Answer

In a remote village nestled within a valley, there was a spring known as Jivan Dhara — the source of life. Generations of villagers had drawn from this spring, their existence intertwined with its gentle flow. Over time, as modern conveniences reached the village, the once-essential spring became a mere background to daily life. One year, after a severe drought, the spring dried up. It was then that the villagers realised the invaluable gift they had taken for granted. They lamented the lost waters that had sustained their lives for so long, a realisation dawning too late. This tale reflects a universal truth: we often fail to recognize the worth of something vital until it is gone, a theme deeply woven into the fabric of human experience and wisdom.

Water as a Metaphor for Life’s Essentials

Water, in its purest form, represents the basic necessities of life — health, relationships, and freedom. Much like water, these elements are so fundamental that we rarely acknowledge their presence until they are at risk or lost. Philosophically, this points to a profound need for gratitude and awareness. The ancients, such as the Stoics, taught that life’s fleeting nature should compel us to live with appreciation for the present moment. Just as we turn on a tap and expect water to flow, we often assume our loved ones, our health, or our freedoms will always be there. The existential reminder here is clear: life’s essentials, like water, are impermanent and must be cherished.

Abundance often breeds complacency. When resources are plentiful, we tend to become less aware of their intrinsic value. This is akin to Aristotelian ethics, where virtues are cultivated through awareness of our limits and the avoidance of excess. A well-filled with water does not prompt gratitude in its users; it is merely accepted as a given. However, the wisdom of scarcity brings clarity. In times of drought, every drop becomes precious. This wisdom aligns with Stoic philosophy, which suggests that facing scarcity or hardship brings about a deeper understanding of what is truly valuable in life. Consider the Great Depression of the 1930s. Before the economic collapse, there was a period of economic prosperity and carefree spending in the United States. When scarcity struck, people learned to value every meal, every job, every resource they had. This shift in mindset illustrates how scarcity can drive an appreciation of what remains, turning ordinary acts into moments of profound significance.

Often, it is not the presence but the absence of something that teaches its true value. This is reflected in the concept of anagnorisis in Greek tragedy, where a character comes to a critical realisation about themselves or their circumstances, often through loss. The drying of a well can serve as such a moment for humanity, prompting deeper understanding and potentially transformative behaviour. Just as King Lear, in Shakespeare’s tragedy, realises too late the true nature of love and loyalty, we often come to understand the worth of our water — be it a relationship, health, or peace — only after it is lost. During the COVID-19 pandemic, many people faced isolation, and the absence of social interactions underscored the value of community and human connection. It was the loss of physical proximity that highlighted how much these interactions meant to our well-being.

Human history often follows a cycle of forgetting and remembering the worth of essential resources. This can be philosophically linked to Nietzsche’s concept of eternal recurrence, where humanity seems doomed to repeat the same mistakes until genuine learning occurs. The cycle of abundance followed by scarcity — and the subsequent realisation of value — is a recurring theme in history. To break this cycle requires vigilance, a continuous state of reflection and awareness. The dust bowl of the 1930s in the United States resulted from a lack of sustainable agricultural practices. The lessons learned led to improved farming techniques, but over time, the vigilance has waned, and similar unsustainable practices have re-emerged, demonstrating our tendency to forget the hard-earned lessons of the past.

The Interconnectedness of Need and Value

The well’s dryness symbolises how need often drives the realisation of value. This notion is reflected in utilitarian philosophy, which argues that the value of something is derived from its utility, particularly when it becomes scarce. Relational ethics suggests that values are not intrinsic but emerge from relationships and context. The worth of water becomes evident in relation to its scarcity, much like how many life values are only truly understood in moments of loss or absence.  For instance, in regions experiencing extreme drought, such as parts of sub-Saharan Africa, the scarcity of water has led to a heightened appreciation and innovative solutions for water conservation. The community value of water is realised most profoundly when it is no longer readily available.

Similarly, the drying well serves as a metaphor for environmental degradation and the human failure to recognize the intrinsic value of nature until it is lost. This idea resonates with deep ecology, which emphasises the intrinsic worth of all living beings, beyond their utility to humans. The anthropocentric view values water only when it serves human needs, while an ecocentric view recognizes water’s inherent value, regardless of its immediate use to humanity. As it is rightly said, “What is the use of a house if you haven’t got a tolerable planet to put it on?” . For instance, the Aral Sea, once one of the world’s largest lakes, has been nearly drained due to poor management and overuse for irrigation. The loss of this body of water has had catastrophic environmental, economic, and social impacts, demonstrating the consequences of failing to value natural resources until they are nearly gone.

Furthermore, Deprivation can be a powerful teacher, forcing a reevaluation of what is essential. This theme is prevalent in ascetic practices across various religious and philosophical traditions, which suggest that self-imposed scarcity can lead to a deeper understanding and appreciation of life’s essentials. The worth of water when the well is dry could also be framed within Hegelian dialectics, where understanding comes through a process of thesis (abundance), antithesis (scarcity), and synthesis (new awareness of value). For example, the fasting practices in many religious traditions, such as Ramadan in Islam, lead to a heightened appreciation for food and empathy for those who are less fortunate, demonstrating how temporary deprivation can foster a deeper sense of gratitude and value.

Water, like other fundamental needs, reveals our dependence on external elements for survival. This can be related to existentialist philosophy, which explores themes of dependence, freedom, and the constraints that define human existence. The drying well represents the fragility of human control over nature, suggesting an existential recognition of human vulnerability and the illusion of mastery over our environment. For instance, the Fukushima nuclear disaster highlighted human vulnerability and the limits of our control over natural and technological forces. The dependence on nuclear energy and the subsequent disaster when things went wrong emphasised the existential dilemma of reliance on potentially destructive forces.

Moreover, water is often a symbol of renewal and destruction. It is life-sustaining but can also be a force of chaos and destruction when uncontrolled. This duality can be explored in the context of Taoist philosophy, which sees life as a balance of opposing forces (Yin and Yang). The loss of water, or its drying up, could metaphorically represent a spiritual drought, suggesting that spiritual fulfilment often comes after a period of existential dryness or searching. For example, in various cultures, water is seen as a cleansing force, symbolising both physical and spiritual purification. The practice of baptism in Christianity represents a symbolic rebirth through water, demonstrating its dual nature as both a source of life and a means of transformation.

The drying of the well serves as a call to action for collective responsibility and the preservation of shared resources. This resonates with communitarian philosophy, which emphasises the importance of community and shared values in defining moral action. The idea of preemptive appreciation — valuing and caring for essential resources before they are depleted — aligns with conservation ethics, which advocate for the sustainable use and stewardship of natural resources. As Mahatma Gandhi rightly said, “The earth provides enough to satisfy every man’s needs, but not every man’s greed.”  For example, the Chipko Movement in India, where villagers, particularly women, hugged trees to prevent their logging, is a powerful example of communal responsibility and preemptive action to protect natural resources.

The proverb “We never know the worth of water till the well is dry” is a profound reflection on human nature and our relationship with essential resources. It serves as a reminder of the importance of gratitude, awareness, and stewardship. By recognizing the intrinsic value of what sustains us — be it water, love, or freedom — before it is lost, we can cultivate a more mindful and responsible existence. Just as the villagers lamented the loss of their spring, let us not wait until the well is dry to realise the worth of the water that sustains us. Instead, let us act with foresight and wisdom, cherishing and preserving the precious elements of life, ensuring they continue to flow for future generations.

DOWNLOAD PDF