NCERT NOTES

Elevate your UPSC preparation with NCERT Notes – because every word matters on your journey to success.

Citizenship: Balancing Rights, Responsibilities, and Migration Challenges Explored

November 22, 2023 1044 0

Introduction: Citizenship in Global Perspective

Citizenship holds a significant place in the global framework, being defined as the full and equal membership of a political community. In today’s contemporary world, states play a pivotal role in shaping the identity of their citizens by providing them with a collective political identity and bestowing upon them certain unalienable rights. This identity is deeply ingrained in individuals, whether one identifies as Indian, Japanese, or German, it is fundamentally tied to the state they belong to. 

Citizenship in Global Perspective

Citizen and State: Expectations, Obligations, and the Inheritance of Culture and Resources

  • Citizenship Expectations: Citizenship identity comes with an inherent expectation of citizens from their state. The expectations are as follows:
    • Citizens anticipate receiving rights from their state and
    • Citizens also seek State protection, no matter where they may travel. 
  • Obligations and Responsibilities: However, citizenship is also about citizen-citizen relations and citizen-society relations, as it involves certain obligations (political and moral) of citizens to each other and to society. 
  • Inheritors of Resources: Apart from that, citizens are also considered to be the inheritors and trustees of the culture and natural resources of the country.

Journey to Citizenship: From Monarchies to Modern Struggles

  • These rights enjoyed by citizens have been acquired after various struggles.
    • Early struggles were against powerful monarchies, like the French Revolution in 1789.
    • In the recent past, in Asian and African colonies also, demands for equal citizenship were part of their independence struggles. 
      • For example, in South Africa, black Africans fought for equal citizenship against the ruling white minority till the 1990s.
  • The struggles for full membership and equal rights are still going on in many parts globally. 
    • Women’s movement and Dalit movements in India etc.

Understanding Full And Equal Membership: The Dynamics of Insiders and Outsiders

  • Insiders and Outsiders Division: If you have ever traveled in a crowded railway compartment, you will be familiar with the way in which those who may have earlier fought each other to enter, once inside, discover a shared interest in keeping others out. 
    • A division soon develops between ‘insiders’ and ‘outsiders’, with ‘outsiders’ being seen as a threat.

Comparing Crowded Spaces to Citizenship: Insights into Division, Resources, and the Right to Movement

Comparison Point

Crowded Places

Larger Communities

Division Dynamics Those inside the crowded place (like a train compartment) form a unit becoming insiders and oppose others who are trying to enter, i.e. outsiders. Similar divisions are observed in cities, regions, or at the national level. 
Scarce Resources Space is limited. Jobs, medical care, education, and natural resources are limited.
Response to Outsiders Those inside attempt to prevent further entries. Demands may arise to restrict entry to ‘outsiders’. For example, ‘Mumbai for Mumbaikars’.

 

Interpreting Full and Equal Membership: Basic Rights, Movement, and Challenges in a Diverse Society

  • Basic Rights and Protection: In simple words, full and equal membership means each and every citizen of the State should be granted certain basic rights along with appropriate mechanisms to ensure its protection. 
  • Right to Freedom of Movement: The concept of “Full and Equal Membership” delves deeply into the right to freedom of movement. 
    • This right is particularly significant for the working populace.
  • Migrant Workers and Urban Centers: In the absence of job opportunities proximal to their residences, labor tends to migrate. 
    • For example, migrant workers from the northern influx into some big cities like Mumbai, Bangalore etc.
  • Challenges of Influx: Conversely, when local residents discern an overwhelming number of outsiders availing of local job opportunities, it often culminates in resistance. 
  • Regional Job Restrictions: Such dynamics lead to demands for job restrictions based on regional belonging or linguistic proficiency.
  • Universal Migration Rights: This raises the question of whether poor and unskilled workers should have the same right to live and work anywhere in the country as skilled workers. 
The Paradox of Migration

  • There exists a glaring disparity in our sentiments: while we express indignation when Indian workers face maltreatment overseas, but we manifest contradictory feelings towards internal migrants.
  • Another dimension to contemplate is the differential reception meted out to impoverished migrants in contrast to their skilled counterparts.
  • Handling Right to Movement: Balancing the Right to Movement with Article 19 and Democratic Principles
    • Article 19: The Indian Constitution under Article 19 guarantees the freedom of expression, encompassing the right to protest (in the above context, local people protest against migrant workers).
      •  It also contains the right to freedom of movement and residence (in the above context, migrant workers influx in big cities).
    • Guiding Principle: If the guiding principle of providing full and equal membership to all citizens is kept in mind, it should be possible to arrive at an acceptable solution to the above problems that may arise from time to time in a society. 
    • Negotiation and Discussion: A basic principle of democracy is that such disputes should be settled by negotiation and discussion rather than force.
      • This is one of the obligations of citizenship.

Need help preparing for UPSC or State PSCs?

Connect with our experts to get free counselling & start preparing

THE MOST
LEARNING PLATFORM

Learn From India's Best Faculty

      
Quick Revise Now !
AVAILABLE FOR DOWNLOAD SOON
UDAAN PRELIMS WALLAH
Comprehensive coverage with a concise format
Integration of PYQ within the booklet
Designed as per recent trends of Prelims questions
हिंदी में भी उपलब्ध
Quick Revise Now !
UDAAN PRELIMS WALLAH
Comprehensive coverage with a concise format
Integration of PYQ within the booklet
Designed as per recent trends of Prelims questions
हिंदी में भी उपलब्ध

<div class="new-fform">







    </div>

    Subscribe our Newsletter
    Sign up now for our exclusive newsletter and be the first to know about our latest Initiatives, Quality Content, and much more.
    *Promise! We won't spam you.
    Yes! I want to Subscribe.