Subject: GS 2: Important Aspects of Governance
Context: Indian cities have largely been designed around motor vehicles rather than people. As a result, pedestrians, cyclists, children, senior citizens, and persons with disabilities face unsafe and inaccessible streets.
A recent Supreme Court judgment (2026) reaffirmed that the right to walk safely on designated footpaths is a Fundamental Right, highlighting the need for people-centric urban planning.
Background
- Rapid urbanisation and rising vehicle ownership have resulted in increasing congestion and reduced pedestrian space.
- Many footpaths are either absent, encroached upon, or poorly maintained.
- Public spaces are increasingly prioritised for vehicles instead of pedestrians.
- This trend negatively affects road safety, public health, and quality of life.
Best Online Coaching for UPSC
Supreme Court Judgment (2026)
Maniyar Ilyas & Others v. P. A. In (2026)
Key Observations
The Supreme Court held that:
- The right to walk safely on demarcated footpaths is a Fundamental Right.
- States and Union Territories must formulate policies to ensure safe pedestrian infrastructure.
- Cities should be designed primarily for people, not merely for vehicles.
Constitutional Basis
Article 19(1)(d)
- Guarantees the Right to Move Freely throughout the territory of India.
Article 21
- Guarantees the Right to Life and Personal Liberty.
- The Court reiterated that the right to life includes the right to live with dignity, which requires safe and accessible public spaces.
Walking as a Public Health Measure
Walking is not merely a mode of transport; it is also an important public health intervention.
WHO Physical Activity Profile (2024)
- Around 49.4% of Indian adults do not meet the recommended level of physical activity.
- Approximately 57.2% of women fail to achieve recommended activity levels.
- Nearly 74% of children and adolescents are insufficiently physically active.
WHO Recommendation
- Every adult should perform at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity physical activity per week.
Walking to schools, workplaces, bus stops, and metro stations can significantly contribute towards achieving this target.
Health Benefits of Walking
Regular walking helps in:
- Reducing the risk of diabetes.
- Controlling hypertension.
- Preventing obesity.
- Reducing the incidence of fatty liver disease.
- Improving cardiovascular health.
- Enhancing mental well-being.
- Improving joint mobility and insulin sensitivity.
Road Safety Concerns
Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (Road Accidents in India, 2024)
- Pedestrians and two-wheeler users account for nearly 67% of total road accident deaths.
National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB)
- Approximately 60% of road accident fatalities involve pedestrians and two-wheeler riders.
Why Are Pedestrians More Vulnerable?
- Lack of dedicated walking infrastructure forces pedestrians onto roads.
- Collisions between fast-moving vehicles and pedestrians often result in severe injuries or fatalities.
- Poor lighting, unsafe crossings, and speeding further aggravate the risk.
UPSC Online Coaching
Balancing the Rights of Street Vendors and Pedestrians
- Street Vendors Act, 2014: Ensure legal recognition, livelihood protection, and designated vending zones while safeguarding pedestrian movement.
- Balanced Urban Planning: Provide unobstructed footpaths for pedestrians, designated vending zones for vendors, planned parking for vehicles, and utility corridors for essential services.
- Inclusive Urban Spaces: Balance livelihood rights with the Right to Walk through equitable and people-centric city planning.
Measures for Citizens
- Adopt Walking as a Habit: Walk regularly, especially after meals, and aim for 30 minutes daily.
- Choose Active Mobility: Prefer walking for short trips (<1 km) and combine walking with public transport.
- Promote Community Participation: Join community walking groups to encourage healthier lifestyles.
- Prioritise Health & Safety: Seek medical advice if walking causes persistent discomfort or breathing difficulties.
Measures for Government
- Improve Urban Infrastructure: Develop safe footpaths, cycling tracks, and adopt universal accessibility standards in all urban projects.
- Strengthen Traffic Enforcement: Impose strict penalties for illegal parking and effectively remove footpath encroachments.
- Develop Priority Pedestrian Zones: Prioritise schools, hospitals, markets, metro stations, and public transport hubs for pedestrian-friendly infrastructure.
- Promote Active Mobility: Launch a National Active Mobility Mission integrating urban planning, transport, public health, and climate action.
- Adopt Walkability-Based Performance Indicators: Evaluate cities using walkable streets, pedestrian infrastructure quality, accessibility, road safety, and Walkability Index, rather than only flyovers and road expansion.
Significance for India
Developing pedestrian-friendly cities will:
- Improve public health outcomes.
- Reduce road accident fatalities.
- Promote inclusive urban development.
- Support climate change mitigation by reducing dependence on private vehicles.
- Improve the ease of living in urban areas.
- Contribute towards achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), particularly SDG 3 (Good Health and Well-being), SDG 11 (Sustainable Cities and Communities), and SDG 13 (Climate Action).
Challenges
- Rapid Motorisation: Rising private vehicle ownership has increased congestion, while vehicle-centric planning has reduced space for pedestrians and cyclists.
- Weak Enforcement Against Encroachments: Illegal parking and footpath encroachments force pedestrians onto roads, increasing accident risks.
- Poor Pedestrian Infrastructure: Lack of continuous, accessible, and well-maintained footpaths limits safe mobility, especially for the elderly and persons with disabilities.
- Limited Institutional Coordination: Poor coordination among urban planning authorities, municipal bodies, and transport agencies leads to fragmented implementation.
- Inadequate Financial Resources: Limited funding for pedestrian infrastructure and a bias towards roads and flyovers hinder walkability improvements.
- Low Public Awareness: Limited awareness of walkability, road safety, and pedestrian rights discourages safe and active mobility.
Click to Explore UPSC Offline Coaching
Way Forward
- People-Centric Urban Planning: Design cities that prioritise people over vehicles, making pedestrian safety and accessibility the core of urban development.
- Promote Walking & Cycling: Integrate safe, continuous footpaths and dedicated cycling tracks into all city master plans.
- Effective Implementation of the Street Vendors Act, 2014: Develop designated vending zones while ensuring unobstructed pedestrian movement.
- Improve Public Transport & Last-Mile Connectivity: Expand public transport with safe walking infrastructure connecting metro stations, bus stops, markets, schools, and residential areas.
- Conduct Walkability Audits: Regularly assess footpaths, crossings, lighting, accessibility, and pedestrian safety for all major urban projects.
- Pedestrian-First Urban Spaces: Shift from vehicle-centric planning to safe, inclusive, and sustainable mobility by recognising pedestrians as the primary users of public spaces.