The decision to include caste enumeration in India’s upcoming national Census marks a potentially transformative step. However, it also raises questions about intent, policy delay, and the true commitment to social justice.

The Case for Caste Census

• Caste Census Importance: A caste census provides empirical data to understand the socio-economic status of caste groups, particularly OBCs.
• Affirmative Action Design: Helps design targeted affirmative action and lends credibility to welfare measures before the judiciary.
• Intra-OBC Disparities: Can expose intra-OBC disparities, assisting in crafting policies for Extremely Backward Classes (EBCs).

Limitations of Census-Based Policymaking

• Risk of Political Misuse: Over-relying on the Census risks misusing it as a political tool rather than a data-gathering mechanism.
• Registrar General’s Role: The Registrar General is meant to present neutral data, not influence policy formation.
• Politicisation of Census: Risks politicising Census operations in an already polarised political climate.

Historical Reforms Without Full Data

• No Precise Data: Major reforms like reservations and land redistribution were implemented through political will, not precise data.
• EWS Quota Without Surveys: The EWS quota was introduced without detailed surveys, showing governments can act without waiting for new statistics.

Existing Data Already Available

• SC/ST Data Availability: SC/ST data is part of every decennial Census and national surveys like NFHS and NSSO.
• Persistent Disadvantages Despite Data: Reports show persistent educational, economic, and social disadvantages, yet bold reforms remain absent.
• Bihar Survey & SECC Findings: The Bihar caste survey and SECC confirm widespread OBC vulnerabilities.

Neglect in Representation

• Low Representation in Sectors: Research highlights low OBC/SC/ST presence in corporate sectors, media, IT, and state institutions.
• Lack of Efforts to Improve Representation: Despite abundant data, no major efforts have been made to improve their representation in higher education, judiciary, or bureaucracy.

Data vs. Political Will

• Data as Diagnostic Tool: Data serves as a diagnostic tool, not the solution itself.
• Political Will Drives Policy: Effective public policy is driven by political intent, mass mobilization, and democratic pressure, not just statistics or surveys.

Conclusion

While a caste census may enhance policy precision, true social transformation demands bold action, moral clarity, and sustained political will. Justice for the most marginalized cannot wait for the perfect dataset.

DOWNLOAD PDF