NCERT NOTES

Elevate your UPSC preparation with NCERT Notes – because every word matters on your journey to success.

Upholding Democracy: The Rule of Law and the Evolution of Human Rights

November 23, 2023 570 0

Introduction: Rights & Rule of Law Evolution

The essence of the Constitution extends beyond governing body structure and interrelationships. As explored previously, the Constitution is a blueprint that constrains governmental authority, ensuring a democratic framework with guaranteed rights. Over the last six decades, these rights have evolved and, in some aspects, broadened too.  

Life Without Rights: The Impact of Rule of Law on Individual Liberty

  • Hampers Individual Liberty and Dignity: Life without rights is a scenario that raises fundamental questions about individual liberties, dignity, and the very essence of human existence.
  • Devoid of Protections: In such a situation, individuals would find themselves devoid of the protections and entitlements granted by a framework of rights

Case Study: Guantanamo Bay

  • Guantanamo Bay detention camp, located in Cuba, has been a subject of controversy due to the alleged violation of human rights and the absence of legal safeguards for detainees.
  • Legal Limbo: Detainees were held in a legal gray area where they were not treated as prisoners of war but were also not afforded the rights of criminal suspects.
  • Torture Allegations: Several detainees reported cases of torture, including waterboarding and other forms of physical and psychological abuse.
  • Habeas Corpus Challenges: Detainees faced challenges in seeking legal redress through habeas corpus petitions due to jurisdictional complexities.

Impact on Human Rights

  • The Guantanamo case raises concerns about the erosion of fundamental human rights, including the right to a fair trial, protection from torture, and due process.
  • The lack of transparency and accountability in detention practices undermines the principle of the rule of law.
  • International Response: International human rights organizations, such as Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, have criticized the treatment of detainees at Guantanamo Bay.

Expanding Scope of Rights: The Rule of Law in an Evolving Social Landscape

  • Historical Evolution: Over time, societies have recognized new rights based on changing needs and evolving social values, such as the right to education, healthcare, and a clean environment.
  • Technological Advancements: The digital age has given rise to new discussions on rights, including digital privacy, data protection, and the right to access information.
  • Global Interconnectedness: The interconnected world has prompted discussions about universal human rights, transcending national borders, and focusing on issues like migration and climate change.
  • Marginalized Groups: Advocacy for marginalized groups has led to the recognition of rights for LGBTQ+ individuals, people with disabilities, and indigenous communities, expanding the understanding of equality and inclusivity.
  • Evolving Concepts: Societal progress and changing norms continue to redefine rights, as seen in debates about reproductive rights, gender equality, and the right to a clean environment.

Rights in Democracy: The Rule of Law and Essential Rights

Meaning and Definition: Rights are inherent entitlements and protections that individuals possess by virtue of being human.

  • Provide Freedoms: They ensure that individuals have the freedom to live with dignity, make choices, express themselves, and participate in society without undue interference. 
  • Rights embedded within the framework of the Rule of Law, can include civil, political, economic, social, and cultural dimensions.
  • Claim to Nation: Rights specifically are claims of a person over other fellow beings, over the society and over the government, all upheld by the principles of the Rule of Law.
  • Any claim to be called as a right has to have three qualities viz: 
    • Reasonable claims of persons 
    • Recognized by society 
    • Sanctioned by law.

Dimensions of rights

Rights: An essence of Democracy 

  • Rights act as a building block for any democracy, which prevents any kind of injustice in society. The absence of rights leads to the exploitation of vulnerable sections and subsequent clashes in society.

Examples for better realization: Contrasting Realities of the Rule of law

Citizens’ Rights in Saudi Arabia

  • Saudi Arabia, a hereditary monarchy, denies citizens basic rights and participation in governance.
  • Monarchical Regime: The ruler is hereditary, and citizens have no role in selecting or changing rulers.
    • King appoints legislature, executive, and judges, and can alter judicial decisions.
    • Citizens can’t form political parties or organizations; media censorship is common.
  • Religious and Gender Restrictions: Every citizen must be Muslim; non-Muslim residents can practice religion privately. Women face public restrictions; the testimony of one man equals that of two women.

Ethnic Massacre in Kosovo

  • A province with an ethnic Albanian majority, Kosovo, experienced violence due to Serbian nationalism.
  • A Serb nationalist, Milosevic, was elected in democratic elections. His government suppressed Kosovo Albanians. Thousands of Albanians were killed or displaced by Serbian forces.
  • Global intervention stopped the massacre; Milosevic faced trial for crimes against humanity.
  • This highlights the complexity of atrocities under a democratic government.

 

Points to Ponder:

Democratic countries offer a plethora of rights to their citizens. This is in tune with the principles of the rule of law, individual liberty, dignity, and lack of authoritarianism.

  • Both the above examples of Saudi Arabia’s autocratic rule and Kosovo’s violent experience emphasize the importance of human rights and democratic values in a society.

Necessity of Rights in Democracy: Democracy’s Lifeblood

  • Rights, underpinned by the Rule of Law, are essential for sustaining a democracy.
  • Citizens need the right to vote and be elected for democratic elections to function effectively.
  • Citizens must have the right to express their opinions and engage in political activities. 
  • The ability to form political parties and participate in governance is vital for democratic processes.

Role of Rights in Democracy: Protecting Minorities through Rights

  • Rights, governed by the Rule of Law, play a crucial role in protecting minorities from potential oppression by the majority. 
  • They prevent situations where the majority tries to suppress or eliminate the rights of the minority.
  • They prevent the majority from abusing its power and ensure balanced decision-making.

Government’s Responsibility: Safeguarding Citizens’ Essential Rights

  • In cases of rights infringement, the government, guided by the Rule of Law, is responsible for protecting citizens’ rights.
  • Rights serve as a defense against any attempt to curtail individual freedoms.
  • Some rights need to be higher than the government’s authority to prevent violations.
  • These rights are safeguarded from government interference.

Written Rights in Constitutions: The Rule of Law in Protecting Citizens’ Rights

  • Many democracies outline citizens’ basic rights in their constitutions.
  • This ensures that fundamental rights are recognized and protected by the legal framework of the nation, guided by the Rule of Law.
  • In a democracy, rights empower citizens, promote fair representation and establish a balance of power between the government and the people.

Need help preparing for UPSC or State PSCs?

Connect with our experts to get free counselling & start preparing

THE MOST
LEARNING PLATFORM

Learn From India's Best Faculty

      
Quick Revise Now !
AVAILABLE FOR DOWNLOAD SOON
UDAAN PRELIMS WALLAH
Comprehensive coverage with a concise format
Integration of PYQ within the booklet
Designed as per recent trends of Prelims questions
हिंदी में भी उपलब्ध
Quick Revise Now !
UDAAN PRELIMS WALLAH
Comprehensive coverage with a concise format
Integration of PYQ within the booklet
Designed as per recent trends of Prelims questions
हिंदी में भी उपलब्ध

<div class="new-fform">







    </div>

    Subscribe our Newsletter
    Sign up now for our exclusive newsletter and be the first to know about our latest Initiatives, Quality Content, and much more.
    *Promise! We won't spam you.
    Yes! I want to Subscribe.