratic governance, and economic opportunities.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Crucial Role of Institutions in Determining a Nation’s Economic Success

• Secure Property Rights and Rule of Law: Institutions that enforce property rights create a conducive environment for investment by providing security against expropriation.
  For example: Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (2016) has improved business confidence by providing a framework for resolving insolvencies.
• Political Stability and Economic Growth: A stable political environment promotes predictable conditions, attracting investments and ensuring steady economic growth.
  For example: India’s democratic governance has facilitated reforms that have helped attract over $83 billion in foreign direct investment (FDI) in 2021-22, according to the Ministry of Commerce and Industry.
• Inclusive Economic Policies: Institutions that promote inclusive policies ensure equitable distribution of economic benefits, reducing poverty and promoting sustainable growth.
  For example: Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) scheme has streamlined subsidy delivery, benefiting over 900 million people and improving transparency in welfare schemes.
• Transparent Legal Frameworks: Transparent and predictable legal systems help reduce corruption and encourage fair competition, fostering entrepreneurship.
  For example: The Goods and Services Tax (GST) reform has unified the market, increasing tax compliance by 17% in 2023, thus enhancing the business environment.
• Institutional Support for Innovation: Institutions that encourage research and innovation contribute to technological advancements and economic growth.
  For example: Atal Innovation Mission (AIM) has set up over 10,000 tinkering labs in schools, promoting a culture of innovation 
• Infrastructure Development through Institutional Reforms: Strong institutions support infrastructure development, facilitating trade and economic activities.
  For example: The National Infrastructure Pipeline (NIP) aims to invest ₹111 lakh crore by 2025 in infrastructure, improving connectivity and supporting sustained economic growth in India.
• Empowering Human Capital: Institutions focusing on education and healthcare build a skilled workforce, which drives long-term growth.
  For example: National Education Policy (2020) targets doubling the Gross Enrolment Ratio in higher education by 2035, positioning the country to leverage its demographic dividend.

Shortcomings of Institutions in Determining a Nation’s Economic Success

• Corruption and Bureaucratic Inefficiencies: Corruption can undermine institutional effectiveness, leading to reduced investment and growth.
  For example: India’s low rank in the Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index (85th in 2023) highlights challenges in reducing corruption, which can deter investors.
• Slow Judicial Processes: Delays in judicial processes can impede business operations and deter economic activities.
  For example: India’s average time to resolve commercial disputes exceeds 1,400 days, making legal processes cumbersome for businesses, according to the World Bank.
• Resistance to Reforms: Institutions often face resistance to reforms, slowing the pace of change.
  For example: Protests against agricultural reforms in India in 2020 revealed challenges in balancing economic reforms with public acceptance, impacting policy implementation.
• Inequitable Access to Institutional Benefits: Despite reforms, marginalised communities often struggle to access benefits.
  For example: Digital India initiative, though extensive, faces a digital divide, with only 37% of rural areas having internet access, limiting economic inclusion.
• Overcentralization of Decision-Making: Centralised power can limit regional autonomy, affecting local development.
  For example: India’s fiscal federalism has seen states demanding greater control over GST revenues to better address local economic needs.
• Policy Uncertainty: Frequent policy changes can create uncertainty, discouraging long-term investments.
  For example: Changes in India’s e-commerce and data localization policies have raised concerns among global investors about regulatory predictability.
• Inefficiencies in Public Sector Enterprises: State-owned enterprises often suffer from low productivity, impacting economic efficiency.
  For example: India’s loss-making state-owned companies continue to receive government bailouts, affecting fiscal health and diverting resources from growth-oriented investments.

How Colonial History Has Shaped Modern Institutions

• Introduction of Centralised Governance: Colonial powers often set up centralised administrative systems that persist post-independence.
• Land Tenure Systems: Colonisation introduced land tenure systems that prioritised extraction over development.
  For example: The Zamindari system in India led to land dispossession and rural poverty, effects that still impact economic disparities.
• Legal and Judicial Systems: Colonizers imposed Western legal frameworks that continue to shape current legal systems.
  For example: India’s legal system, based on British common law, remains influential but faces challenges in addressing case backlogs.
• Infrastructure Focused on Resource Extraction: Colonial infrastructure was designed to facilitate extraction, impacting long-term development.
  For example: India’s railways, initially built for transporting raw materials, laid the foundation for the modern network but were primarily focused on colonial interests.
• Education Systems and Elites: Colonizers established education systems to train local elites for administration.
  For example: Universities like Calcutta University (1857) were created to produce a class of English-speaking administrators, influencing India’s bureaucratic culture post-independence.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books From PW Store

Impact of Institutions on Economic Development in Countries Like India

• Economic Reforms and Growth: Institutional reforms have driven India’s economic liberalisation, spurring growth and integration with the global market.
• Improved Financial Inclusion: Institutions have enabled wider financial inclusion, benefiting millions.
  For example: Jan Dhan Yojana has opened over 500 million bank accounts, providing access to formal banking and reducing poverty.
• Agricultural Policies and Rural Development: Institutional initiatives have boosted agricultural productivity and resilience.
  For example: The Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY) offers crop insurance, protecting millions of farmers from risks.
• Social Welfare Schemes: Institutions ensure the effective implementation of social welfare programs.
  For example: The MGNREGA has generated over 3 billion person-days of employment, supporting rural livelihoods.
• Digital Infrastructure and E-Governance: Investments in digital infrastructure have improved public service delivery.
  For example: The Aadhaar system has enabled streamlined subsidy distribution, improving transparency and access to welfare services.

The 2024 Nobel Prize emphasises the role of inclusive institutions in shaping a nation’s economic future. While strong institutions drive growth and equity, addressing their shortcomings through reforms and innovation is essential for sustained progress. A balanced focus on education, transparency, and collaborative governance can ensure that institutions continue to support economic prosperity

DOWNLOAD PDF