India is witnessing a new wave of student migration beyond elite institutions, marked by self-financed education driven by middle-class aspirations, global credentials, and upward mobility.
Scale and Patterns of Indian Student Migration
- Growth in Student Numbers Abroad: According to Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) data, Indian student enrolment abroad crossed 13.2 lakh across 70+ countries (2023), rose to 13.35 lakh (2024), and is projected to reach 13.8 lakh in 2025.
- Major Destination Countries: India is among the top global sources of international students. The United States and Canada together host ~40% of Indian students abroad, followed by the United Kingdom, Australia, and Germany.
- Recognition as a Diaspora Category: The Parliamentary Committee on the Welfare of Indian Diaspora (2022) identifies students as one of India’s major diaspora categories.
Key Issues in Student Migration
- Illusion of Democratisation: While foreign education is seen as becoming accessible to students from varied socio-economic backgrounds, the reality is more complex and uneven in terms of quality and outcomes.
- Concentration in Lower-Tier Institutions: Many Indian students are channelled into lower-tier universities and vocational colleges abroad, often pursuing courses unrelated to their prior expertise and offering limited employment prospects.
- Role of Recruitment Agencies: This pattern is shaped by recruitment agencies operating in a grey legal zone that direct students to such institutions.
- Profit-Driven Foreign Education Industry: The partnerships between recruitment networks and less credible private colleges abroad are driven primarily by commissions and profit, reflecting the largely unregulated expansion of the foreign education industry.
Consequences of the Current Model
- Deskilling and Underemployment: The outcome is widespread deskilling and underemployment, with many graduates unable to transition into skilled employment after completing their studies.
- Case of the United Kingdom: In the U.K., institutions that were formerly polytechnics were converted into universities after 1992 and now cater primarily to international students.
- Declining Academic Standards: Some of these institutions have waived entry requirements, sparking controversy over the decline in academic standards.
- Limited Skilled Visa Outcomes: Reports indicate that approximately only one in four Indian postgraduates in the U.K. secures a sponsored skilled visa.
Kerala Case Study: The Shift from Labour Migration to Student-Led Mobility
- Historical Migration Pattern: Kerala has historically been shaped by Gulf labour migration.
- Rapid Rise in Student Migration: The Kerala Migration Survey (KMS) 2023 reports that student migration doubled in five years, rising from 1.29 lakh in 2018 to 2.5 lakh in 2023.
- Share in Total Emigration: Student migrants constituted 11.3% of total emigrants from Kerala.
- Outward Student Remittances: Outward student remittances from Kerala are estimated at ₹43,378 crore, equivalent to about 20% of total inward remittances from labour migrants.
|
Contribution of Student Migration to Host Economies
- Canadian Context: In 2022, international students contributed $30.9 billion to Canada’s GDP, supporting 3.61 lakh jobs; by 2023, Indian students (4.27 lakh) constituted ~45% of total international enrolments.
- United States: In 2024, around 4,00,000 Indian students were enrolled, spending an estimated $7–8 billion annually on tuition, housing, and living expenses.
Challenges of International Migrant Students
- Reverse Remittances: Self-financed migration (₹40–50 lakh per student), loans, and mortgaged assets often lead to debt, underemployment, or forced return, with Indian households subsidising foreign economies.
- Living & Work Pressures: High rents, work-hour caps, and visa limits intensify financial and mental stress, pushing students into low-wage, unskilled jobs.
- Informal Exploitation: Multiple part-time or undocumented jobs expose students to precarious and exploitative conditions.
- Policy Shocks: Restrictive visa regimes and shrinking post-study pathways worsen downward mobility (e.g., closure of the UK student-to-care visa route post-2024).
- The PR Trap: Aspirations for Permanent Residency often translate into cramped living and cheap-labour absorption, not upward mobility.
Conclusion
Indian student migration reflects a gap between aspiration and outcome, leading to brain waste. This calls for tighter regulation of education agents, pre-departure counselling, and stronger bilateral accountability frameworks.