The Prime Minister has made a rare direct appeal to the public to adopt specific behaviors for at least one year to help the nation’s economy. These requests include:
- Restricting Purchases: Citizens are asked not to buy gold for one year.
- Limiting Travel & Celebrations: An appeal was made to avoid foreign travel and destination weddings (specifically mentions of locations like Italy or Switzerland) to save foreign exchange.
- Energy Conservation: Encouraging Work from Home (WFH) where possible and using public transport to reduce fuel consumption.
- Agricultural Changes: Asking farmers to reduce the use of chemical fertilizers.
UPSC Coaching Classes
Causes of Economic Stress
- West Asia Conflict and Strait of Hormuz Crisis: The conflict involving the United States, Israel, and Iran has disrupted supplies through the Strait of Hormuz, affecting global oil trade and creating economic pressure on import-dependent countries like India.
- India’s Import Dependence: India imports nearly 80% of its crude oil requirements from foreign countries. Consequently, any increase in global oil prices substantially raises India’s import bill.
- Import-Induced Inflation: When the supply of imported goods decreases while demand remains constant, prices begin to rise sharply. Imported commodities become more expensive, leading to inflation within the domestic economy.
Pressure on Rupee and Foreign Exchange Reserves
- Mechanism of Rupee Depreciation: India pays for crude oil imports in US dollars. As oil prices increase, India requires a larger quantity of dollars to pay for imports.
- Greater demand for dollars in the foreign exchange market weakens the Indian rupee relative to the US dollar. As the rupee weakens, imports become even more expensive, thereby creating additional inflationary pressure.
RBI Intervention
- To stabilize the rupee and prevent excessive currency depreciation, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) intervenes in the foreign exchange market by releasing dollars from India’s foreign exchange reserves.
- This temporary increase in dollar supply helps:
- Stabilize the rupee,
- Reduce panic in currency markets,
- Manage excessive volatility in exchange rates.
However, continuous intervention gradually reduces the size of India’s forex reserves.
Flight of Capital and FII Withdrawal
Role of Foreign Institutional Investors (FIIs)
- Foreign Institutional Investors (FIIs) invest in stock markets and financial assets of different countries. Emerging economies such as India often receive large inflows of foreign investment during periods of economic stability and growth.
- However, during periods of war, geopolitical uncertainty, or market instability, FIIs tend to withdraw investments from emerging markets and shift their funds toward safer assets such as US Treasury Bonds.
Impact on India
The withdrawal of foreign institutional investments from India results in:
- Outflow of US dollars,
- Decline in foreign exchange reserves,
- Weakening of the rupee.
As dollars leave the Indian economy, the shortage of dollars increases their value relative to the rupee, thereby intensifying currency depreciation.
UPSC Online Coaching
Criticism of the Government’s Approach
- Delay Due to Elections: Critics argue that warning signs regarding economic stress were visible even before elections, but difficult economic decisions were postponed due to political considerations.
-
- According to this argument, the government avoided communicating the seriousness of the economic situation during the election period and delayed corrective measures until elections were completed.
- Fuel Prices Not Increased Before Elections: Another criticism relates to fuel pricing policy. Critics argue that if the government genuinely intended to reduce fuel consumption, fuel prices could have been increased earlier.
- Higher prices generally discourage excessive consumption and encourage resource conservation. However, political considerations allegedly delayed such economic correction measures.
“Good Economics vs Good Politics”
- “Good economics is bad politics, and good politics is bad economics.”
- It highlights the conflict between economically sound reforms and politically popular measures, as necessary steps like subsidy rationalization and fuel price hikes are often unpopular among voters.
- At the same time, short-term populist policies aimed at electoral gains may weaken long-term economic discipline and fiscal stability.
El Niño Concerns
- El Niño is a climatic phenomenon associated with warming of surface waters in the Pacific Ocean. It often weakens the Indian monsoon and increases the possibility of drought conditions in the country.
- Weak monsoons reduce agricultural productivity and create pressure on food security.
Sri Lanka Example (2021–22)
- The Sri Lanka Parallel: The request for farmers to reduce chemical fertilizers is criticized because India is facing an El Niño year, which typically results in weak monsoons and drought. A similar sudden shift away from chemical fertilizers in Sri Lanka led to a 20% drop in rice production and a severe food crisis.
High-Value Keywords for Mains Answers
- Macroeconomic Vulnerability — Large-scale economic instability due to external/internal shocks
- Import-Induced Inflation — Inflation caused by rise in cost of imported goods (oil, commodities)
- Flight of Capital — FII/foreign investor money exiting the domestic economy
- Currency Depreciation — Fall in rupee’s exchange value relative to foreign currencies
- Policy Myopia — Short-sighted decision-making; prioritising short-term political gain
- Fiscal Prudence — Responsible, disciplined government expenditure management
|
Click to Know UPSC OnlyIAS Coaching Centres
Governance and Infrastructure Critique
- Work From Home Limitation: The appeal encouraging work-from-home arrangements faces practical limitations because employees often do not independently control workplace policies.
- In most cases, employers decide whether employees will work remotely or physically attend offices. Therefore, large-scale adoption of work-from-home cannot occur solely through public appeals.
- Weak Public Transport Infrastructure: Citizens are encouraged to reduce private vehicle usage and rely more on public transport. However, public transport infrastructure remains inadequate in many regions of the country. Problems include:
- Insufficient public buses,
- Weak urban transport systems,
- Inadequate connectivity,
- Poor transport infrastructure in smaller towns and cities.
- Critique of Freebies: A broader governance criticism presented in the discussion concerns the excessive use of freebies in politics.
- According to this argument, excessive expenditure on freebies reduces the fiscal space available for: Road infrastructure, Public transport systems, Long-term development projects and Economic infrastructure creation.