Revenue Receipts: Tax vs. Non-Tax Dimensions

Revenue Receipts are defined as those receipts that do not create a claim on the government and, hence are termed as non-redeemable. They are broadly categorized into Tax Revenues and Non-Tax Revenues.

What is Tax Revenue and how does it work in Government Receipts?

• Definition: Tax revenue is the income that is collected by governments through taxation serving as the primary source of government receipts.
  • Taxation is the primary source of government revenue. 
  • Tax revenues are further subdivided into:
  • Direct Taxes: Personal, Corporate, and the Legacy of Paper Taxes: A direct tax is a tax that a person or organization pays directly to the government or an entity that imposed it. 
    • Personal Income Tax: Levied on individuals’ income.
    • Corporation Tax: Levied on firms’ profits.
    • Other direct taxes like wealth tax, gift tax, and estate duty (now abolished) are termed ‘paper taxes’ due to their minimal contribution to revenue.
  • Indirect Taxes – Goods, Customs, Service Levies: Indirect tax is the tax levied on the consumption of goods and services. Following are some examples:
    • Excise Taxes: Duties on goods produced domestically
    • Customs Duties: Taxes on imported and exported goods
    • Service Tax: Levied on the provision of services.
• Taxation System: Progressive vs. Proportional

The taxation system is primarily categorized into two types:

• • Progressive Taxation System: In this taxation system, higher income attracts a higher tax rate. 
  • Proportional Taxation System:  In this taxation system, where the tax rate is a particular proportion of profits.
• Indirect taxes – Necessities, Comforts, and Luxuries: They are structured in a way to exempt or levy lower rates on necessities, moderate rates on comforts and semi-luxuries, and heavy rates on luxuries, tobacco, and petroleum products.

Which Sources Contribute to Government Receipts Beyond Taxes in Non-Tax Revenue?

• Non-tax revenue, a vital component of government receipts, encompasses recurring income earned by the government from sources other than taxes. Following are some examples:
• • Interest Receipts: From loans provided by the central government.
  • Dividends and Profits: From government investments.
  • Fees and Other Receipts: For services rendered by the government.
  • Cash Grants-in-aid: From foreign countries and international organizations.
• The estimation of revenue receipts is influenced by the tax proposals outlined in the Finance Bill.

How do Government Receipts, Including Loans and Asset Sales, Impact Government Finances?

• Definition: Capital Receipts are defined as the monetary gains received by the government either through loans or the sale of its assets. 
  • These receipts either create a liability or reduce the financial assets of the government. 

Following are the capital receipts:

• Understanding Loans: A loan is a sum of money that an individual, company, or government borrows from a bank or other financial institution. 
  • Loans obtained by the government need to be repaid to the lending agencies, thereby creating a liability.
  • Taking fresh loans implies future repayment along with the payment of interest on these loans.
• Government Asset Disinvestment – Impact on Finances: Assets sales, such as the disinvestment of Public Sector Undertakings (PSUs), result in a reduction of the government’s total financial assets.
  • This disinvestment refers to the sale of government shares in PSUs.
  • Post-sale, the government foregoes future earnings that could have been generated from those assets.
• Debt-Creating and Non-Debt Creating Receipts
  • Debt Receipts: These are the receipts which create financial liabilities for the government. For example, loans. 
  • Non-debt Receipts: These are the receipts which don’t create any financial liabilities for the government.
• Capital Receipts Implications: Balancing Liabilities and Earning Potential
• • While loans enhance liabilities due to repayment and interest obligations, asset sales diminish the government’s financial asset base along with future earning potential from those assets.
• The dynamics of these government receipts significantly affect the broader financial landscape, shaping the government’s economic and fiscal policies.

How is Government Expenditure Classified, and Its Relation to Government Receipts?

What is Revenue Expenditure?

• Definition: It refers to the spending incurred for purposes other than the creation of physical or financial assets of the central government. 
• • It encompasses expenses necessary for the normal functioning of government departments and services, interest payments on government debt, and grants distributed to state governments and other parties.

Understanding Revenue Expenditure: Plan vs. Non-Plan and Its Link to Government Receipts

Revenue Expenditure is classified into plan and Non-Plan Expenditure (Refer to Table ) as per budget documents:

• Plan Revenue Expenditure: Five-Year Plans and Central Assistance : It relates to central Plans (the Five-Year plans) and central assistance for State and Union Territory plans.

• Non-Plan Revenue Expenditure: Key Insights into Government Finances: It covers a vast range of general, economic and social services of the government. 
  • The main items of non-plan expenditure are interest payments, defense services, subsidies, salaries and pensions.
  • Interest Payments: On-market loans, external loans, and various reserve funds, represent the largest component of non-plan revenue expenditure.
  • Defense Services: Regarded as committed expenditure due to national security concerns, there is little scope for a significant reduction.
  • Subsidies: These are an important policy tool aimed at enhancing welfare. 
    • These can be implicit, through under-pricing of public goods and services like education and health, or explicit, on items such as exports, interest on loans, food, and fertilizers.
  • Salaries and Pensions: For government employees.

Non-Plan Revenue Expenditure insights have an impact on government finances by directing governance and economic policies in relation to Government receipts.

Capital Expenditure: Key to Financial Strategies and Government Receipts

• Definition: It refers to government spending that results in the creation of physical or financial assets or a reduction in financial liabilities. It includes:
  • Acquisition of land, buildings, machinery, and equipment.
  • Investment in shares.
  • Loans and advances by the central government to state and union territory governments, Public Sector Undertakings (PSUs), and other parties.
• Classification of Capital Expenditure: Capital Expenditure is also categorized as Plan and Non-Plan Expenditure in budget documents:
• Plan Capital Expenditure: Central and State Assistance Dynamics : This pertains to the central plan and central assistance for state and union territory plans.
• Non-Plan Capital Expenditure: Embracing Diverse Government Services: It covers various general, social, and economic services provided by the government.
• The Budget as a National Policy Statement: Shaping India’s Economic Landscape
  • The budget, especially post-independence with the initiation of the Five-Year Plans, has evolved to become a significant national policy statement, reflecting, shaping, and being shaped by the country’s economic life.
• Accompanying the budget, three policy statements mandated by the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act, 2003 (FRBM) Act are:
  • Medium-term Fiscal Policy Statement: Sustaining Finances and Resource Efficiency: It sets a three-year rolling target for specific fiscal indicators, examining the sustainability of financing revenue expenditure through revenue receipts and the productive utilization of capital receipts, including market borrowings.
  • Fiscal Policy Strategy Statement: Priorities, Policies, and Deviations Justified: It sets the government’s fiscal priorities, examines current policies, and justifies any deviations in significant fiscal measures.
  • Macroeconomic Framework: Evaluating Growth, Fiscal Balance, and External Dynamics: It assesses the economy’s prospects concerning the GDP growth rate, the fiscal balance of the central government, and the external balance.

DOWNLOAD PDF